Brotherhood of Thieves

It is my go to place in town. Always quality food. Very diverse menu. I’m sushi Italian to traditional Nantucket staples. The clam chowder is my favorite on island. Great flavors and hedges to the thinner side and the thicker side which I like. Pasta is outstanding. The sushi menu has never disappointed. 3 completely different vibes and atmospheres within The BroHo. Go upstairs if you haven’t. And also… the swag, clothing they sale is really high quality. I would put it on the “must go to” list.

Very welcoming to us. We are dinner and lunch here in the off season. The salmon was very tasty with the truffle fries. The nachos are above average and are crisp and not oily which is good. They were delicious.service as fantastic both times. Very attentive

Recently visited Nantucket and had lunch at Brotherhood of Thieves on many local’s recommendations after a trip to the Whaling Museum. Food was great, service was attentive, and the setting is really cool. As you walk in you feel as if you’re stepping back into a time of which this was the local watering hole for shrimpers and whalers coming back after months at sea. The brown butter lobster roll was good, but the salad roll is the one that really stole the show. Also opted for a cut of the clam chowder and it was absolutely delicious as well. Highly recommend!!

Apparently this is one of the more popular places to eat here in Nantucket and I can see why. The food is fabulous. We came for lunch and had the oysters and blackened swordfish with fries. It was great. And for dessert we had the lemon olive oil cake. It was not lemony for sure but it was very yummy

Unpleasant dining experience. Waitress was unpleasant and had a nasty attitude. Didn’t smile once and just felt like I was annoying her the whole night. No manners, no “thank you” no “excuse me” no “you’re welcome”. When it came time to pay, just dropped the receipt on the table and left. No “have a good night” or “thank you for coming” I left her a smaller than usual tip based on her unkind attitude. She proceeded to chase me out of the restaurant and demanded to know why I didn’t leave her a bigger tip. I told her she should have been nicer and left. She is lucky I left any tip at all. This confirmed her entitled and rude attitude. I will never be back. Food was good but does not make up for the experience.

We are visiting Nantucket as a group of 8. We walked into Brotherhood of Thieves and were immediately greeted by Jack. He was so kind and accommodating, as they were pretty busy. We were seating in a private room upstairs that was absolutely beautiful. The service we received from Peter was exceptional. He was pleasant, quick, and had the best recommendations. The food was all delicious. The beer battered fish and chips and the sushi were a huge hit. But the skillet cookie recommended by Peter was by far the best. Peter and Jack made the experience so memorable and we will forever be grateful. 10/10 recommend for anyone to visit!

Great place to eat on Nantucket. We stopped in for early dinner before the return ferry to the Cape. Split a burger (Reverend Foster) and Caesar salad with chicken. Burger was juicy, flavorful and hard to put down. The chicken tenders on the salad were some of the best I’ve had. The backyard patio area had a nice vibe. Highly recommend!

My wife and I had a wonderful experience, if you decide to go before you choose to either sit in the tavern or the back patio ask where Peter is serving and choose him! Not only did this man put up with both my wife and I, but when I jokingly said I would like this to come out in courses. He executed perfectly just enough time before our appetizers to have some convo and drinks, table clean up and then some of the sides/salads to come up, clean up and more convo and drinks until the first entrée we split, clean up and our final entrée to split, and enough time to settle down and finish our drinks before bringing the check. Peter definitely was a professional and made our dinner a dream date. And just before we left, Peter brought us some expresso martini shots on the house. Circling back to dinner though, we had ordered a lobster linguine which was to die for, an appetizer of fries, a small side salad, and lobster bisque. The food was top notch and I would 100% go again. P.S. My wife asked to get on the waiting list and it was 1.5 hours. We checked the bar areas for seating then I asked to get on the waiting list and it was 1 hour (again this was less than 5 minutes from my wife asking). So we went across the street for some drinks (also highly recommend Ethos wine bar) and got texted in less than 10 minutes that are table was ready. Their wait time tracking is terrible and the most inaccurate I have ever witnessed. So beware.

