Brooklyn's Homeslice Pizza

For a first experience at this place it was good. Available seating for me an my little pizza critic. Undercarriage was beautiful. Nice crunch soft dough thin slice lots of grease from the cheese. 2 cheese slices & a snapped was $11.

Their buffalo chicken is one of my top favorite slices now. I've tried their regular and other slices, and they were great too. I love that the crust is flavorful, fluffy, and crispy.

Asked them to remake a pie when mine got messed up. Manager showed up at my place and demanded the old one back and complained I ate off the old one. Never told me not to touch it or nothing - just showed up mad

Friendly staff, all are welcome, great Brooklyn slices, but the big winner is the Broccoli Rabe grandma slice, just wow! So much delicious broccoli Rabe, fresh crushed tomatoes on a delicious pizza dough! Get it!

The only positive: crust was good. Eggplant slice was not bad. However, the spinach ricotta and mushroom truffle slices were so underwhelming.. I’m upset I wasted $40 on it. Charging $6+ a slice for frozen spinach just thrown on the pizza is ridiculous. I think this is probably the worst spinach and ricotta slice I’ve had. The truffle mushroom pizza had 0 truffle oil .. I had to put my own. The garlic knots were very under seasoned.. I see the good reviews and I am so confused. Did we order from the same place? Maybe it was just a bad day… but I won’t be ordering from here again.

Disrespectful and Insensitive Experience at Homeslice on 4th Avenue My family and I visited this Homeslice location because we’re regular customers at the Vanderbilt spot, which we’ve always loved. Unfortunately, our experience here was very disappointing. The employee at the register, Ross, was polite at first, but as soon as the manager left, his attitude completely changed. My 4-year-old son — who has sensory and special needs — was simply excited about his pizza. I had already reminded him to use a quiet voice, but Ross suddenly “shh’d” him harshly. At first, I honestly thought Ross was being playful, but then he started yelling, saying, “This is not a galley!” — directly at my child. I calmly reminded him that my son is only four and just excited, but Ross didn’t apologize or show any understanding. It wasn’t until I asked for his name and requested to speak to a manager that he quickly said, “sorry,” then immediately repeated, “Yes, this is not a galley,” as if to justify his behavior. I stayed respectful throughout, but he was defensive, and another employee — who had already been rude to other customers — tried to excuse his actions by saying my son’s excitement was “disrupting them from hearing orders.” Meanwhile, groups of high school students were talking and laughing nearby without issue. This experience showed a complete lack of empathy and professionalism, especially toward a young child with special needs. As loyal customers, we expected kindness and understanding — not hostility. I hope management at this location takes this seriously and provides better training on how to treat all families with patience, respect, and compassion.

$3.50 a slice in Park Slope. Busy spot, waited about 5 minutes total. Pizza came out warm with cheese dripping. Nice thin crust with good flavor. I love the location with outdoor bench seating on a closed off street on Vanderbilt bike path. BYOB is what I saw at the next table 😊. Very scenic & good place to relax a bit after 40 miles of cycling. Definitely made it to my TOP FAVES 👍

We ordered a large cheese 🧀 pizza 🍕 and a large grandma pizza with a 20pc order of wings and an order of garlic knots and as you can see we didn't even leave a moment before digging right in. The food was delivered on time, fresh, hot and so sinfully delicious!!! I would 100% recommend recommend this place and the items that we had Tonight.

Every slice I've tried here has been a hit. The crust is always light and crispy, the sauce is just the right amount of sweet, and the cheese is the perfect amount. There are a few tables inside, but it mostly works as a takeout spot. Credit cards are accepted but a small discount is given for cash.

Their buffalo chicken is one of my top favorite slices now. I've tried their regular and other slices, and they were great too. I love that the crust is flavorful, fluffy, and crispy.

If you love NY pizza this the spot for you. Especially for New Yorkers that are always rushing to get somewhere and need to grab something quick to eat. We ran in here and found a gem with a small interior with two tables and outdoor seating at the curb (a bench and another small table) You walk up and read the walls because the menu is everywhere. Kinda crazy but hey that's Brooklyn for ya. The guys in the back are cracking jokes, dancing to 50 cent (Go shorty) and serving up fresh out the oven slices, calzones, Philly cheesesteak and more. Loved the vibe, the food and the service.

Slice was crispy and hit the spot for our Brooklyn slice adventure but it was oily. I probably should've stuck with the regular cheese slice.

Roaming around Brooklyn and found this popular spot on Yelp. Tiny place with two dinning tables. Quick service and friendly staffs. Delicious pizza and large portion for cheap. What can I ask for more? Love it!!!

