Bronx House Pizza Nocatee

Kayleigh was an excellent server and very personable. She made some excellent recommendations and made my wife, daughter and I feel like regulars even though this was our first time dining in the establishment. We ordered the veggie pizza, meatball sliders, garlic knots and the tuxedo chocolate dessert. Everything we ordered was a 10 out of 10. All of the staff was extremely welcoming, positive and the restaurant in general just had a great vibe. My daughter is only 5 years old and is a very picky eater but she ate all of her food and even ate some of mine and my wife’s food. Thank you for an excellent meal and a great dining experience.

First time at Bronx pizza and not from the area. FOOD: Ordered a sausage and pepperoni pizza and some mozzarella sticks. Pizza was good and mozzarella sticks taste like this I buy at the store and heat up. My reason for a low review is I brought myself and two children here after a long day of travel and thought it was just a call in and order and pick up. I didn’t know there was seating inside. So I just asked the staff and was turned down and told it was “Dine in only”. I get there are rules but there was over 10 tables vacant and it just soured our first experience with this pizza chain. I’m just not familiar with the rules or whatever. So we just ate the pizza outside the restaurant lol

I love Bronx Pizza in Nocatee! What really sets them apart is the amazing staff. Everyone is always courteous, cheerful and happy to help. You can tell that this is no accident, and absolutely flows down from the leadership at the top. Bronx Pizza is a welcome addition to the community! Every menu item I’ve had is great. If you want an epic cheese pull, try the one of the Detroit Pan pizzas or a calzone. Their hero sandwiches are full of flavor and indulgence if you want to give those a try - definitely big enough to share. And, of course, you can’t go wrong with a traditional New York slice, or any of their featured dishes.

Closest to NY pizza in Jacksonville IMO. Great tasting pizza, fantastic under carriage and flop. You can hold the slice with a few toppings and it held up. Gets a bit busy in the evenings and pizza to the table can be slow so would recommend ordering an app if you are super hungry. The pizza bread was a tiny bit dry but otherwise great pizza, fantastic sauce and well cooked toppings. They have tried to create a NYC atmosphere but falls quite short. It’s only a couple of train themed wall hangers but otherwise not much NY feel. They got the pizza right though :).

I was so impressed with this new restaurant! My family and I are from the Bronx, NY and we loved it. Great service, great prices, and very clean! Will definitely be coming back. Make sure to get the garlic knots, they are to die for. The cheese pizza is just like home and the cannoli’s are perfect!!

It was a delight to dine here tonight for my friends birthday party. they are very accommodating and have yummy garlic food. thank me you, see next! 👩🏾‍🦱

Jenn (Bartender/waitress) took great care of us! I tried the mango margarita. Uniquely different, yet delicious. We had the garlic knots and chicken marsala (large portion, easily two people could feast on for lunch) I personally liked the fried chicken with the marsala. My partner would've preferred the chicken grilled. We will be back to try the chicken parm.

I will drive all the way to nocatee to have this pizza. It is delicious and is definitely a treat. So far I have only had the deep dish and the regular pizza. I have not tried any of their other items. They do have a bar with draft beer and cocktails. The only thing I don't suggest is sitting in the row by the takeout counter. They typically have a long line of takeout and the line bumps up against the seated patrons.

great service, really cool ambiance! above all the food was amazing. Great pizza, they nailed the crust as well as any place in town. and the Meatballs were fantastic, pause.

We came here on a whim because our little one wanted garlic knots. We were a little worried because it was Saturday around 5:30pm and we know how busy this location gets. To our surprise, we walked in and more than half the restaurant was empty, so our party of 7 was seated quickly. Steven was our server. He greeted us, and quickly took our drink orders. I ordered a lemon drop martini, my kiddo ordered club soda, and my husband ordered their Bronx House Ale. All drinks came out quickly, and the drinks for the kids came with lids (thank goodness). We ordered my kiddo's garlic knots and the kids meals to come out first while we looked over the menu. Garlic knots came out hot and quickly. My kiddo ate almost the whole plate (this was his meal lol) and only took one home. I ordered the chicken milanese, my husband ordered the chicken ceasar salad. Everything came out pretty quickly. My milanese was perfectly cooked. The breading had a nice crisp and the salad was delicious. I especially love the salad dressing they use and asked for a side (which I received). Would I go back? Yes.

