Ben S.
Yelp
I've got a different perspective perhaps on Brooklyn College I guess, because I was the kid of two Brooklyn College English Professors #1, and #2, I also took some classes at BC (and at Hunter also) during my "gap years" in between high school & college (though I was altogether more focused on working, interning, competitive ski racing and traveling) just to make the parentals happy, before I figured out what colleges and universities I even WANTED to apply to. Being the product of two Ivy League educated parents who were academics came with a certain level of demand and expectation when it came to even going to college, especially because I was expected to be some kind of role model to my younger sister, AND because I'd already mostly failed on that front by not being the world's best student in high school. I also grew up in the neighborhood near the BC campus, so I also knew I didn't want to have a "commuter" school experience and live at home for college and have the experience of "going away to college" be a part of my overall college experience.
When I was attending high school at Edward R. Murrow (which is actually a great public high school) I started taking college-level classes in my junior year through Murrow's "Early College Program College Now!" though Kingsborough Community College. The classes were taught at Murrow, but a couple of times a year we would go to KCC for college-level introductory orientations and basically I caught on fast that my high school was just a funnel into the CUNY/SUNY system.
Most NYC public high schools are, but I wasn't particularly interested in attending a CUNY or SUNY institution necessarily to get my degree, and the relentlesss recruitment at college fairs was a bit annoying, so I kind of tuned the whole "college marketing experience" out. I had high school friends that were starting college at NYU, Hunter, BU, Columbia, Bard, Sarah Lawrence, Oberlin, Hamilton, Wesleyan, Colgate, Rutgers, Amherst, Smith, Bowdoin, Swarthmore, Bryn Mawr etc...I'd gone to high school with some exceptionally intelligent and driven students, and I knew that I came from just as intelligent a background as they did, and was as bright as they were, but I just hadn't had the same knack for standardized testing that they'd had, and I guess I hadn't "applied myself" enough while in high school. I didn't know anything other than I felt like I wanted to do "other things" first with my life BEFORE college. So that when I was TRULY ready to go, I would select the colleges that were the BEST possible choices for me. I also felt like I wasn't emotionally ready for it yet.
So, I enrolled both at Brooklyn and Hunter as a "non-degree" seeking student during both the 1991/1992 & 1992/1993 academic years and took classes on both campuses using my parents tuition discount waiver that family members of CUNY employees can use. Given my lack of college focus at the time, this was the best possible option for me, as it gave me a frame of reference and kept "going to college" on my radar. What I also did was hang out with high school friends at their respective campuses and see if that got me interested in applying to go to school there also. This is how I eventually ended up applying to NYU, Hunter, Sarah Lawrence & Bard. Having already visited Hampshire a couple of times, it became my top first choice college, and Emerson in Boston became my top second choice college. Bennington, Marlboro, Goddard and UVM became the Vermont schools I ultimately applied to, because I discovered I REALLY wanted to go to a small New England liberal arts college. Reed, Oberlin and Antioch, although further away in Oregon and Ohio, were also in my top choices, because they also fit the characteristics of colleges I wanted to attend.
Brooklyn College is a good school, it has a beautiful campus for a public commuter college, and it does have great programs in the performing arts (which was my focus). However, administratively, the college is a MESS (as are ALL the CUNY schools I realized) endlessly bureaucratic and full of stressors and headaches. NOT what I ultimately wanted my college experience to be like, although I realize that to some extent, ALL colleges and universities (even upper-tier private schools) have these administrative nightmares. I ran into this even at Hampshire; although it was QUITE different and more low-key than it would have been at a CUNY or SUNY institution for me. I think Brooklyn would have absolutely been a "poor fit" for me, given what I eventually figured out I wanted my college experience to be like, and I only ended up applying to Hunter CUNY-wise, because that at least was in Manhattan, and I could have lived in a residence hall, and still had more of an "away at college" experience even though I would have stayed in NYC for college, which I didn't end up doing anyway. And that was the right choice
for me.