Always a great meal and never disappoints. As usual the burger was great and the sushi was a winner too! It's always cozy inside no matter the seat so it's especially welcoming during the colder fall days.

We stopped by Brotherhood of Thieves on a Saturday afternoon in September. We were seated outside at a very cozy and romantic table for two that was a bit separate from others. It was really nice. We started with shrimp cocktail, which were massive. I have never seen shrimp this big. We also shared shrimp tempura sushi for an appetizer, which was very tasty. For my meal, I ordered the Caribbean Buffalo tenders, which were probably the best tenders ever. They were very flavorful with a sweet and spicy taste. I normally wouldn't order buffalo tenders, but someone at a nearby table got them and they smelled amazing. Definitely try them! My husband ordered the salad with lobster, avocado, corn and mango, which he devoured. If you visit Nantucket, I highly recommend Brotherhood of Thieves. It's not quite as expensive or upscale as some of the other establishments on the island, but the food is fantastic!

I'm so glad this restaurant is back! After it reopening last year it's been the island staple. From the cozy dark downstairs dining room to the beach theme upstairs bar/dining room, whole vibe is amazing. Food is superb, ranging from fresh sushi, steak to the best French onion soup! Anything you get at Broho is gonna make your mouth water! My favorites are the boom boom shrimp and the egg rolls! And if you're looking for an awesome burger they will deliver, my favorite is the Cisco Burger.

I haven't been back since the outdoor area has opened up and what a treat!! This bar would never have come up on my list of best espresso martinis on the island, but I'm a convert! Possibly one of the best drinks I had during my whole stay. The food menu looked awesome and the bartender at the outdoor bar was very friendly and damn good at his job! This place will definitely be making the short list for future ACK visits

Wow- this restaurant was an experience!! The fresh seafood is incredible and the atmosphere is fancy and fun. It's super clean and I thought the restrooms were pretty nice too. The lobster roll and swordfish were incredible along with the clam chowder. All 3 are a MUST! I would love to eat this every day if I could. My biggest criticism here is that the employees at the front took so long to help us make a reservation and had a huge line forming in back of us. They very clearly did not know what they were doing and didn't seem to care about helping the customers or the long line. It was some really awful service and I was surprised by the lack of professionalism here. Most everyone else we encountered here at least tried to be friendly and professional though the service as a whole did not live up to expectations with the high prices. However, the seafood was so good and I assume it is expensive so I would still say pricing is very fair. I would just hope some better service would come along with it in the future.

Great spot in late May for a drink and a bite. Orders a few of their drinks and some wine to start off. The Thai chicken lettuce wrap was flavorful, cool and refreshing. Ordering these to start is a great way to open your appetite.

Best burger in New England! Make a reservation, it's busy for a reason. Food is delicious. They serve a great Guinness on tap.

IMHO, Probably one of the best meals I had on Nantucket. Came with no reservation on a Monday and the downstairs was packed. Was told to give the upstairs whiskey bar a try if they had any open seats and well, they did. There is a staircase in the back at connects them. Was able to order the same menu upstairs. Service from Brooke was great. Got the Thai Chicken Lettuce Wraps and the Braised Short Rib Entree (so I could get the roasted broccoli and smoked Gouda orzo mac, which won me other the sandwich version). The lettuce wraps were packed well with chicken salad. Wow. Not sure if that was because it was the end of the evening or not. The short rib entree was perfect in all regards. Proper portions, great complimentary flavors in each part of it. Tender short rib, perfectly roasted broccoli and all over a "bed" of cheesy orzo. Nice draft and bottled beer menu, which was unexpected. Highly recommend.

Brotherhood of Thieves has a really extensive menu. It's a great place to go if a group of people need a lot of options. I called in two meals and found the service to be good. I really enjoyed the sushi menu and loved the Dragon which consisted of crab, avocado, cucumber, topped with bbq eel, avocado, and sweet soy. ($24) I also really like the Caterpillar which consisted of crab and cucumber, topped with avocado, sweet soy, tempura crunch ($24) During a different meal, I had the fish and chips ($28) which is beer battered cod, with curly fries and cole slaw. Overall, it's a nice restaurant to check out.

