Doug B.
Yelp
Benny and Mary's is located on the corner of Von Karman Ave and Michelson Drive in Irvine. There is a paid parking lot right across from the restaurant, and they will validate your parking stub at the host stand.
We were in the area for another activity and happened to arrive around 3:30pm, so we sat in the bar area to take advantage of their happy hour which runs from 2pm to 6pm. The bar area is bright with a lot of windows, and we had a nice sunny view of palm trees and the fountain outside. There is also patio seating outside. The main dining room is spacious with high ceilings, and there is a lot of light from windows on the walls and skylights above.
We started out with an appetizer and a round of cocktails.
The Goat Cheese Tomato Crostini ($12 during happy hour, normally $17) comes with a good sized scoop of goat cheese and had a good tang. The tomato pesto sauce was good, but this appetizer definitely needs to come with more bread. Our server was happy to bring us another plate of toasted bread.
I had the Adult Green Juice cocktail (Gin, Mezcal, Lime, Lemon, Pineapple, Cucumber, Ginger, Dill, Celery Bitters, Angostura Bitters, $16). It is served old-fashioned style with a large ice cube. The smokiness of the mezcal was at a good light to medium level. It was light and refreshing with some complexity. The cucumber and ginger flavors stood out to me.
She had the Hibis-Kiss cocktail (Citrus Vodka, Framboise, Hibiscus, Strawberry, Pineapple, Lemon, topped with Brut Rose, $16). It was refreshing with a light sweetness and we mostly tasted strawberry and a little pineapple. It has a light bubbly finish.
Next came entrees and a final round of cocktails.
I had the Ribeye sandwich ($23). The meat was cooked medium and thin sliced. It had good flavor and wasn't chewy at all. The added cheese, mushrooms, onion strings, and arugula made it a very tasty sandwich. It was also very filling as I only ate half and took the rest home. The fries were hot and crispy the way I love them. I would definitely order this again in lieu of a regular dinner entrée.
She ordered the Mediterranean Chopped Salad and added shrimp ($15 + $12). It looked good, but as soon as the bowl was set down, we smelled a strong fishy odor coming from the shrimp. She cut one of the shrimp in half and it was undercooked. She sent it back, and they took it off the bill. She didn't care to order anything else.
My final cocktail was their off-menu take on a gimlet with cucumber ($16). It was light and refreshing and had some unexpected sweetness. The bartender said the sweetness was coming from the house made cucumber syrup. It was good, but a little too similar to my first drink, and I probably should have ordered something else.
Her last cocktail was the Snake Oil (Blanco Tequila, Lillet Blanc, Lime, Grapefruit, Spicy Grapefruit Cordial, $16). It had a nice grapefruit flavor, but we didn't get any of the spiciness.
Jamie was our bartender and server. He was friendly and provided good service.
The shrimp on the salad was a big miss, but everything else was good. We will probably return again to try some other menu items.