Barrotta’s Supper Club

My wife Crystelle and I were finally able to celebrate our 21st wedding anniversary and me being cancer free after my successful Whipple surgery procedure in March got in the way. I feel like I have been given a 2nd chance on life and so glad we were able to enjoy a live jazz band while indulging in the delicious flavors at Barrotta's Supper Club. Why travel to NYC when you can have a better experience right here in the heart of Huntington Village. The food was delicious, drinks were amazing, and the service and ambiance were outstanding. So much food we had to bring it home. Mike and Fabio were super nice and generous and made us feel like family. We highly recommend Barrotta's for a romantic evening or just a night out with friends or family. Tell em Joe sent you!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A truly unforgettable experience! We celebrated my father’s birthday at Barrotta’s Supper Club and I honestly can’t say enough about how special they made it. From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel welcome and taken care of; it was clear they genuinely cared. Every detail was thoughtful and polished, and the entire evening felt like a celebration of family, food, and good living. The drinks? Incredible. Perfectly crafted cocktails that hit the spot. The food? Delectable. Every dish was beautifully plated and absolutely delicious! truly five-star quality. And the live jazz music in the background added such warmth and energy to the room. It was classy without being stuffy, it was really elegant and cozy. Barrotta’s went above and beyond for our family, and we left with full hearts (and full stomachs!). Highly recommend for anyone looking to celebrate a special occasion or just treat yourself to an exceptional night out! We’ll absolutely be back! Thank you!

Barrotta’s Supper Club is an absolute culinary gem. From the moment the appetizers hit the table, we knew we were in for something special. The Burrata, paired with roasted tomato jam and fresh greens, was rich, creamy, and perfectly balanced. But the real standout starter? The meatballs—so tender they melt in your mouth, swimming in a sauce that could rival (and beat) any beloved family recipe. Dinner continued to impress. The lobster ravioli was hands down the best I’ve ever had—overflowing with fresh, perfectly cooked lobster. It wasn’t just the best ravioli I’ve had—it was the best lobster I’ve ever tasted. The truffle Cacio e pepe was another surprise: delicate, rich, and expertly done without the usual overpowering truffle oil. Even the Brussels sprouts were a revelation. Exceptional food is hard to find, and Barrotta’s delivers it with service to match—warm, attentive, and truly rare these days. If I could give this place a Michelin star myself, I would. A must-visit for any serious foodie.

Barrotta’s Supper Club 📍Huntington, NY @barrottasupperclub Barrotta’s Supper Club is one of our favorite intimate restaurants for date night! It is truly a special spot, and a must visit location when in the Huntington area!. The ambiance is cozy and sophisticated, giving it a perfect exclusive feel to it, and the live jazz performance adds the perfect touch. Everything on this menu is executed amazingly from their top tier crab cakes, lobster ravioli, and beef Wellington. Even down to their sides that are prepared deliciously, assuring that every bite here is as good as the last. The cocktails are fresh and full of flavor. We love it here and we know you will to! Follow us on Instagram at @drinklongislandny for the full video and much more reviews from spots all across Long Island!

We hosted my sister’s “Casino Royale” 30th birthday party at Barrotta’s Supper Club, and it was an absolute 100/10 experience! We completely transformed the upstairs party space to fit her speakeasy-vibe vision, and it turned out even better than we imagined. The food was phenomenal—Barrotta’s pasta, chicken parm, meatballs (YUM!), and Caesar salad had everyone going back for seconds. The staff was beyond helpful from start to finish, assisting with setup (even bringing in boxes for us!) and handling breakdown and cleanup with ease. As hosts, the entire night was stress-free, and our guests couldn’t stop raving about the space. The ambiance, the service, the energy—unmatched! We also hired DJ RARI, one of their recommended DJs, and he absolutely KILLED it. We danced all night long! Can’t wait to come back for dinner downstairs during one of their live jazz nights. Huge shoutout to Paul and Olivia for helping bring the whole evening together—you two are amazing! If you're looking for an upscale, welcoming venue with incredible food and service, Barrotta’s is it!

I cannot recommend Barrotta Supper Club ENOUGH! Our experience was exemplary! Upon walking in to the restaurant, we were immediately greeted by the sweetest Manager Paul who seated us in seconds! The ambiance was STELLAR. It was so intimate, the musician playing was fantastic, it was perfect for our usual date nights. Our server Nick was impeccable, I literally could bat my eye the other way and he came to check in on us! Onto drinks and dinner: The bartender Adrienne really knows how to mix a great cocktail. The citrus & bloom, as well as the My cousin's old fashion were made to perfection. For food we were given amuse which is so cool it changes everyday. It was a croquette style potato with a horseradish crema. After we tried that, we knew we were about to have an amazing meal. We ordered the street corn salad, the meatballs (that were melt in your mouth!) For entrees we had the truffle caccio e pepe - no exaggeration the BEST Ive ever had, as well as the cordon bleu which was amazing to me because it was made with BRIE! The dessert was an apple crumb alla mode that was super fresh and flavorful. Chef Tyriek & his team truly mastered EVERY single dish on the menu. Its really rare to find a restaurant that hits all the marks. Impeccable service, delectable food & great vibes. I haven't stopped talking about this restaurant to all of my friends and family. You wont regret checking them out! THANKS FOR READING. Best of luck to Barrotta Supper Club & the phenomenal staff. We look forward to seeing you guys again soon. All the best, Krystle T! @pharmfoodieLI

Incredible new spot in Huntington! Went for dinner with close friends on a Friday night. 4-course pre fixe menu with wonderful options! The artichoke heart starter was amazing. Crab cakes were to die for. The cacio e pepe bucatini was so incredible , highly recommend. My friends also enjoyed the salmon with zucchini (they say it was the best zucchini ever), and beef Wellington cooked to perfection. Finally, the dessert cheesecake was light and had a delicious chocolate dipped cookie underneath that paired so well with the berries on top. On top of that, service was top notch. Waiter was lovely, wine and water was refilled immediately, and the atmosphere itself was upscale. Listening to live jazz all night was the cherry on top of it all. Great band. Thank you , and will be back!

Barrotta's is doing it right! Came in for dinner on a Friday, we were seated immediatly. The food was delicious! Portion sizes were very generous and the cocktails were some of the best I have had in a long time. Service was on point as well as the band! Where else can you catch live Jazz and a great meal for the price? Looking forward to my next reservation, don't walk, run to Barrotta's!