Lan S.
Yelp
Bargello has Asheville's best cacio e pepe. This deceptively simple dish (I know -- I've tried and failed to make it properly a number of times) uses just four or five items -- pasta, peppercorns, Pecorino and/or Parmesan Reggiano cheese, olive oil and salt.
Prepared properly, it is wonderful, and that's exactly how it is a Bargello, the Hotel Arras' main restaurant. Bargello (pronounced bar-jello) uses a thick spaghetti. The menu says bucatini, which has a small hole in the oversize spaghetti strands. (Some use spaghettoni, a large spaghetti without the hole, instead.) This is absolutely the best cacio e pepe ($17) in Western North Carolina and better than some I've had in Roma.
Our first course was seafood -- the grilled octopus with apple and fennel salad and charred potatoes ($16), which makes an excellent starter or antipasto.
With my cacio e pepe my companion had the Maiale pizza ($16, personal size) from the brick hearth oven. This was fine, but not exceptional. We wouldn't come back for the pizza.
The high-ceiling dining room is pleasant, and service on a fairly slow night was excellent. Our cocktails and wine were good. Cocktails were mostly $12 to $15, with wine by the glass from $9, local craft beers $7. The tab for two including tax and tip came to about $135.