Billy's Bakery - Upper West Side

The carrot cake was seriously hyped up on instagram so i was kinda really disappointed that it was just a basic carrot cake. The banana cake was better but still not that great. Both cakes were too dense and a little hard. Their arnold palmer was delicious though definitely recommend that.

First time customer after hearing about Billy’s for years. Thank you for the incredible cake which made my Mom’s 70th Birthday so special! Not only was the cake beautiful, but the party guests were raving about how delicious it was! 10/10 I’m a believer!!

I recently visited here and had a mixed experience. The chocolate cupcake was delightful, boasting a rich and satisfying flavor. The tea selection was extensive, providing plenty of options for tea enthusiasts. However, the latte fell short of expectations.

Super cute little bakery with delicious goods! My son and I shared cheesecake, a cupcake, and a stuffed cookie. All were fantastic with great flavor. Loved the wide variety of cupcakes that were available. Staff was extremely friendly and service was quick. Great atmosphere too!

I recently entrusted Billy’s Bakery to make a very special birthday cake for my partner. The cake in question was a German Chocolate Cake. I do not generally care for German Chocolate Cake due to my aversion to coconut, but I share this info to emphasize exactly how astoundingly delicious our German Chocolate Cake was. My partner absolutely loved the cake; just thrilled. In spite of the fact I do not care for German Chocolate Cake, I devoured nearly half of the cake myself because it was so good I just couldn’t stop eating it; almost like a delicious out-of-body cake devouring experience. If Billy’s can make a type of cake I do not usually care for so astonishingly good that I “accidentally” eat half of it, I can’t wait to experience another cake from here. Don’t hesitate, order anything from this place and you’re going to love it.

Best vegan cupcake I have had in NYC and maybe ever! Had no idea they even had a vegan option, but it was delicious. Not dry and not overly sweet. Hard to find a vegan cupcake that gets the texture right! So good!

Visited this place to pick up birthday cupcakes for my girlfriend. I thought the place lacked energy, enthusiasm, and it didn't have that sparkling feeling that I usually get from bakery. I ordered 6 cupcakes and I asked the representative to add sprinkles and some glare to the cupcakes. The Rep told me "no" we are unable to add it at the time. Not her fault, but I'm thinking if I paid $26 for cupcakes why can't I add sprinkles to it? In addition there is no parking, so be careful with the traffic ticket cops, they are very tricky in this area. The store was clean and relatively spacious, but not quite what I was looking for. Service was so-so. I recommend you order what you you need in advanced.

I happen to be walking in the neighborhood one afternoon. Not knowing this location was here once I saw the sign my mouth dropped and I went straight in. I was greeted by the staff members but also the sweet aroma of goodies surrounding me. They offer a variety of products from cakes, cookies, brownies, cookie sandwiches, pies, cheesecakes, etc. They even offer a vegan cupcake. I'm unsure what other vegan products they offer. My favorite cupcakes are the lemon with cream cheese frosting and the crowd pleaser (chocolate and vanilla cupcake and icing). The cupcakes are moist. However sometimes when buying extra for later then tend to dry out really fast which is a negative for me. The staff was very friendly while assisting me. Next time I'm in the area I know where I can stop if I want a sweet treat. They only accept card. Nearby public transportation.