Black Magic Pizza

I came to Black Magic the other night for the first time with a group of friends plus my boyfriend, who has raved about their pizzas since we've met. He's a long-time devotee and I can now say that I understand why. I wouldn't call myself a food snob or picky by any means, but I am a little particular about pizza. The pizza at BM maintains a crispy bottom yet is still soft, airy and delightful to eat, which definitely speaks to the shop's goal of providing a New-Neapolitan pizza. The menu is small-ish (which to me means that there's a greater chance that everything on there is specially curated and thoughtfully made), the mood is casual and very down-home Milk District, and on Wednesdays there's a great deal for 6 chicken wings for $6. Altogether, my friends and I ordered: -2 Jack the Trippers -1 Coheed and Calabria -1 Dr. Pepperoni -1 order of Garlic Parm wings -1 order of Barbecue wings We all traded a couple slices so we could get a feel for what everyone else ordered—none of the slices disappointed, though the Coheed and Calabria and Dr. Pepperoni were slightly greasy for my taste. I got over that pretty quickly and devoured the rest of the pie. For pricing: We all agreed that for the size of the pie (basically a standard medium pizza), the prices were high, but in line with most places' pricing these days; and considering that the ingredients were fresh, tasty, and I could see them preparing the cooked toppings from the order window, I think the pricing is fair. The specialty pizzas are, in my opinion, pretty overpriced, though. I wish there were an option to try just one slice of the weekly specialty pies, because they sound enticing and fun to sample, but I'm not sure if I could or would want to stomach an entire pie with cream cheese and chili sauce à la the crab rangoon pizza. Maybe I'm just not hardcore enough. Aside from the pizza, the staff were really cool and kind. Loved the vibe of everyone working the night that we went, and you can tell they're invested in the shop's objective to furnish great pies and create a space that's accepting of all.

I’m a big fan of Black Magic Pizza, they’re consistently one of the best pizzas in Orlando and are always trying new variations with their weekly specials. The owners are very kind, friendly and clearly love what they do, which shows in the pizza.

On one hand, Black Magic Pizza is some of the best pizza in Orlando. All pies are made-to-order, the crust and ingredients are fresh, they have inventive flavors and offerings, and I love their merch - particularly the stickers. I cannot think of a single greater place to grab pizza, beer, and wings. It is located inside of Whiskey Lou's which is a great dive for cheap, stiff drinks. Personally, I love the atmosphere, but it might not be for everyone. On the other hand, there are a couple things keeping Black Magic from being my #1 pizza spot. I have an important, personal quip which I always forget about until after I have eaten their food. It is very greasy and I'm yet to go there and not get sick in some capacity. There are very few foods that upset my stomach or make me feel ill, but Black Magic's food just does not sit right with me. Their hot honey pizza, I think, is a particular offender: lots of grease mixed with honey and marinara. My girlfriend, however, has never gotten an upset stomach after eating, so this could just be a me problem. The second trouble comes with the prices. I'm contented to pay $20 for a medium-sized pie if it's of superb quality - which is true for Black Magic; however, their specialty pizzas are way, way over-priced. They have inventive and exciting weekly offerings such as the Crab Rangoon pizza, but I'm unwilling to spend upwards of $30 on something that might be bad. I think they should offer specialty pizza by-the-slice. Even though it upsets my stomach consistently, Black Magic Pizza is one of the best pizzarias in Orlando and I cannot think of a better spot to grab a delicious pizza with a cheap beer.

Great people and awesome pizza. This was a drive for me and it was worth it. Ill make this drive every time based on the taste of this pizza. This place is a gem for sure. Don't hesitate , go see for yourself

Save your money and ask for a refund if there’s a mistake, because here’s what happened to me: Back in February, I ordered a pizza and it was missing sausage. I spoke with the manager, Travis, who told me the next pizza would be on them. Last night, I finally used that offer and asked for a simple pepperoni and sausage pizza with regular sauce. I was told the closest option was called “Coheed & Calabria.” I confirmed that as long as it didn’t have mushrooms, that would be fine. When the pizza arrived, it was extremely spicy with hot peppers, which I hadn’t been told about. It was so spicy that my partner and I couldn’t eat it. When I called back, the employee explained that the pizza had chilies on it and laughed it off, saying, “Well, it’s a free pizza, what do you expect?” So the first order was wrong, the replacement was wrong, and instead of making it right, I was dismissed. I also asked for a call back from the manager but never received one. Very disappointing experience.

