Stephanie D.
Yelp
My family absolutely cannot get enough of the pies from this place. We're thoughtful eaters and sometimes find traditional renditions of western favorites a little overwhelming (too heavy, to salty, to sweet!). Never so with the pies from Butter Love. Every month for the past two years we've ordered multiple whole pies to go and have never been disappointed. Our favorites include:
1.) The Chicken Pie. Somehow, this pie has convinced everyone in my family that it's at once comfort food AND health food. The crusts are light and crisp and flavorful without ever once feeling heavy. The filling is absolutely stuffed with flavorful lean white meat (how?!) and silky potatoes and peas. 10/10, this pie is a miracle. Every time my dad eats it, he's sits back in his chair and says "WOW this lady can BAKE!"
2.) The butterscotch pie, which is the perfect balance of sweet and bitter and smoothed out with a fluffy whipped cream topping. It goes down so smooth I have this fantasy that I get to eat one whole pie all by myself (but it's a fantasy because everyone else also gets "just one more slice" syndrome.)
3.) The butter pie, which is just bite after bite of gooey, chewy, bittersweet decadence. (The holiday version of the butter pie, which has all sorts of apple-cider-style spices in it, is even more delicious but its seasonal. This is fine; waiting on deliciousness just makes it more delicious.)
Some tips:
- Order ahead! Like a busy Marie Callender's from the 90's, the pies you want may not be around on the day you happen to swing by the bakery, so be sure to check the menu in advance and order a day ahead to ensure you get the flavor you want.
- Pies freeze great! In the magical off-chance that some parts of the pie survive dinner, OR if you think "I'd like a pie but I'm just one human how could I possibly order a whole chicken pie for myself?" I've discovered that leftover pie slices freeze great. Just wrap them up in foil or cling wrap, put them in a ziploc, and pop them in the freezer. Thaw the day you want them. Instant meal prep!
- Craving a pie that's not on the menu? Once after calling ahead we asked if the baker could make a chocolate satin pie. She very graciously agreed. She's world class at what she does so... yes, the pie was amazing. Esa, if you're reading this, thank you. We're so lucky to have you in our neighborhood. :)