Sally F.
Yelp
Beautiful atmosphere, but not the most attentive staff / hosts, especially for special occasions. For that, I wouldn't recommend, as I've seen a few reviews complaining about the same thing. We came here for our anniversary with a reservation and no one said anything or did anything until the host validated our ticket as we left and added "happy anniversary" like an afterthought. This was not a busy day either, so I was disappointed by the overall lack of attention. However, the food was amazing, but again, I'm not sure I'd be back to celebrate anything again. Breakdown below:
Ambiance (4/5): Very classy in there. Although spacious, it felt cozy at the same time. We loved the books on the wall and the chandeliers that hung down from the high ceiling. We came on a sleepy afternoon 4:30 pm reservation on a Monday (Presidents' Day) since we were out of town and didn't want to be out too late with little ones. There weren't too many parties in there during our time there through 6 PM or so, yet the hostess seated us off to the side and I had to ask if we could move the the table literally to the left by the library wall just for better photos since it was our anniversary. She didn't even acknowledge at that point with a simple "happy anniversary," which I thought was weird. Was it because we weren't too dressed up since we were out all day at Pretend City with our kids? Who knows.
Service (2/5): It wasn't a busy afternoon but they didn't come over to our side too often. Many just hung around the bar/prep area chatting. The hostess was on her phone a lot. I get it, but by 6 pm as we wanted to leave, it took a long time for someone to come by to grab our check; I had to stare at their general direction until the host saw me (it was young man by then; I think there was a shift change). Again, this was for our anniversary and the general lack of attention during the dining experience and zero acknowledgment about our special occasion until the end as we validated to leave admittedly just left a bitter taste in my mouth. It might have been the change in hosts, but the first hostess should have said something or I think they need to do a better job of communicating things like that.
Food (4/5 overall): If it was any redeeming factor, it was the food. We loved every bite. Our picky toddler and our little 11 month-old enjoyed their food too. We ordered the Bucatini, Ribeye with Chimichurri, and the Black Sheep burger with fries. Breakdown below:
* Bucatini (3.5/5): The Bucatini was creamy and tart, which I actually loved, as it reminded me of my favorite Greek lemon and chicken soup. The pork bits went really well with the dish. The portion is on the smaller side, but it's so rich, almost greasy, you probably want to eat it with something else anyway.
* Ribeye (5/5): It was juicy, flavorful, and overall well seasoned. It went really well with the pomme purée (which my toddler devoured) and the asparagus was perfectly cooked. Chimichurri sauce complemented it well. This was my favorite dish.
*Black Sheep Burger (3.5/5): The burger was interesting. It was sweet, slightly bitter, but overall pleasing. The combination of the sweet bacon(?) bits and cheese and greens made for a unique flavor. We enjoyed it because it was different. The fries were a little overdone, but the flavor was fine.
Maybe we came on an off day, and maybe I was regretful we came here to celebrate. However, at least the food was good and the ambiance was good? Will we be back? Maybe, maybe not.