Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Arlington

It was a pie kind of day. We got 4 pies and here’s how we felt about them. The strawberry cream was by far one of the best in the bunch. It was kind of like eating a strawberry shortcake on shortbread, if that makes sense since the crust tasted like shortbread (10/10). The next one we tried was the coconut cream pie. The meringue on top was fluffy with coconut flakes on top. The custard tasted pretty good, like something I’ve had before. My boyfriend said that it was like eating an Almond-joy. The crust also tasted like shortbread which I’m actually liking more than the traditional graham cracker crust (8/10). The next one is a classic key lime pie. I’m a crust person and well, I wish there was more of it, so that was kind of a let down. The key lime flavor is not too tart and the cream on top was perfect. Overall, it’s a good pie, but not the best (8/10). The last pie was the banana cream pie which is one of my favorite flavors, and well, it was delicious! Another 10/10!! Definitely buying again. Price-wise, they’re more towards the pricy side given their small size and being at $6 each, but we got four, so that was actually $22. This was the second location I’ve been to, since I went to the one in Mansfield and well, you can read my review on that. Overall, it’s a nice place to stop by once in a while if you’re craving some pie. If you want something more affordable and decent, Walmarts got some 86 cents pies!

The pies here are so delicious! The key lime & chocolate cream pie are amazing. The staff are extremely friendly. Perfect dessert and they even have personal sizes so you can try smaller portions too.

This place is so good. The staff is always so friendly and welcoming. The pies are baked fresh daily. The crust is king. If you get the crust right the filling should come easily. The pecan pie is one of my favorite. The peanut butter pie is creamy and nutty. The coconut meringue pie is decadent. I've always purchased the minis. Just the right amount of yummy. They often have promotional deals and rewards for their repeat customers.

Amazing pie shop. Always has great flavors and the 4” pies are our family favorite, as everyone can have their favorite flavor. We love strawberry in the summer. Such great customer service, too!

These pies are delicious! Service was excellent as well. I wanted to try multiple flavors so I got the 4 mini pies ($16). If I had to choose a favorite then it would be their apple pie - best overall flavor & it was full of apple slices. I also really liked the other 3: buttermilk, pecan, and I 40 (chocolate & pecans). If you love pies, then this place is worth trying - so many other flavors to choose from. I will definitely be back for more!

Got some pies to go. Service was really friendly and helped with pie choices. Apple pies are made fresh daily in limited quantities, so they were out at the time. Pies tasted great. My favorite is Key Lime pie. It was a bit tart but tasted great! I look forward to tasting all of them!

Overall pretty good! Got a four pack minis to see what flavors I liked and I wasn’t disappointed! Favorite is the chocolate cream; least is the buttermilk. The latter was too bland in my opinion. The cookie was fine but it was super dry and it fell apart before I could get a nice pic of it :(

Purchased 3 pies and all pies were extra dry the flavor of the pecan pie was not normal the coconut cream was way to sweet and the banana pudding flavor is good just the crust makes it extra dry not worth the 25 dollars spent