Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Colleyville

Purchased a coconut mirguine pie a few weeks back & the Flavor was phenomenal which was great. Maybe I’m spoiled by southern cooking in Alabama but my past mirguine pies were always fluffy, very tall & light which made them great but this mirguine was short, thick & gooey. Not sure I’m spelling it correctly but like sharing feedback if the management wants it & If not I understand. In all fairness I haven’t tried their other pies & they look delicious so I may return for a pecan pie. The owners/family are friendly & great people so I wish them the best!

Came by the other day to get my birthday pie. Ordered a regular size chocolate cream pie, paid while the attendant asked the lady in the back I'd they had any more. She said no but they could throw one together really quick. I said no, that I would just change to a banana cream pie. We got home and took the pie out a couple hours later, I noticed that the pie filling was pulling away from the pie crust and that the filling had a hardened like film on the top, you can see the color difference between the top layer and the rest of the filling, the top layer was rubbery...we went to cut it and the pie stuck to the knife like crazy. We ended up needing to rinse the knife off completely between slices. The filling had completely separated from the crust and was just clearly old. We ended up throwing our pie away. I'm pretty bummed since this was for my birthday. I've bought the 4 pack of mini pies here before and they've always been delicious. I hope they get this corrected sooner rather than later, but for the price I will try some more shops around before returning. The customer service was good, the reduced stars was because they sold me something that they didn't have in-stock. The ambience is adorable and well decorated for a pie shop.

Picked up two pies the Tuesday before Thanksgiving. Had easily placed and paid for my order online a few days prior. Pickup was quick, they had pies wall-to-wall. Everyone loved the Pumpkin and Apple pie. Pumpkin pie did say it’s only available 10/16-12/31

We had the Granny’s Apple Pie and were near speechless at the taste. It tastes like coming in from a crisp Autumn Day. It tastes like a Halloween afternoon just before you go trick or treating. It tastes like the end of Summer, in the best way. It was fresh out of the oven warm. The crust was sweet, buttery, and crumbly and spiced with what I can only describe as Autumn in a bottle. Inside, it had a sweet apple filling with just a dash of cinnamon that doesn’t overwhelm the fruit. This shop nailed this style of Apple Pie. Absolutely nailed it. If you want to taste the greatest way to ring in the start of spooky, witchy, sweater weather season, this is the way. 🍂🎃

Great treats shop with pie happiness in every ingredient of the business. Friendly staff who aim to please...and smell like pie! Up with pie. End the reign of cake and its cute allies cupcakes 😁

Great service, wish we had somewhere to sit and enjoy the pies! Came in and ordered: Banana Pudding, Key Lime, Apple and chocolate cookie. They were small and packaged well! They were tasty. The crust was soft and the pies were rich and creamy. The service was friendly and informative. We enjoyed getting to know their store and wish we could have enjoyed our pies inside!

I've been here twice, and have really enjoyed the pies. The decor is cute and makes for a nice atmosphere. I will say that I wish they had silverware that isn't wooden. I guess I have a sensory issue that makes eating my pie there with a wooden fork unbearable.

Wanna piece of me… I mean Pie? I thought you’d never ask. Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is worth the trip even if it’s way out of your way. Fresh homemade pies thumbprint cookies, s real cool Magnolia-esque vibe…. This place is adorable. Oh and the pie… I recommend the apple but you should also try the Cloud Nine which is any one of their pie flavors mixed up with Blue Bell. Yep. Together.

Pies are fabulous! And flavors change. But they sell out... So Better go early! Always a sweet young lady behind the counter. Small little place... With all the good stuff!

Bought two pies for Thanksgiving and they were a hit! We got the I-40 and the pumpkin pie. The I-40 was delightful with a great mix of flavors, and the pumpkin was classic and not too sweet. I just wish more flavors were available during the holidays, since the peanut butter one has been my favorite

Absolutely divine pies and exceptional service! Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is a must try! I ordered an assorted dozen of their 4-inch pies for a party. That amount fed 10 of us and we even had some leftover! When I picked up the pies, the lady helping me was very friendly and gave me info on how to store/warm the pies before I even asked! The carrier they placed the pies into made it very easy to transport. My personal favorite flavors were the Chocolate Chip, Pecan, and Apple. The pies were a massive hit and I can't wait to try more of their flavors!

