Blue Sky Bakery Review - Park Slope - New York - The Infatuation
"Blue Sky Bakery is a tiny cafe near the Barclays Center known for its muffins. They wholesale them to places around the city, but the shop is a popular stop for Park Slope people on their way to work in the morning. These muffins are unbelievably good, stuffed with fruits, and never too sugary or sweet. Get there early - they close at 2pm and the best muffins sell out by late morning." - Matt Tervooren
I recently had the pleasure of visiting Blue Sky Bakery, and I can't recommend it enough! The highlight of my experience was definitely the cream rolls—they are absolutely delicious and incredibly affordable. Each bite is a perfect blend of sweetness and creaminess that left me wanting more.
What truly made my visit special was the owner. They were incredibly friendly and took the time to walk us through the various items in the bakery. I appreciated the personal touch as they shared fascinating stories and history from Afghanistan, which added depth to our experience. It’s clear that they are passionate about their craft and genuinely care about their customers.
If you're looking for a delightful treat and a warm atmosphere, Blue Sky Bakery is the place to go!
Raheel Zaman
Google
One of my friend took me there for Cream Rolls, these were superb and guess what although I was travelling back from Canada but I just went there to buy more and enjoy it.
I also tried chocolate puff, which I will give 8/10 but for cream rolls I will definitely give 10/10.
The place is very neat and clean.
Zinat Bary
Google
This family-owned bakery is a rare hidden gem. I've been getting pastries from here for years. For anyone new to Afghan pastries, the cream rolls are a must-try! I love bringing an extra box to gatherings; it’s become a tradition that my friends and colleagues look forward to. I will gladly make the one-hour drive here, because it is THAT good. The staff have always been warm & welcoming to me, plus my order is always prepared right on time for pick up. I highly recommend this place to anyone who appreciates authentic, freshly made baked goods :)
Kashif Sayyed
Google
Blue Sky Bakery is a beloved Scarborough institution known for its fresh, Middle Eastern and Canadian baked goods. Their cream rolls are a standout—light, airy, and a customer favorite. With a focus on quality and traditional flavors, it's a go-to spot for delicious cakes, pastries, and treats that feel both comforting and authentic.
Lone Wolf
Google
This place is a hidden gem! Got introduced to the Afghan creme rolls and I have to say they are very addictive, I come here every few weeks to grab a box for family and friends. The staff are polite and amazing. Definitely recommend this place.
Ramsha Khan
Google
Came across this bakery through some family friends and we’re definitely not disappointed. We tried the cream rolls and they 100% lived up to the hype (my cousin couldn’t stop eating them). Will definitely visit again!!
lets.weekend
Google
The cream rolls are the best cream rolls we’ve ever had. These have the perfect texture, perfect sweetness and just melts in your mouth. Anyone who tried them, couldn’t help but go for more. There is a reason why everyone is raving about the cream rolls! Go grab yourself some, you won’t regret.
The profiteroles are also really delicious.
Mahfuza Akther
Google
Best cream rolls I ever had.🤍
Worth it
Tony G.
Yelp
Super Friendly. Great value and quality. Wide selection of Afghanistan and Iranian pastries. Everything that I have tried here has been outstanding.
R V.
Yelp
Their cream puff rolls were pretty good, as were the chocolate-covered rolls. Service was friendly, even gave me more than what I asked! Also gave me a free cookie upon exiting lol
Rona M.
Yelp
I went to get Root from this place. She told me they are sold out of Root but she has Cream Rolls, and one of the best Cream Rolls I ever had. Excellent Pastry.
Reeda T.
Yelp
Perfect everything! They have all the kolcha, cream rolls, whatever you need for when Mina-jan drops by-Amazing pizza as well, and for a really great price!
Anne M.
Yelp
This little Afghan bakery is right in our neighbourhood. Their items are all made right at the store - their baklava is wonderful, fresh and really good. They also have an Afghan sweet (I forget the name) that is made with nuts and butter that resembles middle eastern halvah that I love. The owner/baker is very friendly and I always buy more than I intended when we visit.
J D.
Yelp
To experience a taste of heaven go to Blue Sky Bakery. My son brought home some pastries from this bakery, my taste buds went wild, the best pastries I have ever eaten. Give yourself a treat check it out.