Laura B.
Yelp
This is the first 1 star review that I have ever written, but Brooklyn West Winery has earned it. I visited with a group of three other friends on Friday evening after work. The place was almost empty which should have been a warning. But, it was kind of fun having the place to ourselves after a hectic work week, so we decided to stay, and ordered two bottles of wine to all split.
We too unfortunately met the winemaker, Stew, and his equally uncouth wife, Michelle. They kept pestering me and my friends every chance they got for us to buy some kind of a wine subscription, saying how they have won all these SF Chronicle awards. We thought that we should at lest try the wine first, and it's a good thing that we did! The Tempranillo was just terrible, no flavor yet sour on the tongue with very high acidity. Made from grapes watered by the East River, perhaps?
The Cabernet came out next after a lengthy wait, and I was rewarded with a "fresh" glass that already had greasy fingerprints all around the sides and a touch of pink lipstick on the rim! Gross! The tasting room associate hear me gasp in horror when I saw this and did come over quickly to switch out my glass. I however was done drinking after that, and even though my friend's glasses appeared clean, they didn't want any more wine either. To cap it all off, we were overcharged by mistake and had to almost argue with the person at the register to have the extra charge refunded. She finally agreed to the refund after my friend said that the charge would be disputed.
We certainly won't visit this place ever again. Save your precious time and money and go elsewhere!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Michelle,
Thanks for your reply. I too wish to forget such an unpleasant evening, but am not there yet, hence my review. Whether or not you truly don't remember me and my friends (I suppose we are fairly plain and forgettable) OR you're just borrowing a page from Jeff Session's playbook, one thing is for sure, we most certainly have met before. For example, I already know that you don't work behind the bar at the tasting room, as you mentioned several times you are a co-owner of Brooklyn West and married to Stew, one of the winemakers, so therefore you hang out there a lot after your day job in development. I remember this well as I remember not being surprised about your line of work after the hard sell we were given regarding subscriptions.
I do appreciate that you take this matter seriously, and will chalk this up to an off night.