Benny's Café
Family restaurant · Clayton Crest ·

Benny's Café

Family restaurant · Clayton Crest ·

Breakfast, burgers, Italian-Albanian entrees, and cocktails

Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null
Benny's Café by null

Information

5354 S 27th St, Milwaukee, WI 53221 Get directions

$10–20

Order delivery
See Menu

Information

Static Map

5354 S 27th St, Milwaukee, WI 53221 Get directions

+1 414 431 0004
bennyscafemilwaukee1.com
@bennys_cafe_mke

$10–20 · Menu

Features

wifi
payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Nov 26, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater
390,870 Postcards · 10,986 Cities

Crowds Pack Colleyville Restaurants After Mayor Reopens Patios | Eater Dallas

"I observed that Benny’s Cafe had lines and full patios over the weekend, and photos suggested many patrons there were not maintaining social distancing or wearing face coverings." - Amy McCarthy

https://dallas.eater.com/2020/4/27/21237759/colleyville-restaurant-patios-crowded-after-mayor-allows-restaurants-open
Benny's Café

Keith M.

Google
Just up the street from my car dealer and an oil change, we did a u-turn to go back for breakfast. Good thing, the food was great, staff was attentive. Definitely going to return next time we're driving by!

R. M.

Google
When I walked into Benny's Cafe I was greeted by a server with a warm smile and the scent of freshly brewed coffee filled the air. The menu has many options including salads, wraps, breakfast skillets, omelettes and even a fish fry on Fridays! The booth and entire Cafe looked clean and the atmosphere was pleasant. I had a skillet and it was served over American fries (which are hard to find in diners I've been to) the eggs were fluffy and it tasted delicious. We also got a fresh egg dish served with 3 eggs, bacon, ham and sausage. The over easy eggs were cooked perfectly and the ham was a generous thick piece. The pancakes were fluffy and golden served with warm syrup. Everything tasted great. I would definitely recommend you come try out Benny's Cafe for breakfast, lunch or dinner! I know I am definitely coming back to try more items myself!

Robin P.

Google
Clean and comfortable. No frills. Exactly what a classic diner should feel like. Great food. Kind service. Classic menu choices that include the sides and drinks to make a lovely dining experience.

Mary E

Google
Friendly and efficient staff, quick service, delicious food. We had a very large group, waitress did a spectacular job, chefs too. Cream of mushroom soup was delicious!

Adrienne T.

Google
This place definitely has its regular costumers and I can see why. Staff is friendly, service is quick and food is good. Came here for a mom and daughter breakfast during the week. We love our bacon extra crispy!

D D.

Google
I expected better but being understaffed led to mediocre fish dinners being cold and long waits for any service. Waitress was running and out of breath so we still left nice tip. Side of corned beef hash for $7.50 tasted like microwaved canned. Soup was good, but I'll pass for a return trip. I feel sorry for the wait staff.

Keith W.

Google
Every time we go there we have a good meal. We always get very good service. And they have a good atmosphere. Very nice and welcoming place I would recommend Benny's Cafe

Turea M.

Google
Benny’s Cafe was good! I was waiting on an oil change and needed to walk somewhere close to grab food. I saw this place had great reviews, and went with them! The server was extremely nice and the food came out extremely fast, not just to me but to other tables as well. The food was good too, I ordered the 2 pancakes, 2 eggs, and 2 pieces of bacon. I would come back again.