Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta

Garlic knots were missing garlic. Caprese salad had balsamic dressing instead of glaze. Too watery. Pizza was amazing. Fresh ingredients and not greasy. Only one waitress working on Friday and she was friendly, helpful and everywhere at once. Very impressed with customer service. 10” pizza plenty for one person. We had the veggie and mozzarella. Will be back! Highly recommend for pizza. Next time will try pasta.

This place was awesome. Amazing food, reasonable pricing especially when you take the portion size into consideration. This is very much a gem in the rough. Don't skip this one and definitely get the calzone!

Best gluten free NY style pizza in the area! The crust is the best part it has air pockets from rising but it doesn't end there. Great sauce and the cheese is just unbelievable and generous. I love NY style pizza and when I get a craving this is the place! The GF and traditional crust is just like you would get in NY city. The cheese is piled high its very stringy when you pull out a slice. I'll be back again and again!

Went in and got the Lunch special. I got the Pepperoni and my girlfriend got the Cheese. I'm from Orange County New York. This is the spot for real pizza in Cincinnati. Absolutely taste the difference between this pizza and all the other pizza around. I can recommend a few other places like in the area. This one is the new top spot for me. Cheese, sauce, crust, and grease with foldable slices all correct. Service was fast, friendly, and efficient.

Everything here is delicious especially the pizza. My husband loves their wings. I've had several different meals and they are all great!

Not sure if this is how the pizza is made in Brooklyn but this little pizza place in Montgomery makes great Italian food (including pizza) at reasonable prices. The daily specials are a great bang for the buck also. There's an element of speed and no nonsense to the service and the dining area is clean and well kept.

Very low-key, mom n pop place. Nothing fancy but the food makes up for it. Friendly staff. A 10” 5-topping is a steal of a deal. Eggplant is a tasty topping option. They were not skimpy on the toppings in the least. Crust is done just right. We usually get lasagna and it’s packed full of meat! Hope you enjoy it as much as we do.

This place is awesome! We went for pizza and also the Sicilian Ziti pasta. It was fantastic! From the outside, this place doesn't do much. But when you see the menu, the prices and the food, it was awesome! We will definitely be back! Wish this place was closet to us in Beavercreek!

We were in the area unexpectedly, and I was browsing Yelp for local pizza places and this place looked good. We were greeted when we walked in and told to sit anywhere we'd like. The place was clean, which was a concern after seeing several reviews say it was dirty. We were given menus and our drink order was taken. We decided on a pizza. It came out pretty fast after ordering. When the waitress tells you to let it sit for a couple of minutes, you should probably listen. The cheese was still too hot and pulled right off the first slices. We loved the pizza. The sauce and crust were fantastic. We live on the opposite side of town, but would gladly make a special trip for this pizza.

2 slices and a drink for $7.20 in 2025 is one of the best lunch deals in Greater Cincinnati. Friendly employees, great pizza, great deal - what more can you ask for?

I stopped by Brooklyn for an early lunch after a doctor visit. They opened at 11 am and I was surprised by the number of customers that were there at 11:15 am. There are two lunch specials to choose from for the cost conscious guests. The first special is 2 slices of pizza with a drink for $7.79. There were several options to choose from with this deal. The second special is a 10' w/5 toppings and a drink for $9.99. I chose the 10' four cheese special, and my mom had 2 slices of the Mattie. Her order came out after a short wait. She enjoyed her pizza's thin crust and fresh vegetables. It took a while for my pizza to come, but it was worth the wait. My pizza was cheesy with the right amount of seasoning. My mother and I agree, Brooklyn is a winner and the go-to pizzeria when we're in the area. FYI: There's a 4% fee for using a card. This is listed on the menu.

Where do I start? The staff was so amazing. My girlfriend Brooklyn and I came to Brooklyn's pizza and pasta on our way home. Our visit was so amazing being that my girlfriend's name was Brooklyn. She was excited about all the Brooklyn theme stuff inside. The owner Diane caught one of our conversations and offered her a free T-shirt. Just all around good pizza and good service. 10/10 would recommend! Thank you Diane for making us feel welcome!