I can't believe how many quality ny/nj style pizza joints in this area, I feel like I am back in jersey. so far this is my second favorite for pizza in st Augustine area, and would gladly come again, it was so good. wife's calzone was insane as well, huge and delicious. been eating pizza like 3 times a week as I currently live in California and can't get a pie anywhere near what you guys get here. sadly will be heading back soon. place was a little loud which is fine, service was top notch as also seems to be outstanding for the area. everywhere we go from Ponte Verda to Flagler beach the people are just incredibly nice and helpful

We've gotten pizza from here twice in two weeks, and it does NOT disappoint. Week one: I had the Popeye pizza which was an excellent version of a white pizza. They don't skimp on the garlic, which was delicious, but buyer beware. My husband had the Butcher Shop - their version of a meat lovers- and seemed to like it. Toddler loved her meatball in her spaghetti and meatball but oddly didn't love the sauce. Garlic knots were great. Week two: cheese calzone with added pepperoni, and a "Department of Sanitation" pizza. The calzone was quite good, but the pizza was exceptional. One of the best "works" pizzas I've had. They describe it as "a little bit of everything" and they do it just right because there is a little everything but not so much it weighs it down and the crust disintegrates. Would absolutely order again. Haven't experienced it in person yet, but will be a regular for the food quality for sure.

Food was good but service was great. We always love when Sandra is our server because she checks in often and makes sure everything is right. Tonight was very loud due to a couple of large parties.

Very good Detroit style pizza. Nice atmosphere, with a attractive bar Good addition to Nocatee.

Gave Bronx Pizza another chance. The food was phenomenal! The garlic knots, Hot 97 pizza and caesar salad were 5 stars. Our server was so good. I did not see her name on the receipt. Lastly the last time I went the happy hour was only at the bar. I put that on my review. I'm so glad the management let anyone get the happy hour. I ordered additional beverages even after the happy hour in thanks. The place is always clean. Such great flavor even their standard pizza.

I have ordered the eggplant Parmesan twice from here. While it's not my absolute favorite it's still good. Pros: they give you a good portion of food Their tomato sauce is really good, it's very flavorful and not bland at all. You can choose between penne or spaghetti. Get the penne, it has the perfect texture. The location is super convenient for me: Cons: the prices are high but you get a good portion you could easily split between two people. The heavy breading of the eggplant was too heavy for me personally. I will definitely order it again.

While I wish this location offered by the slice like the Ormond Beach location, Bronx House never disappoints. While we waited on our pie the owner brought us each a slice of a tester pie he had made for the crew. It was simply delicious and quite honestly just what we wanted. 1 plain cheese slice of pizza. We do pizza tours occasionally and honestly only want 1 slice per stop. No flop, nice undercarriage, sauce is super zesty. Solid 8.0

Follow up: (awkward and not good) : after my initial review, it was nice to see that it was taken seriously by Bronx Pizza mgmt. They encouraged me to get in touch with them to make things right. So based on this, I thought I'd give this location a second try: I placed an order online for a large pizza. I went into the store to pick it up then asked to speak to Alex or one of the managers and I was told that Johnny, one of the owners was there. Great I thought!! I asked to speak to him and he was making pizzas in the kitchen. Anyone could tell this guy was a stereotypical New Yorker because he has no people skills whatsoever!! (Apologies to all the nice New Yorker's out there) I asked him if he was familiar with the deal they were offering a couple of weeks ago, he said he wasn't that familiar with it. So I told him I was there a couple weeks ago and didn't appreciate the fact that the deal wasn't honored when we were dining in. He looks at me and in stereotypical New Yorker attitude says "yeah that deal was take-out only" I said that no where did it say that". Next thing I know he's bitching at me: "so wadda you want?" Taken aback, all I said was "I'd like the deal, I just ordered a large pizza." He yells to the cashier "Give this guy the deal!, yeah he just ordered a pizza. Give him the deal with the garlic knots and salad!". So of course he was familiar with the deal, what a douche! This is the type of guy that gives all New Yorkers a bad rap. Unfortunately for Bronx Pizza, I won't be going to ANY Bronx pizza location EVER.

