Brick Fire Tavern

Pizza restaurant · Kaimuki

Brick Fire Tavern

Pizza restaurant · Kaimuki

1

3447 Waialae Ave, Honolulu, HI 96816

Photos

Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null
Brick Fire Tavern by null

Highlights

Authentic Neapolitan pizza & fresh pasta, Italian wine & cocktails  

Placeholder
Placeholder

3447 Waialae Ave, Honolulu, HI 96816 Get directions

brickfiretavern.com
@brickfiretavern

$20–30 · Menu

Reserve

Information

Static Map

3447 Waialae Ave, Honolulu, HI 96816 Get directions

+1 808 379 2430
brickfiretavern.com
@brickfiretavern

$20–30 · Menu

Reserve

Features

payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Oct 24, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@postcardnews

Locally owned and community‑minded, this Kaimukī staple turns out wood‑fired pies, house meatballs, and market‑driven specials with island produce. A frequent pick of local critics and OpenTable diners, it’s a relaxed, neighborhood answer to great pizza and Italian comfort plates.

https://www.opentable.com/r/brick-fire-tavern-kaimuki-honolulu
Italian Restaurants in Honolulu (2025)
View Postcard for Brick Fire Tavern

Hana Cho

Google
This is a must-visit spot every time I go to Oahu. Everyone I’ve recommended it to has said the same thing—it’s always delicious. From pizza and pasta to the meatballs, every single dish is outstanding. It’s already so popular that you can’t usually get a table at dinner without a reservation, but it’s still a place I want more people to know about. The prices are very reasonable, the staff is friendly, and the whole experience is close to perfect.

R&L Holguin

Google
Been here multiple times and have yet to be disappointed! The pizzas & pastas are always cooked to perfection and the desserts are so delicious! If you plan on coming during dinner hours make sure to have a reservation since it’s such a popular place! Also parking might be a little difficult next to the restaurant but there is a paid parking lot within walking distance.

Pla Nannapha

Google
The best and authentic handmade pizza in town. I had the Mamma Mia pizza and it was so satisfying. My husband had a fresh pasta bolognese and it was so divine. The Chianti wine was so great. And we finished it up with Pistachio Cheesecake and Cannoli, it was perfect. I will definitely coming back here again!

Trestan Nakamura

Google
This place was awesome! I came here with a big party of 13 and the service was fantastic. Our server did a great job taking care of us. We started with Caesar salads, which were okay, but I felt they could’ve used a bit more dressing. Once the entrées came out, though, everything was excellent. The pizzas had a doughy, mochi-like crust that I really enjoyed and each one had great flavor and depth. A standout was the miso spicy pie with garlic shrimp, which had just the right kicks of spice mixed in. My personal favorite overall was the bolognese pasta. The sauce was creamy despite being tomato-based and the meatball was cooked to perfection. Definitely a great spot to check out if you’re in the mood for some fire pasta or pizza!

Samuel gelb

Google
True Neapolitan style pizza, very close to pizza in Napoli. Can never go wrong with a good napolitano margherita pizza, and this did not disappoint. Very friendly service, will come back for some fresh pasta, wine and more next time.

My Calendar

Google
Got the NY meat and margherita plus truffle. both were excellent. the truffle added a really nice umami to the margherita. The creamy spots of ricotta was very nice too. If you like this style of pizza, you'll love this place. Crust was crisp and chewy on the inside...and flavorful. We were there for lunch, about 3/4 full but it still took nearly 45m for our pizza. We had a good view of the oven and it wasn't like they were constantly slinging pizzas so not sure why it took so long. Had a peroni and hopped cider. total w/ tip was ~$75. Dinner time, it gets jammed. We had call 3x in the past for a seat anytime between 530-7 and it was always a 45m-1hr wait. Go lunch time.

F P

Google
Visiting from LA. Pizza and salad were delicious. The dough was great. Service was great too. One of the best pizzas I’ve had. Highly recommend.

Bob Journey

Google
This restaurant serves freshly baked, authentic Neapolitan pizza. The clam dish was bitter and not very enjoyable, so I left most of it. However, the pizza was absolutely delicious, and the servers were friendly, so I’m giving it five stars.
google avatar

Ann N.

Yelp
Having not come here for several years I've ventured back with friends hoping for a better outcome. And I was pleasantly surprised. We came on a Wednesday at 12 PM and miraculously found parking in front. We had amazing, attentive service, and the food was exceptional. We all chose the lunch special which came with a pizza and salad or soup. We all chose salad. The pizza is large cut into fours and I didn't think I would finish mine but I did. I did sacrifice one to a friend. lol. The pizza is thin and not super doughy which makes it easy to finish it all with the salad. With such a good experience, I am sure to visit again. The place was busy for lunch but not too busy. The restaurant is clean, bright, and full of positive vibes.
google avatar

Elizabeth V.

