JJ D.
Yelp
Update: The nice folks at Barcelona Wine Bar invited us back for a dinner on them. We visited on a weekend in November with open minds and a hungry appetite. We were really looking forward to seeing new improvements and wanted to take more of their recommendations into consideration. However, after our night, we stand by our original review with a few caveats (see the "Overall").
Food: To start, we shared a Quieto 2020 - an Argentinian red wine recommended by our server. No complaints here: a full-bodied, warm start to the dinner. For the first round of tapas, we ordered the Whipped Sheep's Cheese, Butternut Squash Montadito, and Collard Greens. The Sheep's Cheese was one of the dishes we enjoyed last time, and it did not disappoint! The Montadito and Collard Greens were fine - they were both fairly one-note and did not impress us.
Our second round consisted of the Chorizo with Sweet & Sour Figs, Brussels Sprouts, and Gambas Al Ajillo. The Chorizo had an interesting, almost leathery, texture and had a harsh, barbecue-like sauce that overwhelmed our palettes. The Gambas were 5 medium-sized, juicy shrimps with below average seasoning and no discernable characteristics. The Brussels Sprouts, however, were seasoned very well and might've been the peak of our night - definitely our favorite.
We then got the Braised Pork Ribs and Pulpo Gallego. The 3 ribs had a good bark to them, but we thought the sauce was too prominent, overly sweet, and tangy. The Pulpo Gallego was a spiced acidic mess -- it reminded us of Limón Takis, which we like as a chip snack but not so much as the main flavor of an octopus tapas. Additionally, the potatoes thrown in didn't add much to elevate the dish.
For large dishes, we ordered the Chicken Pimientos and Paella Mariscos. We had high hopes for the Chicken Pimientos, but we were disappointed to find that the sauce was overly salty and acidic without much complexity. The chicken, though juicy, genuinely tasted like it was only seasoned with salt. The Paella Mariscos was packed with fresh, delicious seafood, but the dish overall was underseasoned and lacking a special umph to make it worthwhile.
We ended our night with the Olive Oil Cake and Basque Burnt Cheesecake for dessert. The Olive Oil Cake was surprisingly rich and dense -- almost too heavy for us to finish. The Cheesecake was grainy and didn't have the classic creaminess of a basque burnt cheesecake.
Overall: We believe in second chances and improvements; however, this redux ultimately reflects the same notes of our previous experience. We realized that no dish had us thinking "we need to come back for x," the only exception maybe being the Brussels Sprouts, but priced at $9 we have our hesitations. We ordered a diverse set of tapas per our server's recommendations and our interests. The common throughline in many of the dishes was either: "it's too salty/sweet/acidic," "it's bland or boring," or "it's fine but not worth the price." We were very appreciative of our servers and the attentive managers throughout our dining experience, but when it comes to these dishes, no amount of flashy presentation or authentic-sounding labels could overshadow the lacking feeling of being satisfied with the plates from both flavor and price standpoints. Are there some people out there that might really enjoy this experience? Undoubtedly yes, since the ambiance and variety of options may make for a memorable dinner, but as for us, we'll just have to chop it up to a difference in tastes and values.