Absolutely one of the worst dining experiences I've had in a long time. This is the result of dinner for 6. 1. Caprese Salad - Shockingly small portion, the mozzarella was stale, and there was barely any dressing to mask the lack of freshness or flavor. It looked and tasted like an afterthought. 2. Chicken Parmesan - A complete miss. The chicken was soggy and flavorless, and the sauce tasted like it came from a bargain bin overseas. If this was made in-house, it reflects a serious lapse in quality and taste. 3. Eggplant Parmesan - Nearly identical to the chicken parm in all the worst ways, except the eggplant was shredded and even more unappetizing. It was a mushy, greasy mess. 4. Stromboli - An absolute joke. Sparse fillings (a few sad slices of pepperoni), undercooked dough, and zero structure. It was limp and soggy, not something that should ever leave a kitchen. 5. Sausage and Peppers Sandwich - Greasy, bland, and poorly assembled. The sausage was sliced thin, had no flavor, and the whole thing was just unpleasant to eat. No comment on ambience or service, this was takeout.

Great pasta and even better pizza; what more can one ask for?! I first ordered dinner and the family enjoyed the fettuccine alfredo, spaghetti w/meatballs, and garlic knots. The alfredo sauce was thick/creamy albeit a tad under-salted. The meatballs were huge but moist and well seasoned. Lastly, their garlic knots were absolutely divine! The only thing that would've put them over the top, is being tossed with grated parmesan like they do in NYC (I mean if you call yourself Brooklyn Pizza...) lol. Dinner was so good that we decided to order pizza a week later and boy, was I glad we did. The large cheese pie had the right amount of cheese and the most perfect, doughy crust that I've had outside of NYC. I'm tempted to ask if they import the water. This will be our go-to spot for pizza, and I'm so glad they offer delivery in addition to indoor dining.

A local staple that never disappoints. I've always went with the pizza by the slice for lunch, which is a great deal. The crust is paper thin & crispy. I don't eat here enough but when I do I'm reminded why I always come back! I'd hit it...again.

Best Pizza we have had since moving to the area. We are pizza snobs and appreciate the real deal. Quality cheese good sauce. Independent business is also a plus for me. I totally recommend this pizzeria.

Very bad food. Place looked dirty. Crust was soggy. Ingredients did not look fresh. And staff was not friendly. I highly recommend NOT going there ever.

I ordered the build your own deluxe/5 topping personal pizza and it was quite good! It arrived pretty quickly at carry out too, only after 10 minutes of ordering online. Dough seemed freshly made and toppings were quite nice. The cost was very reasonable too, I had trouble finishing it in 1 sitting as a 200lb man. I would have given this restaurant 5 starts, the let down was the sauce. I asked for double/extra sauce on my order and the pie came almost completely dry. So dry I had to go back in and buy an extra cup of sauce for dipping.

We ordered for take out and absolutely loved it! Really tasty toppings and good amount of toppings! We got the four cheese pizza and the hot and spicy - both very very good!

Lunch with the family, takeout to watch a game, or a slice of cheese on the go. This pizza rises to the occasion. Will definitely be back!

Everything customer service was horrible and barely any toppings. Place was not clean at all.

Food-- Have had their pizza 10 times. Including a large spicy sausage and banana pepper last night. We lived in NYC for 3 years. This is as good as just about any pizza from the city. Large 2-topping is $22-23. I dream of noshing my way through their entire menu, finding it hard to move beyond the pizza though! Will update after a few hoagies and calzones. Service-- Fast service, friendly and experienced staff. Owner is usually onsite, hence the consistent high quality. Ambiance-- only a date night if you're down to your last hundred bucks. But if your girl likes low-brow then you're in luck! I've been to divey-er places than this to eat but def not a date joint... (Clean, spacious, and comfortable: 5-6 booths and 5-6 tables). Branded carryout pizza boxes at Brooklyn read "FUGGETABOUTIT!" I agree, it's the best pizza around the Cincy eastside that I've had. Fuggetaboutit.

5 star pizza. The crust is very close to a good NY pizza crust. Yes, finally someone gets the crust right outside of NY/NJ. The ceasar salad is delicious and the ceasar dressing is amazing. They have real good ranch too. The garlic knots could use more garlic however the marinara sauce is legit and the dough is scrumptious. Another Friday pizza night success!