Keepin it real out here in Brooklyn Really nice service, place looks cool, food is decent, if i ever in need of a quick slice and in the neighborhood, i would go for it. Also not the cheapest but still fine for the neighborhood

Solid slice! I am a connoisseur of pepperoni pizza. Important factors that I consider: grease level should be low to non existent, pepperoni should be thin and crispy, crust should be thin and crispy, balance of sauce and cheese should be the same, ingredients should be fresh, sauce should have a slight tang. Service is very important. Place should be clean. So we will start with the service was quick and painless, they gave me my requested items. Clean place. Balances were perfect, roni and slice were thin crispy and fresh. Slice had no grease. Ingredients were quality and fresh. Sauce could've been alittle more flavorful! See you next time!

The whole staff is super dope and the pizza was everything! Super fresh and hot! I love a good oven brick pizza. The location is small so most people do take out but I sat down and enjoyed every bit of my slice of pizza. Can't wait to visit again!!

Homeslice's grandma pizza is really good. Crust is not your paper thin NY style slice and has the perfect balance of crunch and chew. I liked that the sauce is very slightly chunky with tomato bits. They don't skimp on the sauce either. At $30 per pie, it's a little expensive for the somewhat small size of the pie. The calzone and the pie weren't as hot as I expected them to be upon delivery, but I recognize that's not necessarily because of Homeslice. If you eat in, they have one indoor table and a couple of picnic tables outside.

Now I'm a Brooklyn girl from Bensonhurst, arguably home to some of the best pizza in NY, so I like to stop into other neighborhood's slice shops to see how everyone's slice measures up. Brooklyn's Homeslice? Solid. The crust tastes like it was fermented, it's crisp, airy, doughy in all the right ways. The sauce is tart, maybe a touch sweet, and the cheese pulls just right. The folks behind the counter have the sort of no nonsense kindness that tells you you're in good hands. They're mostly a takeout operation, but I visited on a warm night and sat at one of the little round tables they have set up outside. Try the grandma slice and their mushrooms and onion slice for a good time.

Pizza by the slice. It was amazing. It was late night cravings. We were walking around trying to head back to the hotel and stopped here.

Such good pizza. Came here late night and was surprised that the pizza was still super fresh, staff super kind and the experience was definitely worth coming back the next day. Definitely will come again.

Service was great and fast. Their buffalo-chicken slice was phenomenal! The ambience felt very homey as well.

Great Brooklyn pizza. Great service. Very clean. All the guys behind the counter were great!

Wow just wow this was the best boneless cheese slice I've had in a while, so yesterday at work a friend had a cheese slice and it smelled so good asked her where she got it from and as soon as I clocked out I walked fast to the pizza spot, spot was pretty cool my friend told me I always walk by it but I honestly don't pay attention when I'm focused on getting somewhere I walk super fast. But anyways got my slice and you know it's a good slice when the oil is perfect lol I picked up my slice and it caved in on me that's why I say boneless slice and to me those are the best slices so i definitely will be back for more slices

Today is our cheat day so we decided to treat ourselves to pizza - from a pizzeria. Had I known I was going to receive this overpriced monstrosity I would've ordered papa johns. I got half sausage, onions and peppers and half chicken and spinach. Whoever made my pizza never learned the phrase "less is more" and gifted me with the soggiest, overloaded pizza I've ever eaten. I ordered extra cheese but it was lost and solidified under the undercooked toppings. The chicken wings were the saving grace of this meal as my Caesar salad also honestly tasted kind of funny. Will not be ordering pizza from here again.

I've only sampled their vegetarian options and I've always had a good experience. Don't miss their grandma slice!

Pizza was good. Fun eating outside on the street and soaking in the Brooklyn vibe. Owner was nice.

Pretty solid and good slice of pizza in my opinion! Got the Margherita and the peperoni. Both came out crispy, saucy, and delicious! The slice was quite big for me and 1 slice got fill me up for a lunch.

Grandma slice is like air. Yum. Any pizza by the slice you can't go wrong. Good quality casual pizza by the slice in the area probably the best

Solid slices! Big portions. Good for takeout, there isn't space inside to sit anyway.

went to NY for a concert (Hope on the stage) and they had people passing out flyers as we were waiting we decided to go afterwards and it was the best decision ever! they were so kind they even gave me a bag to help carry all my concert merch. Please please please go eat here their pizza is top tier and their ambiance and service is above and beyond thank you for making my trip to NY memorable!!

These are the types of place I love. Quick and delicious slices of pizza at an affordable cost. Came here after 9pm and there was plenty of fresh pizza options available. The Margherita was looking so good I couldn't pass it up, and something I don't see often back home is a Buffalo chicken slice. Everything about the marg slice was what I was looking for. Great sauce, good flop and a nice crunch. The Buffalo chicken slice has huge pieces of chicken and it covered the entire slice. I wish I had this slice fresh out of the oven because I know it'd be way better than reheated. Gotta love any place that loads up and doesn't skimp on the toppings. After eating two slices, I was absolutely stuffed! Nothing like getting a delicious meal and coke for under $10. My friend lives less than a 5 minute walk, which if I lived here, no doubt, this would be my go to slice spot. Being from the Bay, there's something about NY pizza that just hits different. Maybe it's the water but dang it just tastes so good!