Yelp
Another fantastic dining experience at Brick Fire Tavern! Service was quick, friendly, and on point as always. This time, I decided to switch things up and go for the Bolognese pasta--a dish I've heard rave reviews about. Let me just say... it did not disappoint. The pasta was perfectly al dente, the sauce rich and savory, and that meatball brought everything together in the most satisfying way. Of course, we couldn't leave without a pizza, so we ordered the New Yorker--and it was another hit! Crispy yet chewy crust, flavorful toppings, and just the right balance of sauce and cheese. Brick Fire Tavern continues to impress, and I can't wait to come back for more pasta and to explore even more of their pizzas.
google avatar

Winnie L.

Yelp
We were able to get squeezed into a 7:45 reservation. We were seated in the back in what appeared to be like someone's kitchen. Very warm and homey, just like the hospitality. A plate of freshly baked pizza dough was placed before us to snack on with a balsamic vinaigrette to dip. Wow. Amazing, chewing pizza dough crust. We browsed the menu and we immediately knew what we wanted. New Yorker. Chopped Salad. Pappardelle pasta. The pizza, was love at 1st bite. The sauce hit me first right in the taste buds. A smoothness unlike your typical pizza sauce. Not too overly acidic like there was a nice balance of flavors. Then the ingredients. The cheese, the pepperoni all melded together. I love NY style pizza but this pizza here at BFT takes pizza to another level like it makes me believe I love Italian pizza Period. Then the crust. I could gnaw on this crust all day...and I don't particularly like pizza crust.but this crust. Yes! I used it to wipe the plate of the pasta we devoured. The pasta was nice and al dente. Great texture of the oodles of noodles with the bolo sauce. The creaminess. The balance of flavors. Definitely a comfort food I would choose over and over again. I wished my stomach was bigger so I could order another one. Then the dessert. The pistachio cheesecake caught my attention with the oreo crust. But the cannoli. I recently ate a plate of them in Little Italy from the king but the cherry sauce drizzled and mini chocolate chips took my whole cannoli experience to new heights. The crust. What is it about the way this place makes crusts? They have it down to a science that I so appreciate. I love black forest cake and the flavors of this cannoli make me think of it. Yes, yes, yes! Loved my entire meal here. Why have we forgotten about this gem in HNL? Need to come back more often I can't believe I never sent this review below from...2021? Hubs Yelped this Burrata and Beets (Yellow) Italian Wedding Soup Meatballs with Foccacia Bread Funghi Pizza (add truffle pate & Italian Salami Strawberry Guava Sorbeto BFT Signature Cheesecake- Pistachio, Oregon Crust, Fresh Whipped
google avatar

Monique L.

Yelp
Wow! Food was amazing, very convienent location and staff was very friendly. Sat on the bar and had the best service with our bartender Tim. He recommended this appetizer, I would've never tried other wise but was the highlight of my meal. Drinks were also amazing! (Another highlight) would definitely come back again!!
google avatar

Harper F.

Yelp
Authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, just like in Naples! The margherita was spot on--simple, fresh, and delicious. Service was very friendly, and I'm already looking forward to coming back to try the pasta, wine, and more.
google avatar

Kendra V.

Yelp
I love this restaurant and continue to recommend it to everyone I know. The service provided here is always prompt, friendly, and the servers and knowledgeable about the menu. The food is incredible. Everything I have had here is flavorful and delicious. The portions are generous, the prices and reasonable. The ambiance is elevated but not pretentious. Their wine and cocktail list is diverse. The Chianti Classico is my personal favorite. I got the Sal's Bolognese Pappardelle which was flavorful and well balanced. I also got the Vesuvius Bee Sting which was cooked to perfection with the pizza crust soft and pillowy and the sauce, cheese, and toppings mixing perfectly. I will absolutely be back.
google avatar

Celeste G.

Yelp
Nice looking place. Not too loud could hear my husband perfectly. Service was great. Food was delicious. Had a pizza and a drink. Didn't care for the drink. Pizza was good.
google avatar

Erica W.