Absolutely fantastic! We dont know, what it was, but these pizzas got some special ingredients, which make it so tasteful. The salami pizza was the best i've ever Had!

We drove over an hour to try their pizza. It was so worth it! The pizza is cooked to perfection. It had an excellent flavor and generous toppings. We ate the pizza at Whisky Lou's. They are a nice local bar and it was a great place to enjoy the pizza. Black Magic owners are nice and considerate. They appear to be very involved with customers and crew. We will be back.

If you like Neapolitan style pizza, Black Magic Pizza is THE place to visit. I tried a limited-time speciality pizza of their’s (crab rangoon) when I recently visited and it was to die for!! I could tell the pie was made with passion, and the staff clearly cares about using quality ingredients. Everything from the thin crispy crust to the perfect portions of sauce and cheese makes this walk-up pizza joint a MUST TRY for anyone frequenting the Milk District. I will 1,000% be coming back for more!!!

Excellent! we had the dr pepperoni pizza with added mushrooms and it was outstanding. we would order it again. favorite pizza from there by far. we also had the zeppolas , excellent take on them plenty of them and small .. excellent with the caramel and chocolate dips overall 10/10 excellent !

We stopped by Black Magic Pizza and were seriously impressed! The pepperoni pizza was delicious--crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of spice. The vibe was cool and laid-back, and the staff were super friendly. Definitely worth a visit if you're craving great pizza in a fun spot. Tips: Call ahead to order your pizza to help you save time from waiting.

Now this place right here is the best of the best! If you're looking for the absolute best pizza in Orlando, look no further! From their great service to their delicious wings and of course even better pizza, you just can't top this place! Have tried their Cheezus Pizza (Pictured) which is topped with Basil, Whole Milk Mozzarella, Fresh Mozzarella and Olive Oil which is absolutely amazing. Their Dr. Pepperoni Pizza is just as good which is topped with Cupped Pepperoni's, Whole Milk Mozzarella, Fresh Mozzarella and I can't forgot their spicy maple swirl sauce which knocks it out the park! The crust is also made of Sour Dough which is cooked perfectly fluffy yet crispy. Now their wings, the Hot Honey BBQ wings are hands down some of the best wings I've ever had! The perfect mix of spicy and sweet. If you're in Orlando and haven't tried this place I HIGHLY recommend it.

1st time eating Black Magic pie. The crust was outstanding. Crispy and crunchy the way I like it. The arrugala was not at all wilted. Very fresh topping on the pizza. Great tasting mushrooms. This restaurant is takeout only.

This is a great little pizza shop. We ordered the Hornets Nest, the mozz sticks and the poutine. The pizza stands out. Amazing ingredients. The sauce is very slightly sweet and just tangy enough to not be overpowering. Not smothered with cheese so the toppings stand out. And hot honey belongs on any pizza in my opinion. The mozz sticks are up there with the best I've ever had. Extremely crispy outside (like actually crispy, not that crumble breading that you generally see. And a great cheese pull. These are something you would get on a boardwalk in the NE, if you've been there. And the poutine was an amazing take. Thick French fries with a savory gravy and cheese curds. It's really hard to mess up. I like my fries this way (not too crispy) and this really hit the spot.

Now, I ONLY had the mozzarella sticks but they were super yummy. A very crispy outside and a divine cheeseness on the inside. The marinara to dip was good too. Driving past this place I almost didn't even see it. It's just a walk up window with a sign out front. I'm so looking forward to ordering from here in the very near future!

