Richard N.
Yelp
Great Food, Agreeable Service, Charming Atmosphere, But......
Pros: Adorable Look. Inventive Menu. Very Good Food.
Cons: Failure To Follow-Up With A Special Occasion
Star Ratings:
- Overall: 4
- Food Quality: 5
- Food Quantity: 5
- Menu: 5
- Service: 4
- Price: 4
- Value: 5
- Parking: 4
- Attention To Special Occasion: 1
With several big birthdays and anniversaries in our family coming up, we decided to get together for 5 days by Lake Tahoe. We drove from the San Luis Obispo area and the others came from Los Angeles. The main event was my wife's birthday. It was a milestone so dinner on that date was really important for our group of 5.
After reading lots of reviews for the best restaurant, we chose Cafe Fiore. I made reservations a week in advance and noted the birthdays and anniversaries...especially my wife's. When I called to confirm 2 days before, the young woman who answered said they indeed had those instructions.
Upon arriving, the gentleman host whispered the same information to our server........and that was the last mention of her milestone birthday by any employee at Cafe Fiore.
We didn't expect someone to jump out of a cake or light fireworks, but a simple acknowledgement would have been nice. A glass of champagne? A dessert? A few words? After all, we did spend $471 for 5 people.
So instead of adding another 5 star review to their log book, Cafe Fiore gets one with a mysterious title and a less-than-flattering explanation.
Here are the rest of my notes.
- Location: Convenient. About 6 or 7 blocks south of the lake. However, although the address is on Ski Run Boulevard, the sign, main entrance and parking lot are around the corner on Tamarack Ave.
- Appearance: Adorable. As others indicated, the interior is small but very attractive. We sat in the garden which can accommodate more tables than the building and is just as pleasant in its own way.
- Ambiance: Upscale yet cozy. Cafe Fiore reminded us of out-of-the way restaurants we found a few years ago while driving around the countryside in the Burgundy region of France. Lake Tahoe is much more of a tourist spot, but this place does have its charms.
- Menu: Eclectic and Inviting. Though the menu was not particularly long, all the items at Cafe Fiore were tempting...even for a group with 2 pescatarians/part-time vegetarians. If we didn't live 400-500 miles away by car, we could easily visit 2 or 3 more times and have our choice of great food.
- Food: Tasty. Cafe Fiore serves a basket of regular bread, but in addition we got some garlic bread ($8) for the table. A good choice...which we again ordered later in the meal. We also began by sharing Calamari ($17.95) which included the largest and some of the most tender pieces we've tried.
I ordered the Caprese Salad ($14) which might have been the best version I've had (see picture). I followed with the seafood special...Swordfish ($45)...accompanied by small portions of 4 or 5 really good vegetables. A top notch dish. I topped that off with a scoop of vanilla ice cream over several types of berries.
Other family members had Caprese Salad, Caesar Salad ($11.75 - very good), Eggplant Crepes ($17.95 - excellent), Fettucine Alla Calabrese "hold the butter" ($28.95 - good, but a bit bland), Linguine Fra Diavolo ($48.95 - mixed seafood with spicy marinara sauce - excellent with enough to take home ), Capellini Bocconcini ($32.95 - lightly breaded meatballs, tomato, basil, marinara over capellini - very good) and Aragosta Melodia ($46.95 - lobster and fettuccine - excellent). While I kept my dessert to myself, the others shared a specially prepared pear dish.
I had 2 glasses of the Ferrari Carrano Chardonnay ($20 each), my wife had 1 glass of the same and my stepson had 2 glasses of a cabernet which I forgot ($15 each). The wines were fine and it should be noted all glasses at Cafe Fiore are a full 8 ounces...not the skimpy 6 ounces found at many places for a similar price.
- Service: Very good. The "Gentleman Host" was cordial, but didn't crack a smile (unless I missed it) while introducing the restaurant and menu. Our server was consistently agreeable and reminded us of one from years back who frequently replied to our orders by saying "excellent choice". She kept a watchful eye on our table without being intrusive and had a pleasant way of going about her business.
- Price and Value: Reasonable. Cafe Fiore certainly isn't cheap, but you get your money's worth from the food, drinks and atmosphere. You may leave poorer, but not shortchanged.
- Parking: Sufficient. The lot in front of the restaurant on a side street got full, but it was a Saturday night in the middle of summer. There's also parking along Ski Run Blvd.
Would we return to Cafe Fiore? It depends on our expectations. For an inventive menu...good food and charming ambiance...yes. If we were promised a little extra attention due to a special occasion...maybe not.