Molly T.
Yelp
4.5 stars. Surprises are not always fun. But pleasant surprises are, well, pleasant. Blue Haven, you were a pleasant surprise on Saturday night, and I am very very happy about it.
Came here on, you guessed it, Saturday night, with a friend who wanted to have her FIRST LEGAL DRINK! Boy was I honored to be her company for that. But I digress. Unfortunately, this particular Saturday night was rife with college football. I'm not sure I realized how much people care about college football (I'm more of a pro sports girl myself) until this particular night, because our first five or six attempts to get a table at a bar were maddeningly futile. From bar to bar we hopped, hoping that the next would hold greater promise than the last. But alas, we traveled from Chelsea to the West Village to Greenwich Village - we nearly ended up in Soho. It was raining and we were fed up with this nonsense. But Blue Haven to the rescue! We were able to get a table here *just* before the BRO RUSH and we were finally content.
Blue Haven is a decently-sized bar with plenty of tables - while I've only ordered dinner-type food here, I get the sense that it's just as much an eatery as it is a bar. The back room has a couple of tables and dart boards if you want to get your bar game on. We actually wanted to watch baseball, and while most of the TVs were showing college football, a few were saved for baseball. No shortage of TVs here - props for that.
Our waitress got on our good side immediately, as she shooed a small group of people who were just using a table for a drink rest. So we got a seat pretty quickly, and got to draaaanks. The waitress became more overjoyed than we were upon finding out that my friend had just turned 21 - she couldn't contain her excitement, and it was awesome. There's a fine line with enthusiasm - it can be endearing up to a certain extent, and past that line it's aggravatingly irritating. She struck just the right balance. We both went with Belgian beers for the night (as I always do). ANOTHER PRO: Despite not being any sort of craft beer establishment, they serve their beers in the correct glasses. My Delirium came in a Delirium glass, my friend's Allagash White came in its proper glass, and all was well. Beer and cocktail menus are both far above-average as far as sports bars go. Very impressed.
Now, we had worked up and appetite from all of that walking, so food was necessary. This is definitely what I'd call an upscale bar menu. Not your average pub grub. They have a great variety of options here. You've got your typical burgers and wings deal, but there are plenty of other options. I got the Black Bean & Quinoa Burger w/ lime aioli, Bloody orange BBQ, queso fresco, brioche. One of the best veggie burgers I've had in a while. Our waitress was quite confident that we'd be impressed with the quality of the food here, and we were not mistaken. Both of us cleaned our plates. My burger was flavorful and creative, and the brioche was indeed fresh. I'm semi-addicted to looking up menus prior to restaurant visits, and I didn't get to do this ritual before eating here. But I was not penalized - in fact, the food here was probably better than anything I would've ordered elsewhere that night (we were looking for sports bars with good bar food).
Just a note on the crowd: definitely bro-y and loud. But we didn't mind in the slightest. We happened to be seated close to the majority of the TVs, so the noise was warranted. If you get a table closer to the back of the bar, you'll be able to hear yourselves talk a bit more.
One of the best sports bars I've ever to. A haven indeed!