Awesome pizza! I'm so glad they finally have a permanent location I used to always hope they'd pop up at local events before they opened their new spot. Parking can be a little tricky, but I've always managed to find a spot when picking up my order. You place your order at the window or online and they'll call your name once it's ready. It's strictly a grab-and-go place with no seating, so be prepared to take it to go. Totally worth it for the pizza!

Great pizza. Not greasy. Good crust. Best place found in Orlando for pizza. Unique toppings.

Great food. Amazing customer service upon placing the order to pick up. Very friendly staff as well. On my partner and mines first visit they even gave us a free cannoli which was a very nice thing to see/experience. In the same parking lot was a great seating area with a great ambiance well equipped to sit and eat and enjoy your time

We ordered the Hornets Nest and the Poutine, around 30$ 8.5/10 , The pizza sauce was exceptional plus the hot honey was really good. It tasted fresh, we saw them making the dough in the back. Poutine could've had more flavor but the steak fries were a great choice. Friendly customer service!

The pizzas here are great. Service is friendly and there is a nice ambiance. I tried the poutine which isn't bad -- the gravy is soooo good!

Good pizza not the best but good but ridiculously overpriced!! I'm Italian so my standards are high so far haven't found a place that impresses me much in Orlando!

Phenomenal! Kind, generous staff, casual atmosphere and ridiculously delicious pizza with wood-fired char on the light and airy crust. 10 out of 10!!! Best pizza in town! This pizza joint is window service with limited outdoor seating, but they have an arrangement with Whiskey Lou's that allows customers to eat inside the bar if so wished. Pizza is made to order so there is a bit of a wait (approx 25 min) but you are given a buzzer that lets you know when to come back to the window. Parking is limited.

I first found this place during a lake eola market and there was always a line (much deserved). I need to say I am not a huge fan of pizza and I always look forward to getting a pie from here. The dough is fantastic like 10/10. The way they cook it keeps it chewy with a crispy crust. And then they load it up the way you want it with a mix of traditional and fun toppings. They often have weekly specials (when are we getting that crab Rangoon pizza again ) and offer other items like wings. I love the dr. Pepperoni add ricotta and the good paIt doesn't hurt that they are attached to one of Orlando's chillest dive bars where you can take your pizza if you're looking to sit down and eat. It is also across from milkhouse. I highly recommend this place. Also I love this business and their commitment to community here in Orlando. I will never forget how vocal and supportive yall were as a newer business back in 2020. it did not go unnoticed.

Love me some Black Magic Pizza! After catching their pop-ups around town over the last couple years, I'm so glad they now have a permanent spot and walk-up window at Whiskey Lou's in the Milk District. We happened to hit their $1 Wing Wednesday deal last week, so of course, we had to get some wings in addition to our pizza. We ordered the Hornet's Nest pizza (red sauce, fresh mozzarella, sopressata, basil, and Mike's Hot Honey), the garlic knots, 6 garlic parm wings, and 6 spicy BBQ wings. The food came out in about 15 minutes. We were just taking ours home to enjoy, but if you want to eat there, you can sit on the back patio, inside the bar, or across the street at Milkhouse (they are affiliated). Everything was delicious and we even had enough for leftovers the next day. It was my first time trying their wings and I was really impressed!

Tried the Hornets nest and White Iverson. The ingredients were top notch, the crust was crunchy and delicious! The undercarriage was perfect, best of all no flop! Loved every part of the pizzas! If you're in Orlando, screw the mouse, go to Whisky Lou's and get a pie! Black Magic operates in tandem with the bar and it's perfect together! They give you a pager for your order but it was delivered right to the bar!

Officially my favorite pizza shop!! I finally tried black magic pizza this weekend and I'm not sure what took me so long. I ordered on ubereats and it was ready right on time! It right by whiskey lou's so we pulled right up to the window and picked it up. There are some bar seats on the side if you want to eat there however we choose to take it home. The smell haunted us in the car so we had to try it while driving and truly amazing! We ordered a Dr Pepperoni and Coheed & Calabria pizza. I personally loved the OG Dr Pepperoni. It has the absolute perfect crisp and as someone who doesn't LOVE the crust, I surprisingly enjoyed the crust the most! Later that night after a few drinks we heated the leftovers in the oven and it was easily still the best pizza. I can't wait to go back again!