Yelp
I usually eat pizzas and pasta dishes here. I always come here with my parents, and we share everything so we all have a taste of each dish. Food: 5/5. I don't recall ever having bad food. Service: 5/5. Service is pretty good. No one irritated me. Ha! That's a great compliment from me because I'm usually easily irritated. Environment: 5/5. It's clean and spacious. Only once did a kid act up but I didn't docket the restaurant. I just blamed the parents.
google avatar

Wakaba S.

Yelp
I went back there six months later and ordered the same cocktail - Green River Passport, because I liked it last time. However, what I got had a totally different look and taste, so I was really confused and disappointed. Fortunately, they were kind enough to switch it to wine for me and I really appreciated that. The pizza I ordered this time was Mamma Mia! without onions and less cheese. I liked it but I think I liked Pepperoni, which I had last time better. Nevertheless, it was wonderful once again and I'd be back for sure. Took one star off for my disappointment with the cocktail. But don't get discouraged by that!

Kristie G.

Yelp
Don't get me wrong the flavor was really good! The only thing that threw me off was the dough. Although the flavor was fresh and you could tell it was homemade, it was super thin which made the sauce soak into it which made it soggy really quick. It would've been soooo good if the pizza dough was a little thicker. Service was so amazing! Cute little spot!
google avatar

Nicole C.

Yelp
We came here for dinner when my husband was craving pizza. This had good reviews online so we stopped by. Parking was a nightmare like everywhere around here but the inside was upscale and modern. The inside was small but the place was relatively busy. The tiramisu drink was phenomenal, I had two. I definitely recommend if you like chocolate and coffee and sweet drinks. The whiskey drink at the top of the menu was also delightful. The other drink that was supposed to be more on the fruity side was a pass for both of us. Our waitress was cute and sweet. A younger gal. We began with the squash which was the BOMB. The cheese and crusty flakes gave the perfect mixture of smooth but crispy. It was delicious. The pizzas however were too soft for us. The crust was good and the toppings were fresh and yummy. However, there was hardly any crust under the toppings and the pizza was saggy. You could barely eat it by picking it up. It was yummy but not the best.

Harold W.

Yelp
I ordered 2 pizzas off their menu. Nothing added, nothing special. It took over an hour for them to make those 2 pizzas. When I asked if that was normal the girl said "if you don't want to wait I you can get get refund"
google avatar

Sarah S.

Yelp
So happy to be able to get a downtown experience right in Kaimuki with parking and no traffic! I called ahead and was told they were booked but that we could walk in to sit at the bar . Luckily they were able to squeeze us in for a perfect pre concert meal. Brick Fire Tavern, not to be confused with Brick Oven Pizza, is located on the same block as Brew'd on Waialae Ave. DRINKS: I started with a Green River Passport cocktail. It was beautiful but I felt like the taste didn't live up to my expectations from the description. My friend got a glass wine. FOOD: The menu offers appetizers, salads and pastas, but they specialize in Neapolitan pizza. Apparently they are the only restaurant in Hawaii certified to make it. Our server with a cool name, Holiday, explained that the owner, Matt, went to Italy to get special training for it and brought back a special brick oven. Apparently there are strict rules that must be followed to make this pizza. Since I wasn't that hungry, I hesitated to get a whole 12" pizza for myself. But since it was their specialty I ordered a Margherita. I needn't have worried as the thin crusted pizza was easy to eat with it's delicious herbaceous San Marzano tomato sauce. Our server warned us that this style pizza is soft in the middle so we knew what to expect. I did like the thinness but I prefer my crust less floppy and a little more stiff. (there's a joke here but I'm not going there. lol) I thought I would have leftovers to take home but failed. My friend got the spicy vodka pasta which was cooked just right and not very spicy. It came with a nice Calabrian sausage,We shared everything including a chop salad which balanced out our meal. This Dowtown transplant is a lovely addition to our Kaimuki restaurant row!
google avatar

Van K.

Yelp
Meatballs were great, maybe I'm not refined as some of you all are, but why is the pizza here slimy, floppy and tasteless? Respect to the region of Neapolitan or Mr. Neapolitan, but hell nahh! We tried both the Mamma Mia and New Yorker and both were lacking flavor. Service though here is impressive, very chill and personable.
google avatar

Kingston W.