The best, most consistent restaurant on Nantucket! Fantastic service from Petar and the Manager last night! My wife had the Bang Bang Shrimp and some Sushi and she said that they both were off the charts delicious!!! I had the 1/2 Roasted Chicken w/ Carrots and Mashed Potatoes, and it was unbelievable, and suffice it to say, I would dare to say that it was superb! Probably the very best chicken dish that I have ever had!!! If you are on Nantucket for even just a day, The Brotherhood is the first place that I would recommend for lunch, dinner OR both!!!

Brotherhood of Thieves is my favorite restraunt to visit when coming to Nantucket. The food is always great, perfectly cooked burgers and steak, tasty sushi rolls, and plenty of drink options for the adventurous drinker. Perhaps the best part of brotherhood is that there are three different seating options, the whiskey room, the pub, and Cisco kitchen. This allows for the guest to choose the vibe they want for their meals. Waiters/waitresses are always friendly and receptive to questions and requests.

Very charming place, with friendly staff (though service was slow) and Nantucket pricing (so outrageous for anywhere but Nantucket). We ordered from a verity of the menu, including a burger a salad and some sushi, everything was decent, but nothing really stood out. Probably would have given it a 3.5 if I had the option

Loved this establishment in the center of town. Although we were not able to eat here EVERYTHING that came out of the kitchen looked phenomenal. I preferred the openness of the upstairs bar as compared to the downstairs bar. It had a real authentic pub feel and lots of good Cisco Brewery beers on tap. They also had a full sake menu which you do not see often at a pub - -! Looking forward to heading back here for sure!

If you're downtown and looking for a casual lunch that is both family friendly and enjoyable, this works. I wouldn't say a ton of ambiance in the back patio, but they make it work. Known for their more casual eats of burgers and chowder, they've revamped in recent years. Kids menu. Check. Warm Cisco beer. Check. And not in a good way. Eh Cisco brewery style cocktails? Check. Healthy menu items including a poached lobster salad? Check. A solid fish sandwich? Check. Great service in an outdoor shaded space? Check. Room for larger parties? Check. While I don't do downtown lunches often, this was a nice kid-friendly option. Nothing crazy here, but does the trick. On a rainy day, the inside pub is where I'd want to be* * disclaimer: this rings true if I did not have 2 young kids and could saddle up to the bar.

This place doesn't miss. Customer service was supreme, food was delightful, and the interior design is incredible. Check out the upstairs. Would recommend a resi even for lunch Chowdah is creamy - quality ingredients 7/10

nice atmosphere, average food, rude service. I gave a 10% gratuity for a $220 bill--mediocre food, two orders arrived 10-15 minutes after 3 of our party had been served, water glasses never refilled despite twice requesting additional water. Our waiter removed the receipt (with gratuity ascribed) from our table--a restaurant no-no! Worse, the waiter returned and pointedly asked if that was the "correct gratuity." When I said,"yes, it is," the waiter appeared angry, muttered something, and walked away. We were shocked by his rude, disrespectful, and unprofessional behavior. Hopefully, this restaurant's management reads this review and addresses such rude behavior. The waiter was male, late 20s, and had an accent.

Bucket list to spend a few hours on Nantucket. I have read every Elin Hildebrand, when I found out she was retiring, and her last book was coming out on my birthday, June 11. I booked a flight to Boston. Bada Bing. We met her, cried, laughed and went in search of lunch. Walked into the Brotherhood, were seated immediately and had one of the top 3 chowders of New England

