Brad H.
Yelp
The meat is 4, 5 stars, very tasty and good BBQ.
Love how they have done the place. The inside is conducive for visiting with friends. The new outdoor patio is spacious and awesome. The four or five smokers in the meat smoking area is huge. Nice vibe.
This is a "go down the line" type of place where you place your order and like Panda Express or Jersey Mike's, you go down as they assemble your order telling them what sides you want, etc.
I had the Bashful Tray with two meats, three sides, half sour pickle and a non-existent smoked crack pie, whatever that is. I had brisket and pork ribs. Cost me $45. My wife had the smoked chicken plate. My Yelp friends also had plates with brisket or pork ribs. His rib plate came with only three ribs. For $23 bucks, that's not much. He was still hungry at the end. Like I said, the meats were very good. I would rate it just a tad shy good of Ken's Hardwood BBQ, which is the best BBQ in Tucson in my opinion. Just shy. They were all very delicious.
Why only 3 stars? First, the sides were not good. I had the Borracho Beans (eh, didn't finish), the Dill Potato Salad (also didn't finish), and the Sunflower Crunch Salad (yep, didn't finish). Just something about the flavors. Turns out that the Sunflower Crunch Salad is coleslaw. When you eat BBQ, the sides have to be good to complement the meat. It's part of the reason you have BBQ. Ken's Hardwood BBQ had great sides to go with their great meat. This was really not that good at all. And both my Yelp friends' mac and cheese was cold. OK, they're new and working out the bugs. But they were definitely underwhelmed with the mac and cheese. And I passed on it because it didn't look creamy. I like my mac and cheese on the creamy side. This was on the sticky side. One star docked.
Now a word about their BBQ sauces. The "OG BBQ and Chiltepin are good. The House and Molé not so much. None of us liked those two. The flavors just didn't work, especially the molé. You have to have good sauce to go with BBQ meat. I mean BBQ is just an excuse to have BBQ sauce, right? Half a star docked.
So after I was finished eating, I realized I didn't get my Smoked Cracked Pie. I inquired on this and was told they were all out and that I was given extra to compensate. Really? I wasn't told this and what, exactly, was I given "extra?" I just now figured it out writing this review and looking at the menu again--I got a whole pickle instead of a half of one! Wow. I feel so compensated LOL. I got an extra half of pickle instead of a slice of pie. Would have been better if they had told me this when I was forking out the $45 for this menu item. Maybe I could have asked for a little extra side or something (which I wouldn't finish). I'm spending $45 for a meal here, you could tell me when I'm paying that you were out of the pie. You should have 1) told me, 2) then suggest a substitute, like maybe comp my fountain drink or something. Lame. And I love pickles, but I only took three bites of this one. I didn't like it. Half a star docked.
I wish I had read the menu more carefully. I got the $45 tray because I wanted to try two meats. If you get the plate for $17 - $23, for $$25 you can get double meat. I should have done that and save me a wad of money. Especially since they were out of the pie. Which I wasn't old.
So my final verdict is definitely try it out. Nice vibe at the restaurant. The meats are very good. Two of the sauces are good. You might be different than I am and like their sides. You might be able to try this "Smoked Crack Pie." The people are friendly. What they have is someone who knows how to smoke meats. They need a chef to create edible sides. I'll just be sticking to Ken's.
5* = A top favorite. Mind-blowing good. I will definitely return and I will go out of my way to go here. Worth every dime of my money.
4* = Outstanding. Tucson-top-tier. Some elements not quite as good as it gets, but it still is worthy of my regular business.
3* = Good experience. I might do repeat business if it is convenient, the only option, the only one in its category, or on a whim, but would not be among the first thing to come to mind. Would definitely recommend you trying it to get your own take on it.
2* = Not so good. Would not recommend at all. Waste of money.
1* = How are they still in business? Stay away at all costs!