Yelp
The Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana (AVPN) is an international organization, officially established by a group of Neapolitan people, representing the oldest families of pizza makers. This organization was later officially established by the Italian government as a denomination of control (DOC), a designation that made the AVPN a legal entity able to give special designations to pizzerias who meet the strict requirements that respect the tradition of the art of Neapolitan pizza making. The point of all this is that "Brick Fire Tavern" is the only (VPN) certified pizzeria on Oahu. Although it's not listed on the website, Brick Fire Tavern has a prix fixe lunch menu ($24). I took the option that provided a salad and personal sized pizza. I ordered a local beer ("Maui Sunshine Girl @ $9). There was a 3% surcharge; but I liked that they described it as a "kitchen appreciation fee" ($1.04). With tax ($1.55) my ticket was $35.59, before gratuity. The Ceasar Salad was very nice; it was much more than I expected--both in terms of serving size and how elaborately it was assembled. The Funghi pizza was very good. As this is a Neapolitan style pizza, I suppose it's better to focus on the bread. The crust is not the thin style common with most pizzas. In my mind, the best way to describe it is like a freshly baked pita--but its thin; soft; a bit spongy, providing a nice chewing experience. Double check the restaurant hours. They close for a break after lunch, before dinner (from 02:00p to 04:00p). The dining room is comfortable. There is seating at the bar. The bar offers beer, wine and cocktails. Parking is a bit of a coin toss. Sometimes there's street parking, and parking behind the building; sometimes you've got to look around a bit. But these caveats aside, the food here is good; its different.
google avatar

Lisa W.

Yelp
What a great place! Great service and delicious foods. From the person that answers the phone to the person that greats you and serves you....all so friendly and efficient. The ingredients in the salads and pizzas were fresh. Best to make a reservation such as with Open Table.
google avatar

Greg T.

Yelp
Long overdue review/update. This place is an absolute must for anyone that loves great, no, outstanding food, ambiance, service, and just a great dining experience. They really do it right here, fresh ingredients combined to bring out the most robust of flavors from pizza to the best Caesar salad one could ask for. If it isn't apparent yet, I am a true fan of this restaurant/bistro. We have been on several occasions at this point and the consistency is amazing, anytime, and every time. Please do yourself, family, and friends a favor and get out and support this establishment, we need more like it, that's for sure!
google avatar

Gary W.

Yelp
Very nice place for some great pizza. Smart casual is how I would describe those in the restaurant (we showed up after a day of sweating and hiking and felt under dressed! We ran back to the hotel and cleaned up before our reservation time. Lol) Great pizza with excellent crust and toppings much like you find in Italy. Good service and friendly staff.
google avatar

Justin H.

Yelp
TL;DR Delicious Neopolitan pizzas and al dente pastas in the heart of Kaimuki. BFT Chop Salad = ONO Porcini Rigatoni = ONO Spicy Vodka = ONO Margherita Pizza = ONO ----- Mmmm, I love this place. My wife and I were craving both pizza and pasta and decided to visit BFT. We had done takeout a few times a while ago but never dined in, so we were both excited. Parking is a bit tricky. I believe there's a tiny lot off 9th Ave, but typically in this area you're searching (and hoping) for street parking. We started with the chop salad, which was fantastic. The lettuce was crisp, there were a lot of different textures and flavors, and the dressing was on point. For pasta, we went with the porcini rigatoni (absolutely must order if you love mushrooms), which is always a banger, and the spicy vodka, which was also delicious. The pastas were perfectly al dente and sauced. So damn good. Lastly, the margherita pizza was just awesome. My daughter devoured her slices, which is always a solid indicator. I'm excited to return to BFT and try other items on the menu!

Anicea C.

Yelp
My favorite neighborhood spot. I would consider Brickfire one of the best places in Oahu to get a cocktail. Lots of Italian liqueurs, well balanced and creative.
google avatar

Panapa W.

Yelp
We got the meatball appetizer and specialty pizza! The meatballs and bread was perfect - freshly made and served hot! The specialty pizza had a vodka sauce that was to die for and the crust was amazing . . . Perfect. The atmosphere and service were top notch - drinks refilled and table cleaned after each portion . . . perfect.
google avatar

J M.

Yelp
Service is very poor. Rude staff. Pizza is smaller now than before and yet price went up.

Jeff M.

Yelp
I've never raved about a soup before until I went to this place. Also their starter dishes are out of this world and their entrées are fantastic. I'm not a pizza guy so I can't tell you about their pizza other than it looks fabulous, but I stopped eating pizza when I was a kid, but Very popular and it's not a pizza place. It's an Italian restaurant that will also serve pizza but they do a fabulous job.. Bartenders are excellent and flexible on the way you want your drink some people make it new school some people make a drink old school some people make it with a flare. They're willing to do whatever you wanna do. . Excellent service nice nice people work there product is fresh as can be and impossible to walk out of there without saying that was worth it and the prices were reasonable a all-around great lunch from 11 AM to 2 PM with a short break closing till 4 pm reopening and then I guess they close around 11. You'll have to check the hours but trust me when I tell you a must have in your tummy Yummy yummy yummy in your tummy.
google avatar

Nami P.