As a sales representative who prefers to support small businesses, I've used Buttermilk Sky across multiple locations without issue--until now. Unfortunately, my experience at the Colleyville, TX location was deeply disappointing and unprofessional. I accidentally placed an order with the Colleyville location instead of the one I was physically at. Upon realizing my mistake, I immediately called Colleyville and spoke with the manager (who I later found out is the owner's son). I explained the situation, and he assured me the order could be canceled and refunded--no problem. The next day, I received a call from his mother, the owner, who stated that her son had no right to approve a cancellation and that she would not honor the refund. I was stunned--not only had I followed every step to do the right thing, I had received confirmation from the store's manager. Her response? Accusing me of not having the money to pay and suggesting I was trying to "get over" on their business. It was not only insulting but completely uncalled for. What's worse is that during the call, her son walked in and, when confronted, denied ever telling me I could cancel--despite the fact that he very clearly had. I have no reason to fabricate this, especially considering this was a small order and the refund has already been disputed through my corporate card. This experience was upsetting not just because of the refusal to refund, but because of how I was spoken to--dismissively, unprofessionally, and dishonestly. In the grand scheme of things, that single order was nothing compared to the potential repeat business they've now lost. Sadly, I'll never use this location again, and I caution others--especially those placing larger or corporate orders--to think twice. Customer service matters, and integrity matters more.

So many great things about this pie shop. Customer service was excellent! Prices are pretty good, 5 mini pies for $20. They have a huge selection of pies ready to go in both regular and mini size. It was compared to a cupcake variety as far as amount of choices. Now the pies. Pecan was my favorite of the ones I tried. It was sweet but not too sweet and the pecans were crunchy and plentiful. 5 The chocolate cream pie. The custard tasted cream and smooth. The crust was also chocolate but was kind of wet and falling apart. The flavor was good. 3 The strawberry pie had a strawberry filling but no actual strawberries: I'm thinking because strawberries don't last long in pie. The flavor was very good. 4 The banana cream pie. Custard was very good. No actual bananas again because real bananas go bad fast I would imagine. There was a vanilla wafer sticking out of the top, nice touch. 4 The shop was cute and whimsical.

Everything is always fresh and flavorful. Even when slammed, the staff keeps a smile on their faces

Customer service and consistency. Pies are okay one minute, then bad the next. Some staff are pleasant, some others, not so much.

Best pies around our family fell in love with the apple pie, the pecan pie as well The service was quick and very professional

Meh. Pies are bland and staff aren't friendly. Save your money go to Sonic next door.

I can't even describe how much I love this shop and their pies, but I'll sure try! I've been here on numerous occasions, and just thought to take pics in Pi Day (March 14). I've never had a bad pie here, but I totally fell in love with the limited edition Cherry Pie! It edged out the Apple, as my favorite! I love that you can get 4" pies instead of buying one large one (not that there's anything wrong with that!) My advise during busy seasons (Pi Day, Thanksgiving, Christmas, other food related holidays) is to call ahead or order online ahead so that you can be guaranteed your full share of deliciousness. Pie makes everything better. Go there, get some Pie. You'll be glad you did!

It's been a while since I've been here. I like that they have mini pies for when those cravings hit. Their pies have a good ratio between crust and filling too. Some places have too much crust for their mini pies. They offer seasonal flavors and I was looking forward to a pumpkin pie but unfortunately came in a bit too early. It's not available until later this month. We were in the area for dinner and decided to stop in to pick up dessert on the way home. We ended up getting 4 mini pies for $18 - key lime, I-40, peanut butter cream, and caramel turtle. All were great and even better with ice cream, which they also have available for purchase. The young gentleman was friendly and helpful. I do recall the customer service here being usually excellent in the past as well. I'll definitely make it a point to remember them for the upcoming holidays.