I'd rate Homeslice three and a half stars. I had the chicken cutlet, bacon, and ranch slice. Toppings were good and probably would have made for a good sandwich but there was more to be desired from the crust. More of a specialty toppings style of pizzeria rather than a classic NY style pizzeria. Lots of interesting specialty slices. Open late and no line.

Love Brooklyn for their pizza! Prices are affordable and you get great value! I ordered the Jalapeño Pepperoni and the Spinach White slices for $9.72. Both had great flavor and ample toppings. Only thing I wish it had was a thinner crust. Too much bread at the end makes me want more sauce. Lady at the desk was super nice and had a very relaxed attitude. She gave plenty of friendly vibes. Cheers

Walked here to grab a slice of the Sicilian based on the reviews. Saw 2/5 of the staff members weren't wearing masks so I quickly turned around and left. No one's pizza is worth risking your health or the health of the people you live with. Sorry. EDIT: the owner messaged me on Yelp and apologized profusely and said he mentioned this to his staff that it's unacceptable. I'm updating what had been a 1 to a 2 star based on that experience and am open to changing my review upon a new experience.

Grandma slices were good, but I wish the regular slices were thicker. Slightly floppy.

Probably the best slice I've ever had. Such an underrated pizzeria, if you haven't tried Brooklyn's Homeslice definitely got to give them a try, you won't regret it.

To everyone reading this review Homslice does have good tasting pizza make no mistake about it . If you're going for a few slices you shouldn't have any disappointments , as for a chicken roll the minimum wait time is anywhere between 15 - 25 minutes per roll , if it ain't pizza then expect a much longer wait time for your food , then again the choice is always yours .

Another neighborhood staple. Staff is warm, kind and attentive, service is always quick. Pizza is good, I think the crust stands out the most, it is perfectly crispy. I can't recommend the margarita slice enough times!! I will say, everything I have had beyond pizza (rice balls and garlic knots specifically) were substantially less fresh and no where near as good as any slice at Homeslice. Wish there was more of an indoor seating area, even something casual but appreciate the outdoor seating area when it's warm!

Found my new go to Pizza place!!! loved the Sicilian pizza with the pesto sauce on top also the margarita crust was so amazing. I have to say i loved both! The place is very clean and the bathroom is super clean and new. it is a perfect spot around the Barclays center if you want to grab pizza before the game!

this is the best pizza in town. I recommend everyone to come here. It is so yummy from Samia Keriaky.

Solid. Got the pepperoni Sicilian and a margherita slice. Both were good, paid $9.5 for them. They have mainly outdoor seating which is covered, but when it's hot outside there are a lot of flies around. So not great ambiance. Service was good? They just heated the pizza up and gave it to me lolwtf.

Dope pizza spot. I walked 15 minutes to get here and it was worth it. I ordered a margarita slice and a Sicilian slice they both had totally different flavors. The Sicilian slice was a little salty to me however the margarita slice was very banging. The sauce was perfect and the crust was thin, light and had a crisp to it.I really enjoyed that slice and will definitely get it again. The workers were wearing masks and there are seats outside where you can dine

I would give it 3.5 stars. It is good. We ordered tonight and it came in under and hour which was good since it estimated 60-80 min. I wasn't happy with the price. 6 dollars for pepperoni and 3 dollars extra for onion. All in all with delivery we paid 35 dollars for a pie. Which is expensive. I really liked the crust. We heated it up on our pizza stone to make it crispy. I liked the cheese and sauce as well both had good flavor. Except some bites I got a stinky parm cheese flavor I didn't like. Also pepperoni was cheap quality. I wanted garlic on it. But they didn't have that choice. So i roasted my own garlic and put it on it. Our fav pizza place is closed during this time so we figured we would try this place. Probably would get again though and try some other toppings.

We ordered Grandma's pizza and a pepperoni pie. The crust and dough were delicious on both pies! Plenty of pepperoni and a savory tomatoe sauce with the right spices! It was fresh, hot and tasty! I recommend this pizza place for good quality and great service!

I paid around four dollars for a slice of pepperoni, I liked it, liked the crust. The slice was very hot and I was in a hurry. I'll come back for more.

Came here to get some pizza. The place happened to be a stall where this inside is small with limited inside seating. Ordered a BBQ Chicken, Bacon Chicken Ranch, and Butcher's Blend. The place is no different that the closest one to where I live. When I entered, there was pop music playing. There was a TV showing reality shows. THere was a customer before me when I entered. By the time my order was ready, another customer entered.