Yelp
Best pizza, pasta & cocktails. Service was excellent. I love both front & back seating area. I came here a few times and I had such a wonderful experience every time. Overall 5|5
google avatar

Richard L.

Yelp
First time here for Mother's Day Lunch for my wife and mother-in-law. My son actually was the one who picked this place who was here 2 days ago with his Geema and Papa. He loved this place and he said, this is now his favorite Italian place. He's 14 years old and he was spoiled by his papa and knows what good quality food taste like...lol. I was pleasantly surprised when I walked in this place...loved the ambience and the vibe with the music playing in the background. We loved the food here. Food is great...delicious from the starters we ordered (clams and ceasar salad) to our main entrees (clams risotto, pizza, butternut pasta, pizzas, and the meat ball dish) and we ended with a bang at the at end...we ordered the top 4 dessert on the dessert menu so we can all try it as we were in a group of 6. All 4 desserts we ordered were delicious. I would recommend all four and would ordered all again when we come back. Yes, we'll definitely be back more often... yes that's how good this place is. Our server was awesome...he provided a 5 star service. I would rather go here now over Assagios.
google avatar

Emily S.

Yelp
Their pizza, pasta, and Caesar are sooo bomb! When I ate there, it was unbelievable--1000/10. I tried takeout once and the Caesar was kind of mid, but the pizza and pasta were still amazing!

Bryan W.

Yelp
It has a nice family atmosphere. The pizza and pasta dishes were simple and without much flavor. The serving amounts were very small. The service is good.
google avatar

Roman M.

Yelp
The photos don't do the food justice. Firstly, the staff member Annie went above and beyond with service, absolutely phenomenal kindness and professionalism. The Satriale's Pizza was so good, with full of rich flavor. The star of the show really was the bolognese. Typically a basic dish, I'm not always a fan of bolognese unless it's done well. Let me tell you, this was some of the best I've had, with so much flavor and juiciness....10 out of 10. Highly recommend, will be back.
google avatar

Jim C.

Yelp
It's been years, like before pandemic, since I last visited Brick Fire. The experience was different from the cozy Chinatown location to the larger Kaimuki restaurant. But the food was delicious still. You love pizza? I love pizza! But this is authentic Neapolitan pizza. It's done right. It taste great! I thoroughly enjoyed the service. Each course was plated and serviced with the right utensils, plates and bowls. They turn the plates and utensils! No soup drippings or empty clam shells left behind when the pizza arrived. The staff from the front to the back, provided us an elevated dining experience.

Stephanie S.

Yelp
Delicious!!! So yummy would totally recommend. Definitely worth the wait. We ordered Ceasar salads and margarita pizza and they did not disappoint. Service was fast and attentive, we enjoyed our lovely waitress. Will 100% be coming back when in Oahu again!!!!!
google avatar

K O.

Yelp
1/2/25 Thin floppy chewy crust Bottom slightly scorched from brick oven Had the Mama Mia... not overloaded w sauce n toppings unlike those overstuffed commercial pies But it works for me flavor seasoning n texture wise Support Local
google avatar

Marissa K.

Yelp
Absolutely love this place! I went for a bday dinner and love how there's a back area private section. We ordered bunch of appetizers to start - chef's salad, garlic & fennel clams, and Hauula tomato & burrata. For the entree I shared proscittto arugula pizza and their bolognese pappardelle. Dessert we shared coffee gelato and cannolis. Everything was delish and service was great!
google avatar

Rob B.

Yelp
Saturday night, the parking meters are free after 6pm on the street. I love the bistro style decor, open and bustling. Service is friendly but also extremely leisurely. While we weren't rushed, it was a good 15 minutes being greeted and another 15 to place an order. The meatballs were delicious and really beautiful! The clams had a tasty broth but were small and not a great choice. Pizzas were all delicious will try the pasta next time.
google avatar

Connor S.

Yelp
Overall our experience was fine. The food was incredible. And the place was very local pizza-y. It had history on the walls and showed what was made fresh. We got the meatballs and burrata as an appetizer, both were delectable. I ordered a Margherita pizza and added pancetta while my friend got a pepperoni pizza. Both were delicious. The crust is fantastic, thin and chewy but great flavor The main complaint we had was service was slow. At first it seemed like they had 1 server doing the job of the host, bartender, and a server. However that changed about midway in our meal when we noticed 2 other servers working. Overall a fine experience would definitely go back for the food
google avatar

Erica H.