Bravo! This pizza checks all the boxes and some. Beautiful charred crust, airy, and crispy. Not too crispy though. If you like maple syrup, the Dr. Pepperoni is a must. Quick service and headed to Milkhouse next store to eat. Well done. I am a big fan.

Was looking for a late dinner solution after a show at Plaza Live, and we passed this spot and it came up on Yelp also so we decided to check it out. Felt the chicken bacon ranch pie was nothing to write home about, it was missing something. But the apps!! We got the garlic knots and mozzarella sticks, and they were awesome. I'd come back and try a different pie.

I think the pizza is supposed to look burnt, but I didn't think it would taste so overwhelmingly burnt that nothing else would come through. Also the garlic knots were burned and had almost no garlic on them...or maybe it was burned off... I legit had to make a dipping sauce for them to give them some flavor and make them edible.

I'd like to add from my previous review that the fries, ranch, and blue cheese are all phenomenal!! I love this place!

Hubby really wanted a wood fired pizza. Arrived at 4 when they opened Absolutely loved the char on the rust., which was just the right thickness so it Folds like a NY pizza with a nice cheese pull. It's also not too heavy, we each ate 3 slices and felt good so we skipped dinner We ordered half Cheese and half White as we are a divided couple when it comes to pizza. Both sides were great. The balsamic vinegar on my half gave it a flatbread taste, which was fine with me. There's some seating on Bumby or you can sit on the back porch of Whiskey Lou's. But there are a lot of smokers there, and as I smoker I don't like moving my food with smoke. Look forward to our next pie!

Black Magic Pizza is always a must when craving some pizza/wings. The garlic knots were very soft with a nice crunch on the outside and it comes with some amazing red sauce. The pizza had a great crisp to it and the wings were 10/10. This place is very consistent with the quality of their food. Will be back!

Back from another amazing meal. I'll be honest, I barely want to post about this place because then it'll be harder to get some of the absolute best pizza in Orlando. BMP uses amazing artisanal ingredients to serve up probably top 3 pizzas in Orlando and it only keeps getting better every single time I go. It's like they made a pact with the devil to conjure up pizza that couldn't possibly exist in this mortal realm. Currently the shop is a small kiosk next to a bar but I'm sure that will change in the very near future. They have some seating near by but it's definitely not for a group of people. I've sat there myself devouring their personal sized pizzas. Other things I've tried on their menu is their wings. On Wednesday they have half off or a dollar a wing. I'm a much bigger fan of their buffalo with Calabrian chilis. Their garlic parm is fantastic as well if that's more your speed. They also have specials every so often. I just had their take on the chicken tender pub sub and I'm convinced they do it better. If it's not on their permanent menu moving forward I'll probably riot. The whole team and especially the owner are fantastic people who I can tell are super passionate about making delicious food. Don't be afraid to give them feedback, they're always on the lookout for ways to improve. Anyway... don't come here... it's so bad... ... I can't lie. It's amazing and people should let them take their money.

We recently tried this spot and it lived up to the hype I've heard! They were formally a pop up and now have a set spot to pick up at Whiskey Lou's. We opted to order online and then pick up to bring home, but my understanding is you can also eat it over at Milk House. We chose an order of Calabrian Buffalo wings and their Hornet's Nest pizza. Food was ready at the given time and we dug in at home. The wings had a good crunch on the outside and juicy meat on the inside and I loved the flavor of the sauce. It had a nice kick, but not overly spicy. The ranch was tasty for dipping as well. The pizza was delicious! All of the flavors worked well together, ingredients tasted fresh, and we both liked the consistency of the crust (and dipping in the extra ranch I ordered!) The pizza was a little cold and we don't live very far, but it's a thinner style so just keep in mind it might cool down a bit if you're taking it to go. It was still delish! The prices are on the high side, but worth it in my opinion for the good quality and supporting an awesome local spot. It's one of the better pizzas I've had in town for sure. I'll definitely return!