This is a small family ran pizza place. That has a great product with a strong faithful following. First my suggestion would be to clean the location the ceiling is covered with dust from using flour to make dough. Maybe get some adult supervision to run the day to day business. Now onto the food, first the garlic knots I thought were good in the garlic butter, they were a little tough but we still enjoyed them. The lasagna was HUGE it was very serviceable worth the cost we had the dinner portion they do have a lunch special which is a normal person portion. Finally on to the pizza the toppings were very good the crust has great potential it just lacks a little something. Over all it was not a bad choice to try just realize it can be that much better. Try a large pepperoni pizza and a cold beer.

I introduced my hubby about a year ago to Brooklyn Pizza and it has quickly became our favorite. Ordered two calzones tonight, and got to say this is the best calzones we have had in Cincinnati. I ordered the meatball, carmelized onion, basil and mushrooms. Hubby got all meats. Get an extra marinara sauce because the calzone is so big it will need it. I could only eat half it was so that large. Yummmm...!!!!!

Easily the best pizza in Cincinnati! It's the only place you can find upstate New York style pizza. They even have a Syracuse flag hanging in the restaurant. Absolute gem of a place located in the suburbs of Cincinnati.

Horrible food. Tried it several times. Nothing like Brooklyn New York Food. The Pizza has no sauce no taste . Eggplant Parm was defrosted in a microwave from being frozen and was rubbery and awful . Waste of money everytime I go to Trophy Pizza now

Stopped here to wait out traffic after a Bengals game. Pizza was pretty good, service was excellent. Chicken Parm sub was ok. Cannoli was delicious.

I've driven by this place several times and always wanted to stop. Finally did today and I'm glad I did so. I wouldn't say it's a greasy spoon or a dive, but it was a little different. The menu is HUGE! We settled on the pizza, the Mattie. It was delicious. I had three slices and I wasn't uncomfortable. The server was very nice and personable. I can't recall her name. Definitely a repeat offender. Can't wait to go back. Also, ordered wings to go. To be continued......

Cute little spot. Staff is super! Menu is pretty extensive includes pizzas with red and white sauce, pastas and they serve crafts and wine. Prices were good too!

Ordered 12 pizzas for our baseball team at the hotel. Great service and the pizzas were perfect. As a NY'er these were very close to NY style. 100% recommend.

Picked up 2 pizzas that were great. But the calzone was burnt to a crisp. If the owner knew it was sent out like this, I'm sure he would be upset.

We love their chicken parm, and they will cook the pizza well-done if you ask ! Service is excellent , too !

Ordered from here twice when on extended stay at Bethesda North Hospital. Pizza [the Brooklyn] the first time and pasta [baked ziti and chicken parm] the second. Food was fresh, hot and really tasty. Orders were completed quickly and the staff friendly on pickup. Portions are large and the prices very reasonable. Really impressed with this place, would highly recommend it.

tasted like frozen pizza. tombstone is better. service was meh, much better pizza in the area, definitely does not taste like a new york pizza.

Stopped here on a whim one day. It's in hoity toity Montgomery. I walk in all dirt bag construction guy straight from work. I was worried they might sick the dogs on me. Nope. Every time I've ever been, everybody who works there is cool as can be. The place is casual, some might be agast expecting linen tablecloths. It's clean, they have a little library for the readers and , they have the best pizza crust I've ever tasted! Your boy is trying to put the carbs out and lose a couple pounds again, but the ability to grab a slice or two keeps me honest. And every one I've tried is pretty great. Did I mention the best crust I've ever had? It's thin, it has the New York chew, it doesn't have garlic (or too much garlic) , but it tastes like something. I worked in pizza for 14 years and let me tell you, Blodgett deck ovens are the only way!! I mean unless you are talking fancy wood or coal fired. Convection ovens don't do it man!! I used to love la Rosa's. Until the went to convection. It's why a slice at kings island la Rosa's is almost worth $17. I hope they make enough to keep going. It's really a great little place. The specials look great too. I'll have to take a date or actually make a friend so I can try one.