Yelp
I visited for lunch with a friend, and while it was busy, we were seated immediately. Great, friendly service. The food was delicious! We shared Spicy Vodka pasta and a Fungi pizza, and wrapped up with Tiramisu and French Press. Again, delicious! No photos because I guess I was too busy enjoying the scene! Parking at the meters or neighboring lot for a nominal fee. Casual to semi dressy for lunch. Closes at 2pm for a couple of hours before dinner. Spacious. Clean, clean restrooms. Full bar.
google avatar

D Z.

Yelp
The Porcini Rigatoni is just divine! I definitely can't replicate this at home. Their homemade pasta is al dente. I couldn't identify all the perfectly blended herbs use to make this heavenly mushroom cream sauce. Pizza is Neapolitan style, very thin, pillowy crust, and you eat it with a fork and knife. See photo of my pizza going in the oven, The service is exceptional. The way they describe each dish - you know that they've had tastings from the kitchen, and can suggest what wines pairs well with it. When your waitress ask you, what flavors do you prefer and recommends appropriate dishes, then comes to check if everything is okay; that's when you know they are professionals. They were there to make sure you had a pleasant dinning experience. I'm a little tip stressed. I have seen 30% as an option for diner/family style places - heck no. If you want 30% tip take a lesson from this crew on service. They are so professional, they don't even suggest a % tip on the bill. They do have a 3% kitchen appreciation fee and it is well deserved - the food was awesome. Update: I throughly enjoyed my dining experience. However the pizza at room temperature was not received well by the family. The thin pillowy crust became very chewy at room temperature. Grandma who likes her pizza fully loaded with toppings called it anorexic pizza.
google avatar

Kim B.

Yelp
Three and a half stars. Decided on pizza for lunch and after the reviews were excited for the pistachio cheesecake everyone was raving about. We get in at 1 and they seated us. We all had a drink. The non alcoholic one was interesting with the hint of Italian almond flavoring. It was quite refreshing. The beer is just beer and refreshing and goes perfectly with pizza (in my opinion) We ordered two pizzas. They both were delicious and the crust was what I enjoyed the most. Chewy and a little bit of char taste and the toppings were fresh. The choice of the pistachio cheesecake was NOT an option and that bummed us out because we wanted that. lol. It will be on the menu later they said. It was a great little place with a lot of tables. The staff is friendly and it's a perfect pizza place. The prices were pretty fair because rent must be high in kaimuki and add all expenses to run a place, I get it. It was a pretty good spot for last minute decisions.
google avatar

Irene M.

Yelp
Keep it Kaimuki... Making it with an outing with a friend that I haven't seen in awhile we decided to head over to Kaimuki since she had an aunt who lives jus a block from Brick Fire Tavern yay! We already knew this would be the place for lunch but browsed around Waialae first checking out the amazing biz celebrating all the wonderful product you can find here on this Black Friday Weekend as we all kicked off the holidays as well. Walking in we were so amazed how roomy it was as you can smell that brick oven going strong cooking up some pizzas we are so ready to consume. We decided on the Bruschetta Caprese to start which is a nice rustic appetizer as a super thick slice of City Loaf from neighboring Breadshop is topped with fresh mozzarella, marinated tomatoes, drizzle of balsamic and torn basil. Taking that first bite is a struggle with tomatoes rolling everywhere I do love that rustic touch but having bites that is too hard to eat and rolling on your clothing is not exactly fun. Asking about their pizza we were wondering how big it was and was told that it's made on a thin crust and is 12" so that it would be a breeze to finish it by yourself so we did just that as I got the "Funghi" pretty much says it all Mushrooms, mozzarella, fontina and thyme, fresh and classic it was very good though for the price not sure if I'd order it again as good it was it was still missing something that I wish I could think of...probably it was just too simple for me. Bestie ordered "Da "Shrimp Truck"" and this seafood lover loved her pie though struggled with the richness of it all lol! The pizzas here are good using fresh ingredients and showcasing exactly that versus drowning it all in sauces though the simplicity of it does leaves me with wanting more, as we got the pizza fresh out of the oven without that pull we all search for since it's fired for just 90 seconds it was a bit difficult to eat. Thank you!
google avatar

Kristie C.