Yum yum!! NYC here we are. The pizza was like home here in Florida. We ordered a large pizza with sausage with mushrooms. Had a Greek salad as well and forgot to take a pic. But it was delicious, a lot of feta, red peppers, dolmades olives and peppericonos. It was a huge and could have fed 4 people. If you are from New York a must visit.

We preordered pizza and then came to pick it up. The parking lot was packed! Of course it was a Friday night, but man it was a hike after you park waaaay out there. We worked our way up to the pickup counter and another man was standing there, among other people. We didn't want to cut in line so we asked if he'd been helped. He was beyond frustrated because his order wasn't ready and it was way past the promised time. It was making him very late to be somewhere. Luckily, we didn't have any time constraints but the girls working the pick up counter were clearly in over their head. It seems so disorganized - they kept looking at the papers on the various items. Not sure if they couldn't read it easily, something is not working right. The inside of the restaurant was so noisy and crowded, I wouldn't have wanted to eat in. Glad we had it To Go. We ate the pizza after we got home and it was delicious! I would definitely order there again, but probably not on a Friday night.

I love Bronx Pizza in Nocatee! What really sets them apart is the amazing staff. Everyone is always courteous, cheerful and happy to help. You can tell that this is no accident, and absolutely flows down from the leadership at the top. Bronx Pizza is a welcome addition to the community! Every menu item I've had is great. If you want an epic cheese pull, try the one of the Detroit Pan pizzas or a calzone. Their hero sandwiches are full of flavor and indulgence if you want to give those a try - definitely big enough to share. And, of course, you can't go wrong with a traditional New York slice, or any of their featured dishes.

Food was quick, hot and on point. Server was pleasant honest and made good recommendations. We tried lots of apps. The whipped ricotta, the lasagna balls, the meatball sliders. We totally over ordered. And also had a pizza too. Very solid drink too We will be back to dry the Detroit style. Ny was delish

Always great food and great service. Hot, fresh, perfectly cooked food. Didn't have to wait even though it was a packed house on a Saturday night. Definitely try the Detroit style pizza! Extra crunch cheesy crust.

We randomly decided to have pizza one night and gave Bronx a try. I'm from Chicago and my husband spent time in NY. Our favorite by far was the calamari and ricotta cheese. So much flavor. The staff was nice and it wasn't too loud or anything so we didn't have to scream across the tables to have conversations.

I've been wanting to try Bronx House Pizza, so being near Nocatee and having a location there, we had to stop and give them a try. Bri, our server, was awesome; she guided us through the menu, was great, and very attentive. We started off with their garlic knots, a great choice, as they had the right amount of garlic and oil, along with shaved parmesan and marinara, making for a great start. We then ordered a personal pepperoni pizza with small pepperoni cups and extra cheese, which had great flavor, really good-tasting sauce, and a light, crispy crust, definitely large enough for two people. The salads looked large, so we ordered a chicken Caesar salad, which had flavorful chicken and dressing. Lastly, we were given a complimentary cannoli; needless to say, we left full and satisfied. They are in the process of opening a new location by Chubby's in Ponte Vedra on A1A.

Things got better. I have been back since and enjoyed their pizza and Chicken Parm Dinner and Chik Parm Hero. I will try the Meaball hero next. I guess they worked out the kinks. I wish they has they had NY style Sicilian pizza.

Update with an FYI to people who haven't been here before. BHP adds a charge to your bill if you pay with a credit card - very tacky and it requires me to downgrade my rating. The fee exceeds what the credit card processing costs - so they are just padding the bill instead of raising the price of food on the menu. As a small business owner, credit card processing is a cost of doing business. You roll it into your overhead and if necessary you raise your prices a little. The last time I visited here, I just deducted the credit card fee from the total. I won't pay it.

Me and the boys got some Bronx House carryout and it was yummmy. We ordered a salad, garlic knots, a calzone, and two sausage pizzas. The food was great and a good amount to share with the whole gang. We all gained a full stomach after feasting upon the food because we are biggins. The carryout/self-pickup is very efficient in giving us our food hastily even though there were lots of people waiting in line. I really like the cool interior with the NYC theming and efficiency for the small space of the restaurant. I go the Bronx House every once in a while and it's probably my favorite in Nocatee. Overall good filling eats, just keep in mind it could be on the pricier side.