We didn't really have the experience others have had here. The restaurant did not seem particularly clean. We were told to pick a place to sit. Most of the tables had crumbs on them, or were oily. When our server came with menus she sort of cleaned the table we were at. It was a quick wipe down; some crumbs still remained. When I asked for a wing recomendations she said she was new, and did not know what was good. She then told us three choices she has heard people order. We went with the spicy garlic. They were very acidic. The veggie pizza did not impress either. It did have the thinner dough that New York pizza is known for. The center of our pizza was soggy. Not thinner to flip the point up, but mushy. Maybe the vegetables had too much moisture? The sauce that came with the garlic knots was chunky and flavorful. I thought it was the best part of our meal. The establishment is extremely popular. While not many came to eat in, the delivery driver was constantly coming in and out. There was also a constant stream of people coming in to either order pizza, or picking up orders.

Horrible customer service! They made us the wrong pizza, which we didn't realize until we got home. Called just to get a credit and was told I could only receive a credit for the difference in cost between what they gave me and what I actually ordered. The problem is what they gave me isn't what we wanted. They made us return to old pizza and swap it out, yet it was their mistake! Their system of an automatic tip in advance, and then treat you like crap afterwards with no recourse because they have your money is broken!

Although it was a Friday night we were one of only 3-4 other tables in the place and there were two servers. The service was dreadfully slow and painful to get the food out in a somewhat timely manner. Refills were kind of hard to come by and the food was mediocre. Garlic knots were balls of dough sitting in a pool of butter with melted mozz on them. Had zero flavor... I had a Stromboli which was good. We ordered an antipasto salad for the table which was decent but not a great depiction of an antipasto salad. Chopped up olives, meat, cheese and a bow of romaine. Pizza looked decent but I didn't have any and was told from other family members that it was undercooked and chewy which isn't what I would expect from a NY style pizza. Have been here before and I recall the pastas are much better than the pizzas.

So the pizza is a 5 if you eat in. The atmosphere is a 3-4 and the service a 4 since they pretty much take your order and you are there to fill your drink and such. The pizza is pretty much what I eat there although I have had salad and some desert. I'm 11 minutes away and when I order delivery my pizza always seems to be warm not hot and it is not like eating in the restaurant. Not sure if short on staff or it's the distance or they take too many orders at once. It drops to a 3 for delivery and the pizza is a 5 in the restaurant and that comes from a true Jersey boy. And don't get me wrong. New Jersey has some pizza that is not so good there too. It's not just all great pies. So, the pizza is a 5 for me. Delivery a 3. Ambiance a 3. Service I'll push the 4 since my legs still work and I can yell to the counter and always sit close. Enjoy. One of the closest places to NJ pie. There are a few others throughout the city but they require a drive.

Nothing like Brooklyn pizza. Cheap ingredients and not cooked well at all. Having had pizza at hundreds of places from NY to California, this is one of the worst. Service was okay.

I am long overdue to patronize this local pizzeria in Montgomery. My daughter had it not long AFO and really liked it. Tonight, during our quarantine of 2020 I decided to order carry out. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and the garlic knots. Having been to NYC and eaten from several pizzerias I can say that NY style is the best. That being said, Brooklyn Pizza is as good as it gets outside of NY for their style of pizza. I loved the flavor and size of pepperoni and the crust was terrific.! I highly recommend this for anyone near or in Montgomery.

Best pizza in the area. True NY pizza,pasta, and Stromboli's. The hot Italian sub is so good we always split it as an appetizer and don't leave without fried dough for dessert! Don't expect white tablecloths here this is a true pizza joint! The only place I ever get pizza from!

I have been here several times over the past 5 or so years and I have never been disappointed. The Pizza is always very good, this trip I decided to go with a Calzone as I haven't had one here. I came in with my best friend and ordered a Calzone and he ordered the Stromboli, or was it the other way around... odd I don't remember. Either way they were both perfectly yummy, I mean wow. The crust has such a good flavor and the toppings or would those be innings? Either way they were fresh and tasty. I almost couldn't eat it all, I mean it was basically a 12-14 inch pizza folded over and baked... it was a lot of food. The staff here is very friendly and talkative. I asked a few question about dessert and kind of wish I had room to enjoy some of there fried dough that was spoken so highly off. I guess that is a good reason to come back. Next trip I will plan on a pizza and fried dough. You can count on my checking in one day soon and updating this review.

best pizza outside NYC and the owner is the best!. great place to eat and super service

I woke up today and simply wanted an over cheesed floppy pizza. Specific craving, I know. I found this cheesy, meat covered, greasy pizza to be the perfect match for the expectations of my dreams. Sure, there is probably a 'better' pizza out there, but this was a mood and Brooklyn Pizza delivered. Next time you need this much cheese in your life, please consider the Triple Meat Triple Cheese!

