Brother's Pizza

I gave it 2 stars because of the price increase. It used to be $2.50 and now it's $3 and ever since it went up I don't go as much as I used to. I know if the owner reads this they are going to say it's because of the inflation and/or the companies raised their prices on the Ingredients but they also have to understand that as the prices go up, us customers are struggling as well as our jobs don't give us a raise in our paychecks either. UPDATE---August 2022. I waited a while to post up this picture here. I bought a slice with extra cheese and if I am paying $1 extra, I expect my whole slice to be covered with cheese but instead the guy with the green eyes gives me this here SMH. Not only did they raise the slice to $3 but now they make them smaller and I paid $4 for this so called extra cheese slice which is NOT worth it at all. On top of that, at this pizza place you end up spending $20-25 on GrubHub plus the tip at this place because the medium and large pies are $15 and up. There is a pizza place on Moshulu Parkway that I got a lasagna AND one slice with tip included for $12 using GrubHub. If you want to save some money and not be disappointed with the size of the slices here, just look elsewhere or look up the Pizza shop on Moshulu Parkway where the slices are $1. Again, here is the slice with extra cheese that's $4

Worst place ever I ordered the pizza at 8:53 PM. I didn’t get the pizza until 9:56 pm it took them a hour to bring me my pizza I’m only ten mins away on top that they took forever to bring me my pizza they didn’t get the order right I order A large pepperoni pizza, I got a medium cheese pie it was cold and burnt worst pizza ever!! Last time I ordered from there if it was up to me, I wouldn’t even give it a star I’ll let the picture talk for it self

Unfortunately “Brother’s Pizza” is no longer available for business anymore. They are out of business due to not paying “rent” for over a year now, from what I was told by new renters who open up their business here now. It’s a pizza business that they have now in this exactly same place. The name to this new business for this place is called “The Best Pizza”, would suggest to give it a try and check it out. You won’t be disappointed, even thought it is not the same without the Italian pizza business there anymore. Would recommend to still give it a chance, to check out the new place pizza because the workers here are very cool, friendly and hard working workers. Lastly, you will be missed “Brother’s Pizza” Italian. Honest to God, I’m sad now that is no longer in business. You will be missed!

This pizza place is one of the few places that is definitely excellent, and the pizza tastes very good. Workers are very nice people who make sure that the pizza you get is delicious. Overall, it’s an amazing place and it’s worth checking out. It’s a bit costly, but it’s worth it for the tasty pizza that you will receive. Oh, one final thing. Don’t forget to tip the workers' jar if you are able to, of course, because they are humble people and deserve better.

Super tasty fresh slice of cheese pizza!! Very fast line, barely any wait, pizza slice for $1! A must try!

Amazing pizza!! As well as the beef patty with cheese and coco bread!! Ate it so no pic lml affordable and delicious!! Mas de ahi se daña!

IM IN DISBELIEF THIS PLACE IS NO MORE!! IT WAS BOUGHT OFF BY COFFEE SHOP AND IS NOW CALLED KINGSBRIDGE PIZZA!! This cannot be the same!! This was the pizza place to go to because they were Italian and better than Tony’s pizza next door! This won’t be the same with a Mexican making pizza. (Mind you Tonys pizza has tht and their reviews are horrible)😦 My stars are for the brothers pizza not tht garbage their making now

Prepaid at 11am for a 5pm delivery…my pizza was delivered 45 minutes late and cold. The owner’s son took my order and told me that 5pm was a great time since he had other deliveries to make earlier in the day. He also was making pizza without wearing gloves and handling money without washing his hands. I was not given a discount or complimentary garlic knots for my order being almost an hour late. I’m extremely disappointed and will never give this business another penny. Cross Morris Ave and go to their competition.

The service sucks the pizza is garbage the cheese is curdled and the manager today 8/20/2022 was very rude and hung up cause I was a 1st time client complaining about there sucky pizza!! YOUR FOOD SUCKS AS WELL AS YOUR SERV SpaghettiICE!!!!

Excellent authentic Italian cuisine perfect attention to detail on the food and service family business I will forever and always go here when I'm in town Every bit made my day brighter The setting and ambiance is very Italian home Style you walk in and your knowing good food is there

Super super thin crust overcooked hard as a rock..I ordered two pies came out to $40 and on top of that it was ice cold when I finally got the food very disappointed especially having small children and they didn't even want to eat it. So disappointed first and last time I will ever order again from there. Such a rip off..

I grew up on Brother's Pizza. I miss walking down to get a slice or grabbing a pie to bring home.

Really bland and dry pizza. Customer service was nice but definitely will not be going there again.

I ordered a pie from seamless over an hour ago. I called them and was told that they had left with my pie a while ago. The pie finally arrived and it was freezing cold!!! I called them back and the woman said "Well, I don't know what to tell you." Told me to call seamless to get my refund and hung up on me! DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME OR MONEY! THE CUSTOMER SERVICE IS AWFUL!!! I truly wish I can give zero stars!

Delivery always on time...pizza, all food nice fresh n right on point, Will recommend to everyone i know and wont complaint at all

This place used to be good the lady is so kind. However there's this one older man behind the counter extremely rude. He makes it seem as if he's doing you a favor for getting a slice ready. I ordered spaghetti a few weeks ago the sauce was sour and watery. A cheap place for bad and nasty pizza.

I been ordering all summer since Giovanni's went out of business. The food is ok but there service sucks. We order are norm on a Friday night on GH and waited hours. So I called to ask what happened and a old man told me he canceled my order because they too busy. No one ever called me and my 2 little girls and wife we very hungry when I got home. Since you are so busy let me help you by never ordering again.

I literally just paid $4 for crap... never ever will I come back. $4 for a SLICE WITH SOME VEGGIES ON IT IS WAY TOO MUCH!

I would rate them zero stars if possible. After waiting an hour for my delivery and calling because I did not receive it, the owner argued with me that I did and that his delivery man was right. The customer service is provided by the owners and they are disgusting people to interact with as a customer. No thank you.

Stay the hell away from this place!!! Aside from the mediocre tasting pizza, the calzones suck (and I'm partly saying that because I found a hair in mine GROSS), The only redeemable thing were the buffalo wings but they were too few for the price. Poor Quality in food and sanitation. So do yourselves a favor and skip, avoid, do not enter this place!!! ABANDON ALL HOPE, ALL YE WHO ENTER!

nice ghetto spot with large, greasy slices that are sure to ill you up and raise your artery clotting. Nevertheless, the place has been here forever and its kinda worth eating if you are low on cash and don't want assorted great in a box from Kennedy's or whatever the hell it is that Golden Krust claims they sell.

Hands down the worst pasta dishes my co-worker and I have ever had. Nothing hurts worse than receiving food so awful that you have no choice but the throw it in the trash where it belongs. Please for the love of god stay as far away from the pasta at all costs.

I didn't eat here and wouldn't. The guy at the counter had a dirty white torn shirt on that showed off his midriff. It's like Appalachia but dirtier.