My friend and I decided to abandon our reservation we made a month in advance at another restaurant because we saw that this place was POPPING late on a Sunday night, which may have been one of the best decisions on our trip! We got here a little earlier than our reservation so we went to the bar and ordered drinks. I got the blueberry lemonade which was very tasty, although a little sweet for my liking. The hostess found us by the bar and seated us for our reservation. it was unseasonably cold and we lucked out by being seated right next to the fireplace so it felt like fall instead of almost summer. A sign of a good menu is when you could easily see yourself enjoying multiple items. Brotherhood of Thieves has an extensive menu and I could have easily ordered salmon, pasta, burgers, sushi rolls, the short rib sandwich, or a lobster and been happy. We asked our server what was popular and he said basically everything. The service was great overall, although it was busy, our server was attentive and helpful, and we didn't feel rushed. So we ended up ordering the sage-pesto salmon and the lobster fettucine. They were both INCREDIBLE. The salmon was perfectly cooked and so flavorful and the mashed potatoes were so delicious. The only con was the brussels sprouts were undercooked so they were a little tough and hard to eat. The pasta was perfectly al dente with large chunks of lobster meat, spinach, and little bursts of tomato. The sauce was also surprisingly light given that it was a cream sauce. They also have an amazing dessert menu and we definitely saved room. We ordered the Brohood chocolate chip cookie sundae. Holy moly it was delicious. The cookie was slightly undercooked so it was gooey and melded perfectly with the not overly cold ice cream.

I came here solo on a weeknight, eager to check this place out since it came highly recommended. The place was packed, but I was able to find a small high top table near the bar. I ordered a lobster roll and it took over an hour to arrive which would've been fine I guess if the food was actually good. The lobster was tough and rubbery and the fries were pale and limp. I was left wondering why this place is so hyped up when both the food and service are not all that good.

Love the old restaurant with tons of history! The food was amazing. Best truffle fries I've ever had in my life!

Fun pub with all the style, ambiance and service to go along. Beer selection is ample and reasonably priced. Love the varied menu options from full entrees to sandwiches and salads. The burgers are fantastic and mine was cooked to perfection- medium- slightly pink and juicy. I'd opt for the side salad rather than the fries. And friends if you can sit at the bar. It's just more fun. Enjoy!

Such a cool spot! Old school tavern with a lot of history. The food was incredible!! The cheesesteak wontons were crispy, cheesy and flavorful. Highly recommend as an app! The lobster roll was the best I've had on my trip yet! Huge chunks of lobster, with a light mayo sauce, and a light brioche bun! Paired perfectly with curly fries.

The service was solid with just enough attentiveness. The food was tasty and when we ordered extra wasabi for our sushi they were very generous. I would return again.

Visited Nantucket for the day yesterday and thought this would be a nice stop for lunch. Easy walk from the ferry area or Main Street. For 1:00-1:30 lunch it was pretty busy but not overly. So cute! Generous portions of food. I had the chicken caprese sandwich with fries and my friend had a burger (on gluten free roll). I had the Cisco Brewery Lady Grey 16 ounce draft and my friend had a glass of Pinot noir..... what a good pour! Prices very good for Nantucket. Our server, Eva, was friendly and attentive. Highly recommend.

After taking a day trip to Nantucket, we decided to stop at Brotherhood of Thieves for a quick lunch. There was a short wait of around 10 minutes. The restaurant offers both inside and outside seating; we chose to sit inside. The interior was very quaint and had an antique feel. I ordered the Brohood sushi roll and the crab cakes appetizer. The waiter informed us that the sushi rolls come from a separate kitchen. So be aware that other entrees might come out first. The crab cakes were good and tasted fresh, though the aioli was just okay and the Frisée lettuce was a bit too large. The sushi roll was very good, although a bit expensive for a 10-piece roll at $24. Overall, I would recommend checking this place out as it is a nice spot to visit right after arriving on Nantucket Island.

Had to wait past reservation, kept getting shuffled around and the bar was standing room only. I made this reservation as fast as I was able 30 days before the date. Terrible table by the kitchen. Good oysters and steak. Slow service. Just so busy and slammed that it took forever to receive service. Poor staff -all sweaty and disheveled.

Love the history of the location! Very cool authentic feeling restaurant with friendly staff. To be fair I should have gone with my gut and tried the sushi which looked fantastic (huge rolls). My husband had the warm lobster roll which I sampled and it was warm buttery goodness! His fries were covered in salt with no seasoning. I had the Latin crusted salmon and it was underwhelming (the verde sauce was dried like it was sitting in the pickup window) and the corn was literally like a dozen kernels, but the grilled sweet potato was so great. The tuna crudo appetizer was a hit. I would return and try some other items from the menu.

