Allie E.
Yelp
Celebrated our anniversary a little early with a night in Columbia, including dinner at Barred Owl! This spot came recommended and did not disappoint - solid bar menu, cozy vibe, and delicious food!
We started at the bar while waiting for a table; we did not have a reservation, but dined in on a week night (so assumed it would be slightly less busy than a weekend). It was going to be 10-15 for a table, but the hostess said we could sit at the bar and grab a drink until a table was ready.
The bar was gorgeous to look at (made a great photo back drop!) and the menu was extensive! Lots of wine options - bottle and glass, basically any classic cocktail, and a selection of speciality cocktails. I had the pitter patter - a seasonal drink that seemed to be a play on a whiskey smash with citrus/egg white twist. It was fabulous! My husband had an old fashioned. He asked the bartender for his bourbon recs - he knows his preferences, but loves seeing what others recommend. He ended up with a four roses select. We definitely would have had a good time just staying at the bar and chatting with the bar tender.
We did get seated fairly quickly after our drinks were served and took in the menu. It was different than online, but some amazing looking choices. We opted to share a few things, picking an app, a small plate, and an entree. Our waitress had it brought out in phases rather than all at once, which we appreciated.
Our appetizer was the milk and honey rolls. The bread was fresh, with a good crust on the outside and soft and warm inside. The fresh butter was perfection on the toasty buns, and the honey butter was easily our favorite. Our next course was the gnudi, a cheese dumpling (fancy cheese curd) and was delicious with the autumn sauce and balsamic drizzle. Our main was a porterhouse; it was so tender with a good bit of seasoning to the outside. It was served with some potato, peppers, and a few slices of sausage. We also had a side of the mac and cheese because we can't resist anything with Hemme Brother's cheese. Overall this was a perfect amount of food for us!
Ended up splitting a dessert, which was an eggnog creme brulee. It was so good, with the flavor notes of eggnog without tasting like straight eggnog - which is the impression we got from the menu (my husband doesn't like eggnog, but liked this). It also had two sugar cookies on top - a little 'bonus' dessert!
Overall an amazing space and a delicious meal! They had colorful lights strung up for the holidays that added a fun bit of cheer to the space. Our server didn't check in a ton most of the meal - there were several larger parties - but we also didn't mind as we were enjoying an anniversary date. There was hardly an empty table the entire time we were there. With bar seating, and groups of 2 up to 10, it seemed to be a popular spot. Seemed to be a small patio too, which would be fun in warm weather!