This place is amazing the cheese on the pizza is delicious. Service is so nice. Parking is great because it is a hidden gem. The pizza is everything that good in a pizza would recommend

Carryout order of a medium cheese pizza with pepperoni, small Mattie pizza, regular sized antipasto salad and garlic knots. Only came due to the free medium pizza coupon due to moving into the neighborhood. Pizza was 3/5, salad 3/5 and garlic knots was 4.5/5. The marinara sauce was tasty, the drippings from the garlic knots were delicious. Pizza was very mediocre. The medium and small were supposed to be 14" and 10" but they looked like the same size to me. Salad was small and weird how they rolled up the cheese and meat. Wouldn't come back unless I had a coupon.

I was visiting some friends who live in the Kenwood area and we picked up some Brooklyn Pizza along with some garlic knots! First off, the pizza was really good. I don't think it was the best NY pizza I've had (but that may because we had to take it home). Keeping NY pizza at the perfect level of crust crispiness is tricky and I would definitely like to taste the pizza fresh out of the oven. The flavor was great though and I really enjoyed the sauce. The star of the show were definitely the garlic knots, though. I could not get enough of these. They had the perfect seasoning. They were baked perfectly. As I write this review I'm drooling just thinking about these little carb-filled knots of perfection. I definitely want to try more from Brooklyn Pizza and pasta.

My wife and I stopped in for lunch on a nice Thursday around noon time. Place was busy, almost all tables full and only one waitress. But she did a great job of getting to everyone quickly. I had the Stromboli, my wife had a salad, which she said was good. My Stromboli was delicious. Thin crust, good amount of cheese, and loaded with pepperoni. I ate half for lunch and took the other half home. This will definitely be my "Stromboli place" going forward. Decent size menu and I'm looking forward to trying other menu items in the future. The Hot Italian Sub will be next on my list to order here. Only negative comment is that the restrooms could use some real cleaning.

A friend and I tried Brooklyn Pizza and Pasta recently. What a fantastic little gem! Laid back, great service, and the food was outstanding. We both had pasta dishes that were phenomenal! Will be returning to try their pizza. Highly recommend

This is close to my job and I've been wanting to try it. I ordered the lunch special which was a good price and came with a drink. The pizza is New York style and I ordered the meats. The toppings, sauce and cheese were all above average. I enjoyed this New York style pizza. Sorta reminds me of Dewey's at a cheaper price. I would return if I was in the mood for pizza while at work.

I had heard about this pizza place from someone who was in search of pizza that closely resembled the best pizza in the world, New York pizza. The kind of pizza that you fold in half and eat. Pizza where you don't need a whole bunch of mathematical instruments to eat. No graphing calculators, compasses or quadratic formulas to figure out how to eat it. No cracker crust. No sweet sauce. I've lived in New York for 20+ years and I'm a pizza snob. This pizza is very close to the real deal, but no cigar. It's of no fault to the pizzeria. It's the water. There's something about New York water that makes pizza and bagels something else. So if you don't want to travel to New York for the best pizza in the world, this is a close second.

Used to be good, now soggy and salty. Both the pizza and the wings. Where can you find pizza with pepperoni cooked nicely on top.

This restaurant never disappoints! My husband, being from New Jersey m, just across from NYC, really enjoys it as well! Definitely a must try!

I'm always leery about an Ohio restaurant that touts NY style pizza. But theres no false advertising with Brooklyn Pizzeria. It's the the real deal! The texture of the their crust nails NY style pizza. Thin and wide slices that are foldable. Their cheese is high quality mozzarella, sauce is flavorful slightly sweet yet savory. Great sauce and cheese ratio. Great NY style pizza!

DELICIOUS PIZZA!!!! Especially the White Garlic !!!!! Good location and a no-rush atmosphere!!!!!! And the owner is nice too!!!