Mark T.
Yelp
Oh man, I wish I could give this place 5 stars, I really do. It is a close one, definitely.
The location is superb, right in the theater district, and is hiding on top of a gym. As if it was intended for you to work off a bunch of calories, then put on something slightly nicer and gain them all back again.
Don't let the prices scare you. Yes, it is expensive. But it is a very good value. You get excellent quality food and appropriately large portions.
* indicates dishes I sampled from other people in my group.
No star means I ordered for myself.
Tuna Tartar is one of the best things I've ever had. You get a very generous amount of tuna, coated in a gentle, mild, guac (more like crushed avocado). Sauce is divine, and taro chips are a nice touch.
Mushroom soup was also very nice. It had a pleasant consistency and flavor. Truffle oil is a nice touch. However, I would have liked to see a little more flair in this dish. Aside from the truffle oil, there is nothing that makes this dish a star. But I will give them points for simplicity, and for a perfect salt level!!!
*Calamari was very pleasant. Olives, pepperoncino, aioli all add a nice acidity to this dish. You also have to love the little cloth they put on the lemon (so you can squeeze without seeds).
*Eggplant Napoleon was good, and was something else. I mean it is nothing like eggplant parmesan, not even close. Still a nice blend of flavors. However, in this dish, I would have liked ingredients to be a little more distinct, and less blended.
Lobster Club was good, but not super. Also not technically a club (club are double decker). Good amount of lobster, but not enough BLT (key in a club). I do admire that bacon was in tiny square pieces rather than slices (more consistency).Fries were good, nothing spectacular.
*Scallops were awesome. not overly fishy, soft, and delicious
*Ditto to swordfish -- cooked perfectly, with delicious sides and sauce.
Out of Drinks the Mariachi is delicious. Strong, a little sweet a little spicy, and great. A must get!
Desert was eh. Tiramisu seemed like it was out of the fridge, and creme brulee was good, especially the hardened shell, but nothing super.
Service was quick, nice, and professional.