I haven't tasted any of the four pies that we ordered. My sister said they were good. The store people were excellent with good phone etiquette.So I'm going with them!!

So cute and absolutely delicious concept! I would recommend the I-40! It is like a pecan pie with lots of yummy extras :) There was not one flavor that I did not like. The pies are the perfect portion and even better when warmed up with a scoop of ice cream on top! They also have a rewards program that allows you to accumulate points for pies! Definitely give them a try the next time that you are in Colleyville or surrounding areas!

Appreciate how the pies are wrapped and given. Clean and presentable. Great and tasty pies...peanut butter pie is my favorite!

Was really disappointed when we showed up specifically for the pie a la mode, and they said they don't serve it. We ended up getting the mini apple pie and chocolate chip, which both were okay. We bought an overpriced pint of blue bell that tasted like sand. It must have melted and was re-frozen.

Holy guacamole. SO GOOD!!! I don't know what has come over me the last few months but I've been pie OBSESSED. I can't get enough of them! It was late Saturday night, and all of the sudden it hit me. THE PIE CRAVING HIT AND THERE WAS NO MAKING IT GO AWAY WITHOUT A PIE. My kids were mid bath. I knew I couldn't leave the house. But atlas, Uber Eats to the rescue. I didn't want a SLICE. I wanted the WHOLE DANG PIE. So I looked through a bunch of places and settled on this one. I'm so so glad I did!!! It was DELICIOUS and the pie got to me in record time! Such a great alternative for a cake or other goods. Highly highly recommend!

I'll be honest.. I struggle with how to rate this shop. The pies are good, but not great. Nothing wrong with them, but nothing exciting about them either. If you're in a pinch, need a pie for a party, you're just hungry for a pie, it'll hit the spot. But if you're expecting "amazing", you'll be disappointed. Maybe that's why I struggle with the review. Hard to get excited about, and highly rate a shop that is... forgettable? I've been to several of these throughout DFW and what I can say is that service is always good. The people are always friendly, and the stores are clean and well maintained.

I come here once a month and every time I come by it's always a delight. The smells are great, the pies are my favorite in the metroplex, and the thumbprint cookies are like crack! I've tried every flavor of pie (besides missing a seasonal or two) and they're all delicious. The staff is continually courteous and very friendly. I always look forward to swinging by and recommend you do too! (The peanut butter pie is my favorite!)

We go to Buttermilk Sky every chance we get. The pies are always fresh and delicious. They are the best pies in our area!

First time walk-in visitor. I ordered an individual key lime pie. I'm so glad that I waited until I got home before tasting it. It was so creamy and hearty that I would walked back in the store and ordered 2 more if I was still in the parking lot.

Great service and it served its purpose. If you don't like sweet pies (borderline too sweet) you won't like these. The apple was a good balance. The pecan and chocolate chip was extremely sweet.

This will be the second time I go to Buttermilk Sky Pie for my pies for Thanksgiving. I love pecan pie and it really just reminds me of my aunt. We used to go and buy mini pecan pies when I lived in CA and this pie really hits home. It can be a hit or miss with pecan pie. Too much gooey center (no thank you) but this pie is just the right amount of pecans, gooey center and the perfect crust! I do recommend placing your order if you do plan to order for the holidays!

It's supposed to be a chocolate cream pie, but it's more like chocolate pudding in a pie tin. We are very disappointed in this pie as well as management of this pie shop. We purchased a 9 inch pie based on a 4 inch pie that we bought yesterday, which had Oreo cookie crust all the way around and at the bottom. The larger pie did not have any crust around the sides, and when I called the manager/owner to inform her, she told me that she knew that it did not have any crust around the edges And even made a comment to her staff that it needed to be crust around the edges. She sold the pie anyway knowing that it was not a good quality pie and when I called she did not try to compensate us for such bad pie. I know who not to call for my holiday pies.