Yelp
Very tasty pizza, friendly service in a rather nice but casual location. Wouldn't necessarily do the $40 r/t Uber from Waikiki here again haha, but I'm glad we went at least once. The only certified Italian pizza joint in Oahu apparently, with special water filters and an oven from Naples that cooks pizza in 90 seconds at 1000 degrees! *FOOD* - Pizza dough was excellent, but I would say the toppings could be more unique /uniquely Hawaii. I did miss the tomato a little on the mushroom pizza. - Salad was good, but no option to add chicken or shrimp sadly - Bruschetta was a large portion and tasty but nothing to write home about. - Nutella calzone was the star of the show IMO
google avatar

Wendy S.

Yelp
This was the best birthday experience! Even though we didn't have reservations we were seated fairly quick even though we were at the bar. I prefer this since I could sit next to my partner. We started with the bread and was amazing. The pizza has the perfect amount of meat since they don't skimp out! The pasta was amazing as well as the sauce. I need to checkout the Onda next time! They were so sweet to bring out ice cream and candle. There was exceptional service at the bar and we always come back. The inside is always busy but we love seeing the dynamic and everyone is so happy. 10/10
google avatar

Nick S.

Yelp
Came here for lunch and was surprised by the amazing pizza! Great friendly service and great atmosphere! Will for sure be back. 10 year old say this is the best pizza he's ever had!
google avatar

D L.

Yelp
This was our first visit to Brick Fire. It was a Sunday early evening. We found parking in the back and were seated promptly. The place is clean, the staff is friendly. Our server was Holiday. Clean plates were exchanges for the different courses and water was refilled on a timely basis. Our party if four ordered the little neck clams and the BFT Chop Salad too start. We really liked the salad. For entrees we ordered the asparagus Gnocchi, the Mamma Mia pizza, the pasta bolognese with meatball, and a starter House meatball. For dessert we had the Nutella canzone, the tiramisu, which is not on the regular menu, and the caramel macchiato cannoli. With drinks our bill was about $200.00 The stars of the evening was the Chop salad. The meatball and sauce was delicious. The starter portion came with toasted foccacia bread which was good. And the cannoli was crisp, the filling light and tasty.
google avatar

Jackson H.

Yelp
This is probably my first Yelp review in years. I try to experience as many restaurants as I can, especially when on vacation. All I have to say is this is hands down a top 5 on the island for Italian. My wife and I come to Oahu very often. We popped over to a little shop nearby for our daughter. Saw this place on Yelp and decided let's give it a shot. The spicy vodka genuinely rivals Carbones spicy rigatoni. The servers are incredible, ambiance is great, and food is out of this world. Regardless of what pizza you get, ask for a side of hot honey. It's really a nice touch. I was lucky enough to run into the chef next door at the pasta shop making food for the night and paid my respects. We will definitely be back.
google avatar

Jaime R.

Yelp
At Brick Fire Tavern in Waikiki, Honolulu, HI, the dining experience is as close as you can get to authentic Italian on the islands. The Caesar salad is a refreshing start, with crisp romaine lettuce, tangy Caesar dressing, and perfectly shaved Parmesan cheese. The star of the show, however, is undeniably the meatballs, which are succulent, flavorful, and melt-in-your-mouth delicious. Do save room for the Napoli style pizza. Brick Fire Tavern is a must-visit for those seeking true Italian flavors in the heart of Waikiki.
google avatar

Young P.

Yelp
Jan 2024. Full disclosure, me not a fan of Napolitano style pizzas but this pie is damn good. Don't get me wrong, I still prefer a slice at Joe's Pizza but I can't lie, I actually like this. The crust is chewy but not doughy and the sauce and toppings are 10/10 taste and presentation. Their caesar salad also is damn good. Fresh local greens and perfectly seasoned w their own dressing. Service was excellent. Professional but with warm aloha. The ambiance also great. Perfect for lunch or dinner w friends or date night. My gf tried 2 of their signature cocktails and she loved them both. Said the drinks were legit. I'm a fan of this pizza spot.
google avatar

Jenny C.

Yelp
What a fantastic place! My family just left here and had such a great lunch! If you are craving authentic Italian food then this is the spot for you. Homemade meatballs in a delicious marinara that was accompanied by focaccia. The clams were served with a rustic bread that was perfect for soaking up the delicious broth that the clams were served in. This was just the start to our meal. We also had pizza and a bolognese pappardelle pasta dish. My father, who is Italian, loved the pasta. Of course, we had to get dessert too. Pistachio cheesecake with the Oreo cookie crust was my favorite! The decor is very bright and clean. I love the history of Italian food that is along one of the walls too. The service was great as well. Thank you to Richie and the rest of the staff. Will be back for sure!
google avatar

Joyce L.