Brooklyn Home Slice is a neighborhood favorite, but their service is sub par. Don't order for delivery, the food will take hours or not come. Read my review below or the many others who have said the same thing. Consider ordering from Amorina Cucina Rustica, which has better reviews, is a few blocks away and has a gluten free pizza option. Review below: My husband and I order from them frequently for large events. On 4/16/24, we ordered using UberEats. While I know that UberEats isn't perfect, the food took hours to come to the location the was 2 mins (0.8 miles) away where we were hosting an event. When it arrived, it was missing a gluten free pie. I called them and told them that we're going to order another regular pie and to please send the gluten free pie (it was even written in the order notes.) Brooklyn Home Slice agreed to send the gluten free pie with the new order. When the order arrived it had one regular pie and NO gluten free pie. I went to the location to explain it to how disappointed I was in the service. Instead of owning up to the error or offering a valid solution, they blamed Uber Eats for both mistakes and suggested that we call them to place orders in the future. The event attendees with gluten allergies, did not eat. Here's the thing-- Brooklyn Home Slice don't use a service like UberEats if it doesn't work for your business. Offer solutions instead of blaming Uber Eats drivers for forgetting the pizza (twice) and the customer for not using your restaurant delivery service. If you have a delivery service, then bring the forgotten pizza 5 minutes away to your customer. Or hand the Uber Driver the order and tell them what to take. Going the extra mile is good business, it's that simple. (Uber Eats did refund us for the roughly $200 for both orders since the pizza that did arrive, arrived very late.)

Horrible customer service. Lasagna container was open and spilled everywhere. same with the pizza. I refused delivery and called to request a refund and the . The manager/owner is a pathetic excuse for a human. refused any kind of refund and hit hyper aggressive threatening to fight me because he didn't want to lose money for an order that was not filled. guy is a complete tool. Avoid this horrible place Interesting response since you're describing your own actions. I hung up on you for raising your voice to me and you being completely condescending, obnoxious and aggressive. You then called me back and doubled down on your approach yelling and not allowing any kind of response. then started to physically threaten me in typical meathead fashion. "Why don't you come down here and say it to my face! I'll take you down!" you're pathetic and so is your business.

Not sure wha's up with this place. They need to update their delivery zones if they constantly cancel orders.

Friendly neighborhood spot. Not far from my home, I come here often. My friend and I both love the place. We came in earlier today and had another great experience. Unique taste, stands out. service is great here. Looking forward to coming back in the future.

We picked up pizza from Homeslice and oh my god it did not disappoint. It was so good and the service was so quick - highly recommend!!

Walked in and got 3 slices to go on a Sunday afternoon. There wasn't a line. The employees were super nice. I got a margherita slice which the cashier said was the most popular, a grandma slice which she also recommended and a Sicilian pepperoni slice. I was visiting the neighborhood and had an excuse to try so many. :) Honestly the margherita was really really good. If I could do it all over again, I would just get two of that one. The upside down Sicilian looked so good. I should have just gotten it. Ha. I was full after 1.5 slices. Would definitely go back.

Another sunny day and another bicycle ride thru Brooklyn. I stopped at Homeslice Pizzeria for the first time. The space looks very lived in, but has a nice outdoor pod. I ordered two slices and dined outdoors. My first impression was pretty good. The slice was crunchy and there was no excess oil. The sauce was a bit sweet for my taste, but overall a good slice. My bill was $8.00, and the value was $7.50. Thank U next!

Yummy pizza and helpful and delightful staff! I recommend several of their slices! They were quick with service

This place has been on my radar for quite some time and I finally was able to score a parking close to the entrance. Upon arrival, everyone was socially distant and the menu was on the wall. Less chances for contact. Cool. I was helped by very polite young man who turned out to be the owner's son. I was excited to learn they have beef pepperoni along with other non-pork options for those who us who are either allergic, halal or kosher. Drooling at everything, I went with a regular slice and some beef pepperoni Sicilians for later. A 5-10 min wait and I was at the register chatting with the owner and cashing out. 8 love family businesses, especially when everyone looks like they are enjoying themselves. I bade them good day and hopped back in the car for a sampling. The regular slice was delicious. The epitome of what NYC slices tasted like in my youth.... crisp, chewy dough, with just the right balance of cheese, sauce and a super thin layer of grease to blot. I was sorry I didn't get more. After the Sicilian slices, the BF wanted to know how much was a whole pie. Needless to say, we will be back.

Open until midnight, variety of Sicilian slices and the Melanza (eggplant+margherita) is especially my favorite. The slices are big (that's why they're in the $3-5 range) but the taste is amazing. My favorite go-to pizza spot, enjoy Vanderbilt as you're eating in the outside little patio or walking around and thinking about dessert).

AMAZING!! In town for business, had a long day decided to order through Door Dash. Had the classic pepperoni (large) & bbq wings (8pc). Hands down the best pizza I've ever had!