Matthew Martin
Google
An Absolute Gem in Old Metairie - Consistently a 5-Star Experience!
I've visited Barcar more times than I can count, and I can say without a shred of doubt that it is one of the most consistently excellent establishments in the entire New Orleans area. Whether I'm looking for a sophisticated spot to impress a client, a lively place to take out-of-town visitors, or just a perfect night out for myself, Barcar always exceeds expectations. It has truly become my go-to spot for any and every occasion.
Let's start with the food and drinks, which are always impeccable. I have to specifically mention the Crispy Tuna Rice. I order it every single time I walk through the door; it's an absolute flavor explosion and a texture masterpiece. It's that one dish I dream about! When I bring clients, we always start with a platter of their incredibly fresh raw oysters, which are a perfect taste of the Gulf. And if you happen to be there for steak night, you are in for an absolute treat—the quality rivals any high-end steakhouse in the city. To top it all off, they serve, hands down, the best Espresso Martini in town. It's perfectly balanced, rich, and gives you that perfect little kick. It's a non-negotiable part of my Barcar ritual.
The atmosphere is another major draw. The main dining area is chic yet incredibly welcoming, striking that perfect balance between upscale and comfortable. But the real star for a vibrant evening is the lively rooftop bar. It has such an energetic vibe without ever feeling chaotic. Even when it's bustling, the service remains top-notch, which is a true testament to their well-managed team.
However, what truly elevates Barcar from a great restaurant to an extraordinary one is the staff. The service is, in a word, amazing. I have to give a huge shout-out to the incredible team that makes every visit so memorable. Peyton, Dee, Al, and Ashton are absolute professionals. They are attentive, knowledgeable, and genuinely seem to enjoy what they do. They operate like a well-oiled machine, ensuring your glass is never empty and your needs are always met with a smile.
And then there's the lovely Joanna, who is my absolute favorite! Joanna is the heart and soul of hospitality. She has a way of making you feel like the most important person in the room. Her warmth, genuine kindness, and impeccable service are what I look forward to just as much as the food. She remembers your preferences and always goes that extra mile to ensure your experience is nothing short of perfect. People like Joanna are the reason you become a loyal, lifelong customer.
In short, Barcar has it all: a fantastic menu, a killer atmosphere, and a team that provides some of the best service I've ever experienced. Thank you to the entire staff, especially Peyton, Dee, Al, Ashton, and the wonderful Joanna, for making this my favorite spot in Old Metairie. 5 stars, without a doubt!