Good service and good food. Our waiter was very attentive even though he had many other tables. We put our name down and they quoted us a longer wait time than what we actually had to wait. I recommend hanging around close by while waiting for a table. This place had one of our most favorite clam chowders. Lobster avocado salad was good. Was a big dish so be sure to share! Lobster fettuccine was yummy too.

Food and service were great. My husband and I each got a chowder which was great. I got the spicy rigatoni vodka which was delicious and my husband got the cali burger with a side salad, which he really enjoyed. He also got a guavarita, which was delicious. Restaurant itself is super cute too. Recommend!

There is a friendly atmosphere at this place. We were served right away and paid attention to. The server warned us the sushi and meal would come out different times but it was fine because we were sharing both! The veggie roll was fresh and good. The veggie burger was amazing ! The best veggie burger I have ever had as a vegan for ten years. I asked for no cream and it was *crispy* and filling. My only qualms are that the fries were too soft & the bathroom sink would not turn off. Also, my spicy marg was not super tasty, but I liked the spicy rim.

Amazing food, we got the fish and chips- battered and so light and not heavy which is rare for fish and chips, the fish was cooked perfectly, fries were delicious, tartar sauce was also very good and the slaw was crunchy! Probably the best fish nd chips I've ever had. We got the Cisco beach roll and some sashimi. The fish was oh so fresh! Very impressive. Lobster fettuccine is to die for, the lobster was tender and not rubbery! Espresso martinis were delicious both ways. The only thing is that we checked in with the host 30 minutes prior to our reservation and had us wait 15 minutes over our reservation time, when they seated us , there were tons of open tables so I'm not sure where the miscommunication was.

The bars are great - super crowded, yet the service was hard to beat. Feels like tour back in the 1800s will low ceilings and dark wood. Food is excellent along with the cocktails!

Really good place for lunch in Nantucket. We got some good advice from a guide at the visitor center, to come to Brotherhood for good food and to get out of the rain on a Friday. I was able to make a reservation via Resy, but turned out I didn't really need it. They opened their doors at exactly 11:30am, and there were two hostesses manning the outdoor check-in. We got in line to check-in, and they immediately seated us in a table around 11:35. For future reference, one can eat at the bar without having to checkin outside, but if you want to eat at a table, one has to check-in with the folks outside (I saw/heard a lot of potential customers being nicely told that they needed to go back outside...it is not a great set-up since customers coming from one side of the street would see the entrance before the checkin station). This is more important for dinner, where I'm sure it is a lot busier. Cisco Brewery (supposingly not related to Cisco Technology or Sysco Foods) is local to Nantucket and the restaurant had a selection on tap. We tried a 16oz of the Witbier (Grey Lady) for $11, and I thought it was just OK...a bit watery, easy to drink...nothing to excite your nose or taste buds. My wife tried the Fish and chips ($28), and it was a great example of a proper English fish at a pub...it was a giant piece of cod, beer battered..could feed two people for lunch, equivalent of 3 big pieces of cod at other places. The batter wasn't light, but wasn't overly coated either. It came with vinegary cole slaw and curly fries. The fries weren't great...a lot of 'nub' pieces and the spiral pieces were often undercooked or just steamed because most of the surface area didn't touch the hot oil. I ordered the Brotherhood burger ($18.5), a mix of chuck, brisket, and tri-tip with backyard toppings (lettuce, tomato, onion) with choice of cheese. I adore these kind of burgers, mainly because of the simple but satisfying toppings...knowing this, I asked for heavy lettuce and tomato with mayo. The meat is the star here, and it was cooked to well (my bad since I asked for it medium-well not knowing the meat quality...hoping they could keep a little pink, but admittedly difficult to do). It had a very strong char-broiled flavor, and had a large amount of swiss (I forgot to ask for it with cheddar)....the meat was of excellent quality and next time, I would order it medium-rare. The toppings (besides the cheese) were a bit weak...shredded lettuce, very thin slice of tomato, a little onion. They came with the same uninspired fries. Colleen was our waitress and she was superb throughout, always checking in on us to see how we were doing, making it a real enjoyable stay. They also have a large Japanese Sushi menu, and one of the waiters was raving about it...sorry, just can't get myself to do that from a place that also serves hamburgers and fish'n'chips.