SUPER friendly employees, really nice, and knowledgeable about their food. They saw us walking over from sideward brewing and opened the window and greeted us as we walked towards the building. I guess we had that "we want pizza" look on our faces. Can I tell you though? For me the star items were not the pizza, but rather: 1, the mozzarella sticks - wow, wow, wow, wow, WOW! They're made in house every morning and when they're out, they're out till the next day 2, their garlic knots. Savory, buttery, drench it in sauce.. pizza who? Maybe I'm just not a fan of the style pizza but I thought it was ok, and if I were to come back, i'd just get the mozz sticks and garlic knots. I can't speak for the wings because someone else in our party ate them, but said they were really delicious. Give them a shot if you're in the area and craving pizza.

This is a pizza window at Whiskey Lou's, and there is very little seating available but there is *some* plus I'm pretty sure you can also take your pizza to the bar if you want! Anyhow, the food is expensive however compared to other popular up style pizza places, the pies are BIG! We ordered two thinking we each needed our own but that was a miscalculation lol. The pizzas were really good and not overly charred which is often an issue I have with this style. The mozzarella sticks weren't hot enough and the cheese was solid which was my only disappointment. Overall really enjoyed the pizza and will be back!

Black Magic Pizza was a restaurant that I did not know existed until I saw an Instagram recommendation. It is actually a pop-up style restaurant located in the front of a bar. They serve typical bar style pizza with all ingredients made from scratch. I was able to place an online order so that I could easily pick it up to go. Everything went smoothly and I enjoyed both of my pizzas. Not the best pizza I have ever had, but not the worst either.

This is some dang good pizza! I have heard a lot about Black Magic Pizza and every event we went to with them, they managed to sell out before we got to try them. However, they finally have a store location/walk-up window to get their pizza. We had a bit of trouble finding parking nearby, so we opted for the drop off method. The walk-up window is located right below the Lou's sign and the staff was incredibly friendly. They will even walk the pizza over to the nearby bar and restaurant if you would prefer. The location itself does not have any seating with it, but like I said they have agreements with the two locations nearby (Orlando Milkhouse and Whiskey Lou's Lounge) to allow you to bring your pizza in there. We chose to get two pizzas and I am glad we did because I would definitely say the pizzas are personal pizza-sized. The pizza is definitely a bit on the pricier side ($16-$18 for a small pizza), but they use very high-quality ingredients, the staff is great and the pizza is taasssttyyy! We tried the Hornets Nest and the White Iverson. We both preferred the Hornets Nest, but the White Iverson was a very very close second. The hot honey on the Hornets Nest was the absolute perfect finish! The White Iverson was very creamy with the ricotta base and I really enjoyed the sesame seed crust and caramelizad onions. Excited for Black Magic Pizza at their storefront location and definitely recommend trying out their pizza!

So... you wanna eat pizza? Hell yeah you do! Friendly staff, cool locale, AND you're supporting one of Orlando's best pizza spots. 10/10, would eat again

I have been coming to Black Magic for years since they were only doing pop ups! I could honestly say this is one of the best, if not THE best pizza I have ever had. It's cooked perfectly EVERY time and the ingredients taste so fresh. I love the Dr Pepperoni and the Hornets nest. I love the hot honey sauce they put on top it goes perfectly! I probably have had every pizza on their menu!! Nothing is bad! They (finally) moved into a permanent walk up window at whiskey Lou's bar so I can have it whenever I want thank god! They now also offer garlic knots and some other items. The knots were SO good. I love coming here I always know the pizza will be amazing each time. I used to wait an hour for a pizza at the pop ups and it was worth it. Now it's even better, the pizzas are done in under 10 minutes!!! You can eat the pies in Whiskey Lou's or in the Milkhouse. Props to black magic for the amazing food they can produce i will be coming back as long as they are serving :)

Garlic Knots are fantastic and the pizza was great. I had a vegan pizza because I stay away from dairy.

Pizza-awesome. Poutine-amazing. Garlic knots-on point. Zeppoles-ridiculous. Go! Go now! Well it doesn't open til 4, so go then!!!

