Matilda B.
Yelp
Scrumptious!
Sadly, we learned that Chef Silvio Suppa passed away last year, but that was only AFTER we asked our waitress to compliment the chef on an OUTSTANDING meal!
After reading rave reviews, we decided to choose Cafe Allegre for a wedding rehearsal dinner. We chose the Toscana banquet menu ($38. per person plus gratuity):
Appetizers: Eggplant rollatini, pasta, clams casino and fried calamari
Salad: With house made dressing
Dinner: Chicken marsala, Chicken Fraincaise, Tilapia Aqua Pazza, Salmon Filet, Veal Parmigiana and Past Primavera (vegetarian)
Dessert: Chef's choice, coffee & tea & soft drinks
To our HAPPY surprise, every single bite was absolutely delicious! Everyone raved over the food and our family is usually a tough crowd to please. The eggplant rollatini melted in your mouth... the pasta sauce was the BEST we have ever had anywhere, and we have eaten in some prime Italian restaurants all over the country. The chicken francaise was buttery and lemony - not bitter at all. It was a song on the tongue!
Given a choice between house made lemon or chocolate cake for dessert, I asked for a 50/50 split of both and was very happy when they agreed. My goodness, that was The Best cake we have ever had (except for the red velvet cake at Julia's Bakery in Orange, CT). Cafe Allegre's cake was moist and flavorful, not a flavorless sugar-bomb like most others! You tasted cocoa & chocolate, not sugar! The lemon mousse was delicate and subtle, but the lemon peeked through after a moment in the most delightful way. Heavenly!
Our server Karen was extremely friendly, informative and attentive. Our glasses were never less than half full and plates were removed with expert timing. All guests were allowed to take home their uneaten portions and we were stunned when later, after our guests left and we settled the check, we were handed large bags filled with leftovers! Let me just say the leftovers we enjoyed for the next 3 days were just as delicious as they were during dinner that night. WOW!
We were treated like royalty, from the initial phone call with Jen to moment we left the restaurant that night with full bellies, a happy & satiated family and smiles on our faces. "Service" appears to be a lost art, but it's alive and well at Cafe Allegre!
The restaurant had two other wedding parties there that night and there wasn't an empty table in the house, but service did NOT suffer a bit! The decor is elegant and clean and reminds you of a fine inn. Even the entrance is grand with potted geraniums, ionic columns and baskets filled with gourds and farm fresh apples in the foyer.
Although it was sad to learn that chef Silvio passed away, we did learn that his son Roberto and daughter in law (who have been with him since he opened the iconic DelMonaco's in Wooster Square, New Haven) are carrying on the tradition of fine, award-winning food and service. We found it touching that Chef Silvio's cookbook was proudly on display inside the restaurant. His legacy lives on.
Cafe Allegre is Italian cuisine at it's finest.