Dave H.
Yelp
People generally go out to eat to enjoy a delicious meal in a nice setting. Hopefully with an attentive server and kitchen. If I can cook the meal you serve to me at home better and with less hassle, well, you begin to understand the minimum bar patrons have set for a restaurant.
Sadly, Bradford Tavern does not clear that bar. We came in the other night on a weekday around 6 pm and there were few diners in the place. We chose to be seated in the dining room (vs the bar). The inside of the tavern is a modern restaurant space with touches of old-world charm (like the exposed ceiling beams). However, the overall decor and bright lighting suggest a renovation that was half-done in a weird quasi modern colonial style that just doesn't really work. It's a shame, really, because it could be a really cool space.
Our server was friendly & attentive throughout the evening. Kudos to him, because he certainly tried his best.
After a fairly long wait to get our drinks (10 minutes but the place was empty!), we put an order in for a burger and a chicken sandwich. My partner was specific about her order in terms of no cheese or sauce on the chicken sandwich. I had the burger as it came, asked for a medium temperature on it.
A long time later, our plates arrived. And of course they got my partner's order wrong -- cheese all over the sandwich. It took a few minutes to get our server's attention again, and while he apologized, it doesn't really make up for the fact that now I have my food in front of me, and my partner has nothing. She encouraged me to eat, but it's always an awkward situation.
Server comes right back to the table and says the kitchen apologizes and it'll be done in 5 minutes. How you can cook a chicken breast in 5 minutes is beyond me, but alright. Closer to 15 minutes later (I'm finishing up my meal, of course), her sandwich comes out as ordered.
My burger was on the thin side and done medium-well. While it appeared well-prepared, there was truly nothing special about it. No special condiments, just meat, lettuce, tomato and red onion. The taste was okay, but I came away feeling like I make a better burger at home. Same for my partner's chicken sandwich. Again, no special seasoning or real taste to the chicken, I think McDonald's probably makes a better sandwich. The onion rings and fries accompanying our dishes were good.
I don't get it. You have a wonderful location, a nice space (that has a lot of unmet potential), and then serve just very mediocre food and have a kitchen that apparently can't read a ticket correctly. You're blowing your reputation on this sort of hum-drum experience, and wonder why your dining room is so empty on a weeknight. The only reason I suspect people come here is because it's nearby to where they live and they can't be bothered to go elsewhere.
Two drinks, two sandwiches, and the bill came out to around $60. Yeah, no, we won't be back and don't recommend this place. There are other places you can go nearby with a better overall experience.