Well we went into the basement's bar and dam! We all got seats , got some apps ie Buff fingers, truffle fries, cali sushi roll and some lettuce chicken wraps . All gone that's about it. Highly recommend you hit this place if your here for a quick stay.

Great whiskey bar upstairs !! I highly recommend it and the staff is great! Great vibes!

Honestly, this was our best dining experience on the island. We loved the food, the atmosphere, but most of all, ANI was absolutely AMAZING. He was kind, funny, patient, and attentive. When we asked for a garnish he was unfamiliar with, he looked it up to ensure that we were happy. We ordered an array of items. The oysters were extremely fresh and the swordfish cooked perfectly. The chowder and sushi were equally delicious. Ani, thank you so much for making this experience unparalleled on our trip.

Ate lunch here the other day. Just far enough away from hustle of Nantucket landing. My daughter found this place on yelp so we tried it out. Really solid sushi both pieces and rolls. Excellent clam chowder and apps. Great service and nice atmosphere. Would definitely come again.

This restaurant was suggested to us while on ferry to Nantucket. I would say DO NOT go there. Food was mediocre at best. I had the Thai lettuce wraps and there was nothing Thai about. Bland and boring. My friend had a Cobb salad and it was the same. The fries were overcooked. AVOID.

4 of us went last night, my 1st time sitting in the new indoor patio are. Everything was great, service very good. Very attentive. We had the shrimp appetizer and I had. The salmon which was delicious w filling. Met friends got sushi and the plates were ample. Definitely would recommend and go back!

The bartender was very welcoming. The sushi roll was fresh and delicious. Margarita was perfect

Historic location with British Pub Decor & Charm. Service was quick & attentive. Burger was First Class.

Love the atmosphere here. Dark wood with a bar in the center of the room. Seating at the bar or tables all around. They have a large sushi menu. Did not expect to see sushi here. The table next to us said it was very good. We all loved our food!

Enjoyed this meal the other day with 2 others. The 3 of us were craving sushi and were very happy with this place. The triple salmon and everything rolls were excellent - and big enough to be an entree by themselves. The spicy lobster was a bit smaller than the other 2 rolls. Also enjoyed the lavender lemonade. Delicious. We will be back next time we visit Nantucket.

We got the warm butter lobster roll and swordfish sandwich and they were both amazing but the swordfish sandwich was out of this world. Best fish sandwich I have ever had. The staff and waiters were incredibly friendly and the vibes are lovely.

I have never had a bad experience in any of 4 dining areas/bars in Brotherhood. Staff is exceptional including hostesses/host through our server and general manager. I had the best salmon salad, everything was fresh and my parents enjoyed their meals as well (burger and house salad). The jumbo cocktail shrimp were out of this world and the homemade cocktail sauce was to die for. Can't wait to go back to Brotherhood next time I am on the island!

Amazing raw oysters! Tuna Todtadas definitely a must!!!! Spicy Guavarita!!! Awesome service and super tasty!!!

Sushi is ok the chowder is delicious . Nice interior service is good . This place is pretty pack at night.

we love the brotherhood! we especially love the manager, Ryan. he is always so kind, helpful, and accommodating. he's also handsome! albi, our waiter, was funny and welcoming. we love coming here. thanks for the hospitality!!

Heard this was a must do in Nantucket, and it did not disappoint. The decor is quintessential old whaling bar -- so warm and cozy on a cold night! The Blackened Swordfish sandwich was AMAZING. So tasty. I ordered it with a salad subbed for fries but it came with fries. They promptly corrected the mistake. I anticipated decent pub food, but it greatly exceeded that.