Tam G (Tam)
Google
We visited this restaurant during our trip to Catalina Island, and while it has potential, our experience was mixed.
They open at 11 a.m., and even though everything looked ready, we weren’t allowed in early , we had to wait outside for 15 minutes until they officially opened. We were a large group of about 10 people, and trying to get seated together turned into an unnecessarily complicated process. We were asked to go back to the line, wait again, and the overall seating experience felt unwelcoming and disorganized.
That said, once we were seated, things improved a bit. The food was okay in terms of flavor, but nothing particularly special. However, they did serve a complimentary sourdough bread with butter that was absolutely delicious , we asked for more, and they gladly brought extra.
What really stood out was our server, who was amazing. I believe her name was Lisa (a lovely woman in her 40s with striking blue eyes). She was incredibly kind, attentive, and really helped elevate our experience.
As for the food:
• The buffalo milk drink was excellent, and they offer it in a large size for sharing, which is great for groups.
• The burger and steak were underwhelming , I wouldn’t recommend them.
• The halibut was tasty and felt like a healthy choice.
• The ahi poke was also fresh and enjoyable.
Overall, this place offers a nice ocean view, which adds to the experience. It might be a better option for smaller groups to avoid the hassle we went through. Despite the rough start, we’re thankful for our wonderful server, who made the visit worthwhile.