My wife and I stopped in for lunch today, it was a great choice. The place was surprisingly quiet so there no waiting and the service was great. I ordered a pizza, my wife had meatball sliders, both were delicious. My pizza was called the Department of Sanitation because it had a little of everything on it. I like a lot of toppings and wasn't disappointed. My wife's sliders were very good and more than she could eat, we'll have a nice meal from the leftovers.

This is my new favorite, go to pizza place. Their claim is New York pizza. We have been there three times now, and each time had the Butcher Shop. They have Detroit Deep Dish on the menu which we want to try on one of our future visits. The pizza was cooked to perfection and was sooo good. They have pasta dishes and salads on the menu as well. They have a full bar and draft beers. If you have room after your pizza indulgence, they even have desserts with cannoli on the menu. Inside restaurant has comfortable booth seating and bar has both bar seating and high top tables. Service has always been prompt and friendly. Parking can be a challenge so suggest visiting for lunch or early dinner.

Ordered a Detroit style pizza (The Red Top with pepperoni, sausage and jalapeños) to-go and it did not disappoint! The crust was crispy, sauce was nice and lightly sweet and the cheese and toppings were marvelous. Ordered ahead of time for 5:30pm and it was ready by 5:33! The inside was bustling and the people were very friendly. I ordered a glass of wine while I waited (I came in a little early) and although the wine was a little pricey for what it was and it could've been colder, but the overall ambiance was welcoming and very NY. They also charge a credit card fee, so be aware of that. I will definitely go again to try their NY style pizza.

I love it when the restaurant is so good you spin the block a couple times in one week! That's exactly what Bronx House did for me! I was there for date night and again with a friend and both times were a hit! This is the first Bronx House to open in our area and they are serving up authentic Italian cuisine and I tried a variety of menu items! Every single thing I tasted was delicious! EVERYTHING! For starters, I can't say enough great things about The Fat Paulie sandwich! Just sprinkle on some Parmesan and drizzle some hot honey and baby it's the bees knees! The garlic knots and sangria were fantastic too as well as the pizza! We tried both the Detroit and NY style and while both were delicious, the Detroit style won this round! The "Noc Out" Detroit style pan pizza is only served at this location and it is so yummy! It comes with chicken cutlets, San Marzano tomatoes, roasted garlic, burrata, and pesto! They are doing it right over at Bronx House so if you're in the mood for a good pizza, a good sandwich, some Italian food favorites, great customer service and all around good vibes, be sure to check out the Bronx House Pizza in Nocatee Towncenter!

Best pizza I've had in Florida so far! So excited to have them now open in PVB. Excellent pizza! Great service and quality cocktails too! Chicken parm sub, lasagna balls and salads all very good and large portions. Our once a week go to! Outside seating available too.

Food was so delish!! We got toasted raviolis and we're from stl so we know our toasted ravs. The burrata was funky but so good. Pizza was great. The pepperoni was bussin. Everyone is so nice and our server Jackie was so sweet!!! #shoutoutjackieandgiveheraraise

This was such a great little restaurant! And it was PACKED! Service was on point and so fast! I believe our servers name was Miles and he was fabulous! So kind and efficient! And the food.. ohh man-does if get any better than garlic knots sitting in cheesy butter goodness! And then the pizza.. ohh the pizza.. Detroit style is hands the best of the best! And Bronx knows how to do it! Thank you for fueling my husbands love of pizza and my pregnancy cravings!!

First and last visit to this restaurant. A kids menu without a slice of pizza? A kids pizza? Is this a pizza house or not? Then to continue the bad experience, the server says you can't half and half toppings on a 12" pizza. Only the large pizza. Is it too difficult to figure out how to achieve half and half ingredients on a smaller pizza? "It's a policy of the restaurant". Of course it is, but it's not printed on the menu. While we were waiting for our meals, we noticed none of the people in the kitchen wearing gloves. One of the employees was showing another one something on his cell and tapping the screen. Then he puts down the cell phone, and immediately starts chopping spinach without washing his hands. Then to top it off, they add a 3% service fee if you pay with a credit card. Are we still in 2020 during Covid? That ship has sailed. Back to Moon Dog Pie House where they treat their customers right - pizza slices, half and half toppings, clean standards, and no service charges.

Really good pizza place. I love their Detroit style pizza. Service is always great and the atmosphere is great too. I love the music they play.

