Rita W.
Yelp
I've only had one other cookie specialty place around the area, and Butter Pecan Bakeshop cookies taste wayyyyyyyy better than that other overrated/overhyped chain. I was a bit skeptical at first since a cookie is $3.75 and it didn't look that big and thought well I could make myself a couple dozen for the same price, but then I thought I was too busy to shop for and bake cookies. My daughter had an orthodontist appointment around the area, so she and my husband stopped by Butter Pecan and picked up 6 cookies for $21- brings the price down just a bit per cookie.
What a nice surprise! The box was great and packaged nicely. Love their stable packaging! I asked what flavors they picked out, and they said they forgot. Great... after some quick research and stuff, I think we tried the following-
Birthday Cake (or funfetti)- those edges are everything. Nice amount of sweetness and richness from the crispy-ish edges. My fave part. Center was a lot softer.
Strawberries n cream- again I loved the edges. There were some strawberry bits in there too which I liked, but the husband thought it had an odd texture.
Tea cake- ?? Thought it was a snickerdoodle, but it wasn't. Really good cookie tho. One of my fave, esp the edges. A bit poofier, more volume in the softer cake like center, a lot less flavor throughout, but I loved it that way
Dark chocolate sea salt- pass for me. The cookie and dark chocolate was good, but not a fan with the sea salt. Others enjoyed it though.
Rocky road- thought it was chocolate marshmallow and I got excited until the nuts. Whoops, no more for me- dry throat reaction. My son loved this one!
Snickerdoodle- or churro? Very soft, semi crispy edges. I loved the cinnamon.
Can't wait to try more! We had a quarter of a few cookies leftover and left them overnight for a couple nights, and they were still good. Reheating them to your preference works too.