Boardwalk Pizzeria

Pizza so delicious that although I am well-known for and love my homemade pizza, I haven’t made any in the 10 months since we moved to the area. The service is friendly and efficient, and they make to order if they’ve run out of one’s preference. We are yet to try their expansive non-pizza menu … it’s literally unpassable.

First ate here in 2017 when we lived off Beach 59th, I was pregnant with our daughter & it was the ONLY food I could eat without getting sick afterwards. My husband & I basically lived off of their Grandma Pie, I absolutely fell in love with Boardwalk & since we moved I haven't been able to enjoy other places pizza since. The quality of their pizza, the flavor, the deliciousness is to die for. Can't wait to go back to NY to visit family just so we can go to Far Rockaway to order a few pies. Our daughter is now 7 and she loves pizza so I can't wait for her to finally try the pizza I have told her so many stories about so she can taste it for herself lol.

Honestly, the bad review isn’t about its quality per se. It’s the fact that the owner has a Trump sticker right next to his kitchen full of Latino workers. More specifically on his office door (which he kept open for 99.9% of my stay). That’s absolutely inhumane considering the conditions immigrants (many Latino) are being put under this current administration - especially with the many confirmed reports of the severe abuse that’s happening in the El Salvador/foreign prisons they’ve been sending them to. Not even mentioning the history of the exploitation of Latino/minority workers in America - more specifically in the hands of people who see us as lesser “Americans” (people) than they are. I feel horrible for their workers, they shouldn’t have to deal with it. They’re nice, work hard, and I had a wonderful conversation with them about their day, and they clearly try to create a good experience. I felt that way until the owner kinda stormed through and ruined it with his attitude. Automatically I felt the hostility in that place by the owner, especially toward his workers. Seemingly criticizing them in front of people over what ended up being a network issue. It made me feel uncomfortable off the bat, I just wanted some pizza so I quickly made my order to him right after he barked at a worker and then turned to me and asked what I wanted?? I only noticed the sign after I paid when he opened the door and I immediately regretted my decision. I've been here many times and I WILL DEFINITELY NOT COME BACK. I made sure to tell as many people that I saw today about it so they knew too. And will continue to as the days and years go on. No matter what. No wonder he treated his workers this way. No wonder there was hostility. So I guess at the end of the day, my review IS about the quality. Because the sign said it all. Disgusting.

Visited this past Friday with my wife and saw mice running around the floor. Instantly lost my appetite and decided to leave. As I was walking out, I once again saw mice running around and mice droppings on the floor. Makes one wonder what is really going on in that kitchen. Decided not to speak with any staff because they were distant and had like no emotion or interest in customer service so I decided to save myself the trouble from speaking with them. Would definitely not return.

Listen, the pizza is decent. But where did we get in society that 2 slices of pizza and a Snapple is $13.80? Even if it was the best slice in the world (which it definitely isn’t) I’d say that’s too expensive. Too much oil and too small to be charging that much. Common now. The garbage cans and floors are filthy too

The price is OK. The portion size is decent. The pizza is very greasy. The buffalo chicken pizza is dry. And the pizza crust is very thin. I’ve never had pizza this thin unless I’ve ordered thin crust and I ordered regular.

We’re big pizza lovers and have tried pizza all over New York, so we really wanted to give this place a fair chance. We stopped by a couple of times, but honestly, it left a pretty mixed impression. The staff was… hard to describe — not rude, but not very friendly either. The biggest disappointment was that when we came in to eat, I needed to use the restroom, and they told me it wasn’t working. That was really uncomfortable, especially since we had already ordered our food. A restaurant at this level should really make that a priority. I understand it’s a busy beach area, but still — that’s something they need to figure out. The pizza itself was just average, nothing special, so we don’t plan to come back.

Their food is amazingly delicious! 😋 highly recommend their cheese pizza, pepperoni pizza, calamari, and linguine di mare in marinara sauce- we prefer the spaghetti pasta over the linguini. Delivery is typically about an hour, still arrives hot and food is absolutely worth the wait. 😉