Erin S.
Yelp
This was my second time at Bay Street Biergarten.
This is my review for our most recent time, 1/1/2021: We had a party of 7 on a Friday night. There was no wait to sit outside. The service was good. Our waiter wore a mask.
There were a couple things we ordered from the menu that they just didn't have, like the Biergarten Cobb Salad and Santa's Cookies.
None of the entrees come with sides. For food, we recommend:
- Smash Burger ($9)
- Sweet Potato Fries ($4)
- Tots ($4)
- Shrimp Roll ($15) - good, but expensive
- Biergarten Pretzel ($9)
We feel neutral about/don't recommend:
- Cheese Steak ($13) - if there was cheese, we couldn't taste it
- Brussels Sprouts with Stout Vinegar ($4) - they were breaded, which was not clear on the menu
- Fall Harvest Salad with Chicken ($13+$6) - it was okay, not spectacular
For drinks, we got:
- Holly Jolly ($9) - tasted like medicine, don't recommend
- One Cool Cat ($12) - refreshing, good
- Cabernet Sauvignon ($7) - it was decent
- Wild Bramble Sour from Southern Barrel ($7) - very good
- John Beere from Tradesman ($7) - tasted like beer
- Summer Lovin' ($12) - good
Overall, it's a cool ambiance. The outside is cute with the cafe lighting. The food could use some improvement. The service was good. We would go back.
This was my review from 3/31/19, pre-Covid: Went for Backstreet Boys Brunch! The throwbacks were SO fun! Highly recommend checking out their 90s-themed brunches!
The service was pretty terrible--it took 20+ minutes just to get menus. We had made a reservation, but when we got there, they said they didn't take reservations for their themed brunches. So they need to get that worked out.
Food was good! Larger than Life mimosas were awesome. Would definitely go back for their themed brunches!