Broad Nosh Bagels Deli & Catering 58th Street

Went on a late Saturday morning. It was super crowded, but they do keep things moving, so it does go at a decent pace. My wife had a Philly, which was very good. I ordered an open face bagel and lox. I thought it would be just the one half bagel with cream cheese and smoked fish on top, but it was two halves. Given how big it was with both halves, I thought it was a pretty darn good value. But more importantly, it was incredibly delicious. For one person, it was too much. But I could see it being shared between two people easily. We got berry blast smoothies, which were also very good. There was so much more there, I would have liked to have tried, but there's only so much you can do / eat in a single visit. But they had coffee, a huge assortment of cream cheeses, and many other baked goods that looks really good. As busy as it was, I would definitely have no problem recommending it. Being just a visitor to New York city, I can't say it's the best bagel ever, or even among the best. However, as a bagel rube, it was fantastic to me. Also, it was very conveniently located.

We absolutely loved their Everything bagel with the lox spread. Their bagels and the ingredients were so fresh and high quality compared to the other NYC bagel stores we have tried. The place has a very cozy vibe, and the owner, Robert, is super friendly. Robert would personally come to chat with his customers, leading to an overall great experience. Overall 5 out of 5 for breakfast, lunch, brunch, or dinner or even for a quick snack or coffee break. Highly recommended place to try out and keep coming in NYC. We sure will be coming back! :)

We stopped off for an early breakfast. Slightly overwhelmed by the sheer number of choices for the bagels and fillings, everyone seemed to know exactly what they wanted... except us! I went with the lox filling, really good, soft bagel, fresh ingredients, and lots of it. Definitely worth a visit! Judging by the endless stream of customers and the queue, it's very popular!

Fantastic bagels. Went two mornings. First morning had bacon and egg on everything bagel - it was delicious! Second morning I got a toasted jalapeno cheddar bagel with scallion bacon cream cheese. That was amazing! Most generous serving of cream cheese I have ever had!! Now you have to be ready for the crowd and wait! It was super busy both days, had to wait about 20mins. First day we had ordered and paid but waited a while for order to get ready. Second day there seemed to be confusion with line up to order and pay and our order was ready a long time before we got to pay. It was all worth it though! Just bring your patience!

super packed when we got here on a Monday morning around 11am! Ordering line was efficient though! We got a toasted poppy seed bagel with tofu garlic and herb cream cheese with egg, tomato and lettuce. The bagel itself was HUGE, I’d say a bit bigger than the typical bagels we find in NYC. Everything was super yum but one disappointing factor was how badly the breakfast sandwich was structured. It was loose, not sure cause of the big bagel or maybe how moist it was but after that first bite, the ingredients inside the sandwich started to move around then it got messy to eat. Don’t get me wrong, it was a good sandwich! Just needs to be restructured for better eating purposes. We also got bagels to-go to bring back on the plane and they were just as amazing toasted when we got home!!!

Worth the wait!! (Which for us was about 40 mins on a Sunday morning at 10a). We ordered 2 bagels with scallion cream cheese! Delicious cream cheese spread! Bagels were on point- soft on the baked a with a perfect crunch on the outside! Each bagel with cream cheese was $5.25. Line is deceiving- outside on sidewalk may be short, but it wraps inside and they make everything fresh so you wait your turn til your number is called.

Amazing place with a warm and welcoming atmosphere! The owner was incredibly kind—he personally greeted us, had a friendly chat, and even treated us to a complimentary bagel with mango cream cheese. We ordered three different types of bagels with various fillings, along with pancakes, and everything was absolutely on point. The portions were generous, and the flavors were spot on. Highly recommend this spot for a great meal and excellent hospitality!

I absolutely love bagels. So I give this one a great approval.. they have such a selection in variety. the workers are very quick and efficient. the problem is the place is not big enough. They do have seating inside and outside .because they are very popular there is a line that you wait on. Which I think is definitely worth it but if you have time constraints, forget about it.. It was very good. I got a half a dozen bagels just to take back to North Carolina with me and will be going back as soon as I can.