Yelp
Brick Fire Tavern takes pizza to another level of good pizza. The great gourmet taste of pizza will be fresh in my mind that I probably won't be eating any of that fast pizza joints for awhile. This was our birthday dinner. We ordered the mushroom pizza, the special of the day pizza, seafood risotto, and caesar salad. The pizza crust is very soft, has a slight burnt taste with very thin pizza bottom. It's almost like pizza made out of crepe style texture but good. The special of the day pizza consist of Prosciutto or some Italian cured meat, blue cheese, and walnuts. It was the perfect combination of Italian pizza. So good! Seafood risotto was also good. Caesar salad was made fresh, just right and not over powering with dressing. If you like adult drinks they have plenty. We tried few different canned beers. Aside from the awesome food, service was awesome. My family reserved a table. They served us birthday complimentary vanilla ice cream which was also light and refreshing. My husband love the fact that they served in a chilled bowl so that the ice cream doesn't melt instantly. An extra touch like that is rare these days and adds to the superb service. We also ordered pistachio cheese. It was also very light and good. You can see the brick oven in the corner of the restaurant where most of the staff are working hard. Yes, it is an open kitchen with urban feel. Ok, so I will be back because I want to try more pizza and their cobb salad. Free parking is available behind the restaurant. I recommend making a reservation.
google avatar

Stephanie L.

Yelp
Last night I went to BFT for the second time and I still love them! The first time I went with a GF for a girl's night and we shared a pasta and pizza. I believe the menu changes seasonally because last night, the dishes were slightly different. The first time I had: Pea & Prosciutto Pizza -Creamy and gorgeous. I hope they bring this flavor back! The pizza was beautifully done. The sauce was light, the prosciutto provided the perfect touch of savory, and the pillows of cheese were creamy and light. Sal's Bolognese Pappardelle -The sauce for the bolognese was deep, rich, meaty and the pappardelle was perfect. I love those wide pasta noodles so much. Last night I went with my partner and sister and we had: Caesar Salad -The caesar dressing was so good! My sister felt like the salad could've used more dressing, but I enjoyed the dressing as is. The romaine lettuce was coated thoroughly with a generous shaving of parmesan cheese. -Carbonara Roma Pasta I'm torn about this one. The carbonara was thick and a little flour-y. I'm not sure if this is how the pasta was supposed to taste. My sister was not a fan but my boyfriend enjoyed it. The guanciale was crispy in the pasta which was a nice touch. -Veggie Monster V3 Pizza I loved this pizza! I love veggies and this pizza had a little bit of everything from arugula, red onions, mushrooms, basil, and crumbles of blue cheese which I loved! -"Pepperoni" Pizza This was a great pizza to enjoy. The sauce was yummy and soppressata was delicious! Lastly I want to comment on the service last night (Thursday 1/4/24). We felt like we were in a fine dining restaurant. Our servers were extremely attentive even in a full house. Our dishes were cleared between the salad and entrees, our waters were constantly refilled, and even the root beer that was ordered, the servers took it upon themselves to top off the soda in the glass until the bottle was empty and they took it away. Like, whoa. Anyways, I love BFT for a cute date night with friends! It isn't like an overly formal place where you feel stuffy, but not so casual that you lack energy to go out. It's just a great spot for a nice meal!
google avatar

Randy S.

Yelp
A good example of a Neapolitan pizza. No ... not pizza Napoletana from Naples. But they are Vera Pizza Napoletana certified. So no apologies. no excuses, right? Why, then, wasn't I satisfied? The pizza checks the right boxes. A dough of Italian type 00 wheat flour, water, yeast, salt, that is cold proofed two days. Baked 60-90 seconds in a 900 degree (+ or -) brick lined wood fired oven. More sauce than cheese leaving the middle soggy. Thin soft crust that needs to be folded, or better, eaten w knife and fork. Nice leopard spotted char. It has to do with the crust. It was chewy, mildly salty, nutty, with a proper slight bitter char. But, I was looking for an airy bubbly edge and a firmer base. The base was moist, tasted slightly undercooked, and hard to cut. The crust was more like a focaccia than the airy, blistered charred edge I was hoping for. And, while they did a nice job spreading the dough I prefer an uneven round shape and pinched edges. I don't know enough to say if it was a matter of using a chilled dough to make a more perfect round shape, too much sauce, maybe needing a few more seconds exposed to the fire or placed closer to the heat, or the airiness of the oven (the optimal temperature of an oven is more than the temperature right around the heat source). I just know it could have been, should have been better. None the less, this is still a good Neapolitan pizza.