Crispy crust, great cup pepperoni, and overall tasty. One of the best pizza places in Orlando. Don't skip on the sesame crust.

Excellent in every way. Great pizza. Great service. Great variety. Many nights we have added a pizza to our whiskey Lou's trip.

This place is so unassuming and made for locals. The pizza is outstanding, and the order/pick-up process is about as straightforward as you can get. Black Magic has become our weekend go-to, and we're glad to have them in The Milk District.

Such good pizza! Always wanted to try them and finally got to when they set up a takeout window across from milk house. Pretty fast service & they have a couple chairs to sit on while you wait. Online pre-ordering is also available. The taste is phenomenal ! Went with the cheezus but will def have to try more out next time.

Pizza is great! Check out the Dr Pepperoni. Quick and easy order at the window and in a great area for pizza after a few beverages

Although this is only a window, this window has some delicious pizza. I first learned about them because people were making lines in the daytime so I wondered "who is making the line to go inside Whiskey Lou's?". Turns out it was a line for Black Magic Pizza. So one day, when there was no line, I pulled up and ordered. What else do I have to say? 5 stars.

Best pizza spot in town. HANDS DOWN!! Always sending people their way. Dr pepperoni is my favorite. Chicken wings are fire

Probably the best pizza around Orlando! Even after a 15 minute drive home with the pizza it was still crispy! It is pricey but better than most pizza in Orlando! Cant say much for service since it was take out.

Love Black Magic Pizza, usually the go to move is Coheed & Calabria and a cannoli. Tried a new one today, Three Meat Deep. Absolutely loved it. I was hesitant about bacon because people tend to have just generic smoke flavored meat but this was perfect. Tried the poutine as well, delicious.

great food, great service, great merch. great vibes all around. the staff was super friendly & the food was buss down.

Ok so first off, it was a treasure hunt in finding this literal whole in the wall. The signage need help - my hats off to the witches in finding this place. On to the food review - being from NYC I guess I'm spoiled and so is my palette. I had high hopes for this spot. The garlic knots were the star of the show. They were made with love - crispy outside and pure joy inside. However, the "in house marinara sauce" was a slightly over seasoned for my taste. I ordered two different pies of pizza. 1. Cheese pie - bland and I'm willing to take this statement to court. Looks great in photos but my palette screamed at me where's the flavor! 2. White Iversson - a double whammy of bland. Seriously, a waste of money. Nothing stood out in terms of flavor profiles. So sad. On to the next pizza joint! Wish me luck!!! I have two starts because the garlic knots were really good.

Ordered a few pies to go and really enjoyed them! Wood fired and ingredients were fresh and delish. Nicely cooked and will return! Great little gem!

Best pizza bar none! Great crew with great service too to bottom! The white iverson is the best za to me!

What a fun event filled with delicious food, drinks, and amazing company! It was my first time trying this place and their food did not disappoint. Their crispy & juicy wings, their cheesy mozzarella sticks, fluffy garlic knots, and their incredible pizza were all amazing and I'll definitely have to come back again! My favorite pizza was the Dr Pepperoni with a spicy maple swirl. I hope this place is prepared to see me regularly. I've been on the search for a good pizza place in Orlando, and this might be the spot. Don't forget to order the huge cannolis for dessert!

I'm so, so mad this place is so close to me because I'm going to be there all the time! Very easy to order online but if you walk up to the window, there's always a pretty short wait too. I've tried several of the pizzas and enjoyed them and they're always willing to accommodate if you want to make a change. The garlic knots are the BOMB. I almost don't want to say that because if more people buy them and they sell out faster, I can't get them some days, but they really are soft and buttery and delicious. Staff is 10 out of 10 for being friendly and kind and even left me the sweetest message on a recent order takeout box. So glad they moved to the neighborhood.

Had the opportunity tonight to try the White Iverson Pizza which was absolutely delicious -so was the Cannoli which I highly recommend The staff was very friendly and cheerful, what a great addition to the community