This pie shop is a really cute idea! My husband loves pie so I figured this was the perfect thing to surprise him with for his birthday! I did not realize how getting 6 little pies was going a bitttt overboard haha but we loved trying them all. My favorite was the standard apple pie and the PB pie. My husband really liked the key lime which tasted similar to cheesecake. The coconut cream also deserves a honorable mention. These weren't the best pies we have ever tried, the concept is neat and its a fun dessert. Only one pie could for sure be a nice ending to date night and could be shared- only about $5!

Goodness gracious this place is so good. The homemade whipped cream and their pie crust is UNBEATABLE!! It's sooo delicious that I'm convinced you can put anything in the pie crust and it will probably taste good. So impressed by this place.

Sadly, a bad experience after several years purchasing wonderful pies from the Colleyville, TX store, has us writing this poor review. A foreign object was in our Granny's Apple Pie. Fortunately, the shiny aspect of the object allowed our Thanksgiving Day guest to see it before being ingested. The round metallic ring was embedded in the upper part of the pie crust (see provided photos). When reaching out to the store owners to make them aware, we were shocked at their accusatory and seemingly uncaring attitude. We won't be back!

The best pies, delivery included a beautiful card thanking us for our order. Best customer service and pies were to die for!

I got two mini pies, PIE places are a rare Thing these days. Coconut - it had meringue and not whip topping that's ding number one, it was not a cream pie at all but was custard like and very very sweet. The crust was stuck to the pie tin. Pecan - Very sweet was better then the coconut but these mini pies seem like they were frozen and thawed vs actually being fresh. Really bummed since this place had tons of good reviews.

This place is HEAVEN ON EARTH. I had the chocolate Pecan pie today and it drove me wild. There was even a hint of coconut. The pie crust was so buttery and perfect. I will be doing birthday pies instead of cakes going forward. This place is a game changer. Any occasion to celebrate will involve a visit to Buttermilk Sky!

Amazing pie! We ordered a 41 South pie, there are no words to paint this pie any justice! This pie was the king on the dessert table for Thanksgiving. All of the ingredients meshed together so well and melted in your mouth like ice cream. This pie will not disappoint, if you plan on purchasing this for a potluck, Christmas, or just because. Go get one or two...you'll be pleased.

I'm in town about 10 days a month. I have been stopping by to try the chocolate/chocolate ganache thumbprint cookies for months. I don't want to buy a dozen because I'll end up eating all of the cookies, but I will allow myself a couple of cookies. Today I'm elated that they made my quest for these cookies and I bought two chocolate/ chocolate, and two plain/chocolate ganache. I am thrilled to report that my impression of what the chocolate/chocolate ganache were going to taste like has extremely exceeded my expectations. These cookies were tasty, delicious, and decadent! I have also tried almost every pie except for the coconut one because I've never been a fan of coconut. The pies are truly fantastic too. Hence, I would highly recommend this pie shop for their pies and cookies. Thank you ladies!!!

Great pie! Great customer service! Very much made from scratch as you can taste the butter in the crust. My favorite is key lime pie. A must try!!!

Pretty good pie place. I like the mini 4 inch pies. I found this place waiting on some friends for dinner next door. They had a few samples cut and I fell in love with the I-40. It had a chewy and sweet filling. The crust was nice and moist. Cashier and employees were very friendly. Will come back for sure to try their other pies.

I ordered the coconut cream pie and I couldn't even finish it. Too sweet for me. I was disappointed being I had been craving it and finally got it to not even enjoy it.

Love, love, love this bakery. My friend and I stopped and had a small individual pie each and a cup of delicious tea. The actual eating area is very small with only a few seats however most people seem to be taking their pies to go. It's a bit pricey but well worth the price and I can't wait to go back and try a new pie.

Extremely friendly folks! Visiting from California and the owner was very helpful with flavor suggestions and even gave us some bbq joint recommendations. My fave had to be the pecan with the chocolate cream at a super close 2nd. My bf liked mixing the apple pie with the peanut butter cream pie. Sounds weird I know, but if you eat your fresh apples with pb then this is a must try!

