Jeremy T.
Yelp
I visited this upscale cocktail bar and event space one weekday during Cursed Cauldron's Halloween pop-up event. Unfortunately, I booked on the one night the upstairs is closed, but the reservation system let me book that particular area on that day regardless. The host of the event emailed a few days beforehand to let me know I need to pick another day or just sit in one of the downstairs sections. If I knew what I know now, I'd have either have picked a different day or requested to sit in the rear section since it was decorated more elaborately by the pop-up event. The ended up placing me in the front section near the front door.
The actual Botonica space was nice and modern, taking up 2 levels at the NW corner of the building. Limited free retail parking is available and located in the garage east of the SkyHouse building, which is where I was able to snag a spot.
During my visit, I came on the night of the tarot card mini readings, meaning you wait nearly an hour to speak to the one person doing the readings, and get about 2 free minutes with him, then any follow up readings, which are the informative ones, cost $20 each. I felt it's kind of a gimmick to get you to spend more money.
We tried 2 drinks, an app and a dessert, during the visit. Lillith's Lullaby and the Old Magick. We also added the spicy beef empanadas and a cinnamon roll.
Lillith's Lullaby - a tequila-based drink with a lot of garnishes on top. A fruity, sweet drink but unfortunately my companion pushed the stringy garnish into the drink and basically contaminated it halfway through, so that each time you take a drink, you get a mouth full of the garnish.
The Old Magick - a smoky old fashioned with rye whiskey. Nice presentation as the server lights the embers on the lid which generate smoke for the drink down below. Once the lid has been removed, the smoke slowly fades away, but the smokiness stays with the drink until the end.
Cinnamon roll - this was a little disappointing because the bottom half of it was hard as a rock and made it hard to cut and chew. Otherwise, it was ok, but nothing gourmet by any means.
Spicy beef empanadas- the empanada was tiny but tasty. The green sauce to dip it in is what makes it spicy, but I enjoyed it. It was just too tiny.
They auto add a 20% gratuity here, so that's something to be mindful of; however, the server did let us know this when checking out.
Overall, I really enjoyed the space, but one thing I was most disappointed with was the fact that this was a Halloween-themed event with about 40-50 customers at my seating time but other than myself, there were maybe 6 other customers that even dressed up. At least most of the customers (who didn't dress up) still dressed nicely. The hostess and at least 2 other employees were in costume as well.