Big Gay Sal's Pizza

I really hate to say this….. but I was disappointed. 😔 I got a medium BYO pizza w/ extra cheese & pepperoni & garlic sticks. The garlic sticks were cut in to really, really tiny pieces for some reason? Both items were pretty underwhelming in my opinion— they could’ve used a lot more flavor. The pictures make it look so good though! Bummer! (I ordered delivery)

I stayed the night at the bed and breakfast next door to this place and they were able to deliver right to my room. The pizza was excellent with a nice chew to the crust and the margarita was delicious and perfectly boozy! Definitely highly recommend checking this place out if you’re in the area.

Very disappointed. Stopped by and had a slice of cheese (was alright) but I also ordered a Tres Leches cake and it was very bad. It did not taste like a Tres Leches cake at all, and had the consistency and taste of a caramel candy (very tough and chewy, not cakey). Would not recommend.

We came here after a night drinking, and it was just what we needed. Staff were really friendly. They have some TVs and a bar. Would definitely come back.

First of all - I need to, personally thank - big gay sals- for helping my former league - Cmsa women’s+softball with sponsorship 2nd - your pizza is as scrumptious as your new Wednesday night Loteria! Love is love, yo and there is def love here -

First time in and had a horrible experience. Came in and ordered with someone. We waited and he got his 12” pizza after 25 minutes. I had ordered a 10” veggie pizza and fries right after. 10 minutes after he got his pizza, my fries came out. The server goes “hope you enjoy and yall got everything”. I did not get my pizza and mentioned it to him. He looked confused and puzzled. It was clear that it was forgotten. Another 10/15 minutes went by and my pizza finally came out. It looked strange but took a bite. When I tell you the dough was not cooked all the way, the veggies were all raw, and the cheese was warm at best. It was clear it was rushed after it was forgotten. At this point I was upset and more upset that they didn’t acknowledge the mess up and tried to cover it up with a rushed pile of raw veggies. I had to take the rest home and finish cooking it myself. Not a great first impression and probably won’t be back. I should also note that it wasn’t busy inside.

Take it from me, born and raised Brooklyn pizza snob. Sal’s is legit! Right ovens, perfect sauce to cheese ratio. Good ingredients. NO cornmeal. And just an all round wonderful place. This will be my go to when in Chicago.

The new recipe is SOOO good. I knew I had to try it asap as soon as it was announced they changed the crust and the sauce. The last recipe’s crust was not great and honestly kept me from wanting to frequent. However, Sal has listened to customer feedback, invested in a new recipe and honestly it is delicious. Will be back lots more!

I went here last night on my way home from a Sunday Funday. The staff was incredibly friendly! Like from the moment I walked over the threshold they shouted out greetings and were just super nice. I stuck with a basic slice of cheese. The Pizza was tasty and exactly what I wanted. One of the partners was working the register too and again was super friendly. It's nice to see a locally owned and operated place where service is a tenet. I would definitely go back.

I can't think of a more convivial topper to an evening of debauchery in Boystown than this popular pizza spot on North Halsted. I believe it's only been open for a couple of months, but it already has my favorite neon sign, "Feed Me Pizza and Tell Me I'm Pretty" (photo: https://yelp.to/npSaHeUUpg). The positive vibe comes primarily from the sunny owner whom I presume to be Big Gay Sal. He was smiling behind the counter greeting all the customers. The pizza selection was pretty standard and sold by the slice. A slice was all Jamie W. and I wanted after imbibing one too many vodka slushies at Sidetrack. I had the Pepperoni (photo: https://yelp.to/jrBaVOBOjo) and Jamie had the Vegetarian (photo: https://yelp.to/iVOD4enXFn). Sure, they weren't artisanal masterpieces, but hey, that wasn't our aim at midnight. Besides, when the staff is this friendly, you just want to hang and stay pretty. FOOD - 3.5 stars...familiar pizza slices AMBIANCE - 4.5 stars...very bright space with a lot of seating SERVICE - 5 stars...it starts with Sal TOTAL - 4 stars...I feel pretty, oh so pretty...and it's open until 5PM RELATED - Exploring Chicago? Here's my collection of places I've visited and reviewed: https://bit.ly/44c4CZO

Came here super late on a Saturday (around 3:30am) and fortunately they were open for us. It's getting harder and harder to find late night eateries around this area in a post-pandemic world, but this place that is fairly new came in clutch for us. Staff was friendly (even for that late night hour). We ordered a little pizza and took it home on the train. It was still warm and tasty when we got home. It wasn't a life-changing pizza, but for that hour, anything sufficed. Pizza was still good overall.

I've walked by this place so many times, but I'm glad I finally have it a try. The pizza has the perfect crust to toppings ratio! Pictures don't lie... this pizza is big, delicious, and if you like it, definitely get the jalapenos on top. The mozzarella sticks and cheese bread are perfect to begin with. Although we sat in the back, our waitress was super attentive and we never had to ask for extra of anything. The big neon light in the back is really intriguing, and the seating is ample for you and all of your friends. If you want to try something new in boystown, this is the spot to start at!

Solid slice spot in the heart of Chicago's Boystown neighborhood. They don't yet have alcohol, but indicated it was coming soon! They have a wide variety of slices and I recommend ordering those as an actual pizza takes much longer. Still working though some kinks but food was solid and staff was super friendly!

Exactly what was needed after a night at Roscoes. Tons of options, big slices, friendly staff. And they're not frugal with the parmesan packets. Really met the objective.

Say his name! What's his name? "Big Gay Sal!" If you are out in Boystown aka North Halstead and you are looking for a tasty snack, stop at Big Gay Sals. The pizza is delicious, the drinks be poppin, and the service is impeccable. We have been here 5 times since it opened 2 months ago and everytime the food hits and the drinks are great. Please say "hi" to Claudia, Lady Diana or Sal and whether your a T, a B, or a V you'll love the food here!

Came in late at night on Sunday. Claudia was our server and was phenomenal. She took care of us and made our visit so memorable. Would def recommend and ask for her if you stop in. Will def be telling my friends about it. Good food options, for meat eaters and vegetarians

The food - the crust has not improved since they opened & the toppings are flavorless. Really unsure how hard it is to get pizza this wrong but they need to not focus on the bar & focus on their food

The pizza is amazing. We usually get delivery but the back patio is a sorta hidden gem and the staff is all super friendly.

Went for the first time tonight! Pizza slices are delicious and HUGE. Food came out super fast and the staff could not possibly have been nicer. 10/10 service. The vibe is also really cute. I'll definitely come again. Will probably check out the daily specials and happy hour.

Amazing pizza, refreshing beer, great location, well decorated & clean;; what more can you ask for?!?!

This pizza is legit and it's a cool place to hang out. Service is also top notch. Definitely check this place out

Amazing pizza, open late, great beer, perfect location, clean & well-decorated/cozy spot; what more could you ask for?