It doesn't matter if you order Apple, Cherry or get the I-40. I'm pretty sure these are the pies that will be served in heaven!!!

Good pie , pricey but good. Shop is clean . Prices went up (as with everything these days ) but still a good little coconut creme pie

I just tried two of my pies ( coconut, key lime) and they are ridiculously GOOD! They taste like they are homemade, the meringue is smooth and light and the graham cracker is buttery sweet goodness. I'm sure the other two ( I-40, Apple) are just as good. I will definitively be back.

The pies are amazing. Be sure to buy a couple because you can't eat just one. They have a rewards program and the staff is amazing.

I always thought I was a cake guy... blown away by their delicious pies. The PB and I40 pie was fantastic.

Been here a few times for breakfast, it was amazing! The pancakes and French toast were delicious with eggs ham and home fries, a perfect sweet and salty breakfast! Next time we'll try lunch!

The owners here are great but the pies are not. We tried three varieties. The coconut taste was ok but not the best. The chocolate was just basically pudding in a tin covered by whip cream. I could make the same with in my kitchen with a box of jello pudding mix. And the peanut butter was just ok but not something to go back for. Def not worth the prices but so glad I bought the minis and not the full Pies!!! You'll do better heading to the grocery and buying Marie Callender!! A fun little trip to celebrate Pii Day but not for us as repeat customers. But again, the owners were super nice and run a good franchise. It's just the product that left more to be desired. I wish them the best of luck!

I randomly came across this place and decided to try it out. I wasn't disappointed! The staff were friendly and helped me choose my flavors. I got the chocolate cream and key lime. Both were delicious. The chocolate custard was creamy and rich, but the star for me was the key lime pie. It was perfectly sweet and not too tart. Soooo good! I wish I had tried some of the other goodies available, but that won't be my last visit. Also, I found that they have an email club where you get a free 4" pie upon sign up & on your birthday. Nice!

I first ordered their mini-pies back in February as a gift to be delivered. They were hits! So much so that when my wife and I returned to Texas, the recipients of the mini-pies insisted on showing us just how good by bringing one of their large I-40 pies home for us to eat. It was AMAZING! So amazing, in fact, that while we were still visiting in Texas, we actually returned to try their Key Lime and Peanut Butter Cream pies. Yep! They all rocked! But, do yourself a favor and pick up one of the I-40 pies first. I'm betting after that . . . THIS will be your pie shop forever!

These are some great pies!! We got key lime, pecan chocolate chip, apple and chocolate cream and all four were great! I'm glad we found this place and now can recommend to others.

I have died and gone to heaven after stumbling upon this pie shop on Yelp. I stopped in on a Saturday and they're open but closed to guests coming in so I dialed the number on the door. I had a coupon for BOGO mini pie for signing up for email (woo hoo!). I got 2 mini coconut cream pies and they were out of this world delicious. Even the crust was outstanding! Best. Coconut. Cream. Ever. Legit pie shop, I can't wait until they're fully open and to try every flavor!!

you need to get there early to get what you want. I went there twice the week they opened and i had to settle for what wasn't on the top of my list the first time. lol. it was still good I've had the strawberry, coconut, i-40, buttermilk, and pecan. all pies were so good . i need to go back and eat more.....

I'm about to start eating their pies for breakfast, lunch, and dinner!! I ordered the banana cream pie and it did not disappoint!! The crust was perfect and flaky. The filling had just enough of a banana flavor and was super creamy! Loved the vanilla wafer and whipped cream on top. They had a sample of the I-40 pie and that was delicious as well, I'll most likely order that one next time! Don't let the word mini deceive you. My boyfriend and I shared a mini pie and that was more than enough! It didn't have an overwhelming sweet taste. You're able to taste all the flavors. The shop is small and cozy. There's little seating inside and a few chairs outside. Not really a place to meet some friends but I'm more than ok with that because their pies are AMAZING!!!! We were quickly greeted and asked if we needed any help. We went 30 minutes to closing and they still had a decent selection to choose from. We can't wait to try another soon!