Gary G.
Yelp
Sort of an industrial park setting, so not quite the same atmosphere as their truck at Portland Head Light, but the ample parking, friendly counter service, tables, bathrooms, outdoor seating, and clean space throughout more than make up for it. I visited twice about a month apart.
Lobster Roll Trio: A nice sampler with three different styles of your choosing. Only a few bites each, so you don't fill up. I enjoyed it, choosing Maine (cold/mayo) , Connecticut (warm/butter), and a curry version (spicy but manageable). Cool thing about the hot butter: it's added on right in front of you from a container the Tin Man wished he had. Good theater and good lobster.
Maine Lobster Roll (4.5-ounce): I liked this better, since it's the quintessential Maine style, has a much more generous serving than the trio, and won't fill you up (though they have a larger size if you want to fill up). There's a little more mayo there than on Red's Eats' lobster roll, but still light enough to let the lobster shine. Plump, fresh, good snap, good overall texture and bite. Proper New England roll with split top and flat sides, properly buttered (read: just enough and not overdone, much like the mayo). Very enjoyable.
Burger: Who knew? A 6-ounce brisket burger on a nice little brioche bun, modestly dressed and with condiments you choose. Good crispness, tender interior, good flavor, bright vegetables, nicely buttered/griddled bun. This isn't a destination burger the way the lobster roll is a destination lobster roll, but solid.
Coleslaw: Crisp, creamy, more mayo than needed, no discernible flavor beyond the mayo.
Potato Chips: All items include a generous portion of crisp, extra-thick, high-salt potato chips of high quality.
Water: Large dispenser near the door provides free water, making the lobster roll an even better deal.
Service: Very cordial and very professional. They move the orders out and are very accommodating with questions and requests.