Michael R.
Yelp
The Black Cow is a good restaurant, but there are better in Newburyport. We used to dine here more frequently when they were situated on the water, but tried them once after the move and was not impressed. We were back at a friends request and glad we tried it. We had pleasant service, delicious cocktails and the food arrived from the kitchen promptly and hot. The food itself was quite unremarkable however. Nothing bad, just OK. The meatball appetizer had tasty meatballs, but was served with a pesto sauce that I did not think paired well. It also came with focaccia, which was nice add, but it was cold, hard and well not great.
I'm not a huge steak fan, but do love a good burger. Once again the burger was just OK. It had some interesting add ons, like cajun onions, but the bacon was a fail. Little chopped pieces of woefully underdone and barely cooked bacon pieces. It's like eating fat. No savory bacon flavor and rubbery texture. I just don't like bacon that is barely cooked.
We tried the peanut butter/chocolate cake for dessert which was nice. Anything with peanut butter an chocolate is a win for me. Not sure it was made in house, but decent enough.
Without the view, the food needs to excel, and that that does not seem to be in the case at least for me.