Anna C.
Google
Do not order custom cookies here. The biggest mistake of my wedding weekend was ordering cookies here for my rehearsal dinner. I called and spoke to Brianna and discussed in detail what I was looking for. I also sent a follow up email with font inspiration and reiterated the specific instructions for the cookies that we had already discussed on the phone including "I'd prefer all lowercase (ex. "love you" and "love you more")!" and "As minimal as you can go with trying to make it look like a love note rather than having the words taking up the whole cookie!" I will attach the email. I also asked them if they could send me a photo of the first decorated cookie over text, so that I could confirm or ask for adjustments prior to them making the whole batch. They confirmed they could do that, but they never did. If they had, we could have avoided this entire issue entirely.
The cookies cost $400 for 80 and looked genuinely like they were decorated by children. The instructions were disregarded entirely, the letters were capitalized, oversized, and took up nearly the entire cookie. And the color was a weird orangey-yellow (I asked for an Ivory/Cream).. Every person I showed the photos to said they looked like someone slapped Kraft Singles on top and had a toddler write on them with a sharpie.
On the day of my rehearsal dinner (the day before my wedding), I spent two hours going back and forth with them about a resolution. They didn’t offer a refund, and they were hesitant to remake them given the time. When I asked if someone more skilled could come in to redo them, I was told by Brianna, “We have different people working on different days and they all have a different level of skill.” (basically admitting to me that their staff was unskilled). I would be genuinely so embarrassed as a business to present these to a customer. This was such a simple and straightforward request that I'm honestly baffled and so shocked that it was messed up this badly. I continued to ask on the phone as we were speaking in the hours leading up to my rehearsal dinner (what should have been a fun and happy time with friends as I got ready for the best weekend of my life) why this happened, where the miscommunication was, why a text was never sent to me and the answer I got was "the notes you gave me were shared in the groupchat." Okay, why do we not have a more professional means of communication when dealing with $400 orders for important events... Ultimately, a friend had to miss my rehearsal dinner to pick up the remade cookies, because again, no refund was ever offered, and even the second batch was nowhere near the quality you'd expect for $5 cookies.
I was especially disappointed because the San Antonio location made the cookies for my bridal shower, and those were beautiful. These, however, were genuinely awful and caused unnecessary stress during what should have been a joyful weekend.
My husband also mentioned that when he picked up the first batch of cookies, a couple in front of him was there to collect a cake, but they were told that their pick up date was marked down for the next day and did not have the cake made. I don’t know what their cake was for, but seeing another significant mix-up happen right before ours only made the situation feel even more unbelievable. It’s concerning to witness multiple major errors in a single visit.