First time checking out Bronx House Pizza we went to the ponte vedra location. Love the decor( reminds me of home in NY). The place was packed. We sat at a high top at the bar being that was first available. For starters the server recommended the lasagna rolls and then we ordered a pie "the beast of burden". Pepperoni, meatball, ricotta! Delish! The ricotta was the icing on the cake. Soo creamy and tasty. It made the meal. Good pepperoni, meatballs (meh), the lasagna balls were awesome. Flavorful, the sauce was incredible and that dollop of ricotta ( yumm) I would definitely try this place out. They are opening another location on 210 ( yea!!! Closer to my house!!)

I absolutely love their restaurant. The best meatball sliders on the planet. And it isn't close. The food is so good. But we have ordered the Detroit pizza to go three times now and it has been overcooked and dry and this time wasn't even what we ordered. The Nocatee location has amazing Detroit style pizza. Again the place is fantastic but I would stick to the meatball sliders and the NY pizza. Especially if you pick it up to go.

Mama Mia! That's some good pizza! After hearing/reading mixed reviews, I decided to make my own decisions in this place. First off,as soon as we walked in, we were greeted with a 30-minute wait, while looking over the restaurant, the decor brought back memories of the old hood. The brick and industrial design throughout. The subway signs also lends to the NYC vibe. So we stepped outside to wait, but before we even got down on the outside seating, we were called in to be seated. We ordered two pies as this was the sole purpose of this visit. Within 30 minutes of ordering, out came these beautiful looking pies. We had a cheese pie and a specialty pie called the "Big AL." Contrary to what I read/heard about their pies. I found the dough as I remembered it like NYC. Thin but firm, you should be able to fold it without the slice drooping in front. I found the sauce was not overly done, nor was it lacking. The cheese was perfectly balanced with just enough to string away from the slice when you pulled it. That crust was not overdone, with just the right amount char to it. Overall, the staff was very friendly and attentive. Watching the pies was also impressive as they were made in a unique oven, which appeared to use a multitier lazysusan technique that helps keep them from over cooking and easy to watch when ready to get pulled out. I must say we weren't disappointed by the size of the slices for the price. We also saw some of the other items as they went by our table and agreed they all looked delicious! My compliments on this fine restaurant and will be very happy to come back for another visit in the near future.

First time dining. Had excellent and attentive service. The Greek salad was huge and well made shared easily. The Detroit style pizza was different than any pizza the NYer has had as the crust is baked in cheese. Pizza was hot tasted delicious and more than the row of us could eat. Brought pieces home for lunch the best day. We were satisfied and will be back.

We've tried Bronx twice since they opened in Nocatee! The garlic knots are to die for! So tasty! The kids love the buffalo chicken pie. They are always ready for pickup at the time they give! We are so thankful to have a solid pizza place in the NOC!

Ordered Detroit style Haymaker Friday for take out. It was very good. Took the family there Saturday night. Ordered two kids pastas, a large pizza and a chickens Caesar salad. It was all delicious. Speedy service and quality pizza. Glad to have you in the NocaHood.

The Food was outstanding!! Meatballs bettter than my Nona!! Sauce was Very Good as well!! The service was extremely friendly and fast- considering it was opening weekend. We drove out from Orange Park to have Bronx House! And they did not disappoint!! The ambiance was classic NY Pizza house! Black & White tile...subway station signs. Great full bar and plenty of parking! However we were a little confused about the 3% surcharge for credit card payment?? But figured..."When in PonteVedra..." Still - we will be back!!

Horrible pizza and not that good of service at all the pizza is just boring and bland and I prefer papa John's over this place and this is just horrible and not consistent. It doesn't look the clean or organized at all. Thanks Lauren

I have missed NY pizza since moving from there 6 years ago. This place is great! We had an eggplant parm hero and a 'make your own pizza '. Both were delicious! And the service was great too! Will definitely be coming back!

This is easily the best pizza restaurant in town! The last time that we went, the workers gave my 3 year old daughter pizza dough, marinara and cheese to make her own pizza!!!! It was so much fun! Then they cooked the pizza for her and she got to eat the pizza that she made! The employees are always awesome and the service is impeccable! The chicken parm pizza is the best pizza that I've ever had! We love this place!

