Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Arlington

Ordered the four pie mini pack .. delivery came quickly. Pies are really delicious .. the coconut cream and buttermilk are my faves out of what we ordered ..our order came with a really sweet note! We will definitely order again…

I didnt realize that I walked in minutes before they closed, but I wouldn't have known by their courteous service! I was greeted warmly and treated kindly, with patience. I got the individual chocolate cream pie and it was great!! I especially liked that the pie crust was also chocolate. Will be back.

I got four individual, personal pies for me and my kiddos to share. The pecan pie is to DYE* for. Almost better than my great grandmother’s pecan pie and that’s saying something. I also had the banana cream pie which tastes similar to a banana pudding and is absolutely delicious. The southern cream was also very tasty, not as good as the other two but the other two flavors hit it out of the park. My kids really loved it too

Super cute pie shop! The pies are small but delicious. Great variety! We went looking for ice cream but they had none.. there also isn't a place to sit and it was like 105 outside so we stood around for a bit.

Besides the fact that the pies, and cookies, are delicious, the customer service is outstanding. We were throwing a birthday party, and the date kept changing, due to the birthday boy, having to go through some medical procedures. By the third time that I had to postpone my order, I was expecting to get some pushback, but every single time that I had to postpone it, they were so accommodating. Without knowing what our family was dealing with. So, of course Buttermilk Sky gets a 5* rating. We love them even more. Thank you.

The pies here are so delicious! The key lime & chocolate cream pie are amazing. The staff are extremely friendly. Perfect dessert and they even have personal sizes so you can try smaller portions too.

These pies are delicious! Service was excellent as well. I wanted to try multiple flavors so I got the 4 mini pies ($16). If I had to choose a favorite then it would be their apple pie - best overall flavor & it was full of apple slices. I also really liked the other 3: buttermilk, pecan, and I 40 (chocolate & pecans). If you love pies, then this place is worth trying - so many other flavors to choose from. I will definitely be back for more!

This is the third holiday I’ve purchased pies here, and I had multiple relatives ask me to bring the southern custard pie! They’re always prompt, my order correct, and the pies are delicious. Would recommend and worth the cost, for sure.