Good pizza good service at a fair price. Been twice and I'm going back for more. Full service bar doesn't hurt either

My family and I decided to try Bronx house tonight for the first time since moving to Nocatee. We were greeted right away by the host and she asked if we wanted to sit outside or inside. We said outside due to the restaurant being busy and it was nice outside. We sat down and about 1 minute later the server delivered the tables food next to us and walked right inside. My family then waited at the table for 20 mins with no acknowledgment. At the 20 minute mark the server returned, walked right past us. Again, no acknowledgment and checked on the table next to us. She then proceeded to walk back inside. At this point my family and I decided to leave. We were very disappointed as we were excited to try Bronx House Pizza as we heard great reviews. For us great food can't make up for the lack of good service.

A weekly if not 2x weekly affair for us!! Always trying something new on the menu. Today was another creative Detroit pizza. Great bar service from Xavier and team! Always great ingenuity from the back of the house! Great vibe with music up and lights down atmosphere. Like eating with friends and family. Thank you Bronx House team!

Pizza is ok. Ordered the eggplant parm tonight. So bad I threw it out. Never will I ever order an entree. Pizza at best .

Great pizza, the Popeyes pizza was amazing, as was the onion, tomato and Garlic (3 toppings build your own) true delicious NY style pizza!!

Nocatee waited almost a year to have its own pizza place. The locals are super excited to be able to pick up a pizza on their golf carts and not drive out of the community for a pie. Bronx House is a Nicely appointed place with red brick walls & street signs from The Bronx NY. It has a decent size bar separate from the dining area with a few TV's. As this was my 1st visit my husband & I decided to order a pie. Our server was a lovely girl & very attentive. We chose the chicken parmigiana pizza at $25.99 I asked the server if they had fresh basil & they did. I asked her to put some basil on 3 slices or 1/2 the pie. Now my review of the pie is as follows: The pie came out hot with ample cheese and sauce. The chicken was cut up into tiny cubes & was quite sparse. There was fresh basil as I requested on several slices. The pie crust was thick at the edges, it had a firmness to it and did not collapse when I folded a piece in half to eat ( NY style). Overall, the pizza was quite good however, this is not NY pizza. If you're expecting that you will be disappointed. If not you will really enjoy it. Now let's discuss the bill. The price for the pie was over $27. This included an up charge for the basil. An up charge for a condiment? I thought this was not acceptable since the pie was already expensive & when I inquired about basil upon ordering the server never said it was an up charge. I did question her about the bill & she said when she puts in the order it's computerized & she has no control of the price. She apologized & I did not blame her for the additional charge. Also, be aware as with many other restaurants there is a 3 % up charge to use a credit card. This is a place of convenience for me. I'm happy to have another addition & choice of where to dine without leaving the neighborhood should I want pizza.

Nothing special. Nice interior, ambience good. Service was friendly. Price was heavy but I am sure the rent is high. Prefer Balas or Primos.

We are New Yorker who are always disappointed by promises of New York style Italian food. But, here we found a home away from home! The food was outstanding and reminiscent of our favorite New York haunts, but elevated! Just delicious! We ordered the Noc Out Pan Pizza which was incredible! Also, try the lasagna balls appetizer! If you're lucky enough to get Brooke as your server, the her we said hey! She was friendly and very sweet and took great care of us!

This new pizza chain recently opened in Nocatee, so I figured I would check it out. They have ten booths, six regular tables, five hightop tables, and seats at the bar if you choose to dine there. They also do a lot of takeout orders. The menu has 8 specialty New York style pizzas, as well as build your own pizzas, and Detroit style pan pizza. They also have 10 appetizers, 6 salads, 6 pasta dishes, 6 entrees, 5 hero sandwiches, 4 calzones, and 3 desserts. I stopped in for a takeout order around 4:30. There were several tables dining in, as well as a good takeout business. I opted for the garden salad and the Department of Sanitation New York pizza. The description said it had a little bit of a lot of stuff. The ingredients included pepperoni, mushrooms, bacon, meatballs, green peppers, and onions. It tasted great. The garden salad was also good. The takeout took about 15 minutes.

So poorly done, the sauce left so much bare pizza. Toppings were barely there. I talked my family into taking a second try at this pizza and it was an epic fail!! So disappointed, I was pulling for you!