Cafe Italia
Italian restaurant · Hunt's Point ·

Cafe Italia

Italian restaurant · Hunt's Point ·

Expertly crafted sandwiches, premium meats & cheeses, rich coffee

sandwiches
coffee
fresh ingredients
great food
good service
italian flavor
la madrina
authentic italian
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null
Cafe Italia by null

Information

500 Tiffany St, Bronx, NY 10474 Get directions

$10–20

Order delivery
See Menu
Restroom
Accepts reservations
Popular for lunch
Cozy
Family friendly

Information

Static Map

500 Tiffany St, Bronx, NY 10474 Get directions

+1 718 930 0053
cafeitaliabx.com
@cafeitaliabx
𝕏
@cafeitaliabx

$10–20 · Menu

Features

•Restroom
•Accepts reservations
•Popular for lunch
•Cozy
•Family friendly
•Good for solo dining
•Coffee
•Vegetarian options

Last updated

Dec 26, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2026 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater
391,575 Postcards · 10,993 Cities

Dive Bar Owner Works to Revive Nostalgic Italian Restaurant | Eater DC

"A 40-year-old neighborhood eatery known for its red-checked tablecloths and classic Italian dishes, Cafe Italia closed in April because it couldn’t keep up with rising rents; Freddie Lutz sealed the sale on May 21 and plans to renovate the aging space while maintaining the restaurant’s 'basic skeleton and soul,' and he’s bringing on longtime Cafe Italia vets Adolfo and Birtillo Urrutia (brothers who served there as a busboy and chef) to help reopen it as 'Freddie’s Italian Cafe,' though no reopening date has been announced." - Warren Rojas

https://dc.eater.com/2018/5/30/17411004/freddie-lutz-cafe-italia-revival-crystal-city
Cafe Italia

Patti M.

Google
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️A fresh food oasis in the middle of Hunts Point industrial area. Top notch espresso, and coffee service, ice cold beer, and full bar as well! I had the avocado toast with their all natural, made fresh daily watermelon slushy with no added sugar. They also have a coco piña version and people can add a shot of Henny for an all natural piña colada. In-house roasted peppers complete their pork sandwich and fresh bread every day from Madonia bakery so you know their sandwiches are off the charts. This place is a real gem, customer service is outstanding and the owner truly cares about the quality of the food being served. A lot of truckers stop in on their way in and out of the Hunt’s Point Market and also food industry executives know this is the go to place for breakfast or lunch in the area. They also cater! Highly recommend!

Kerry

Google
The most delicious sandwich you will ever have. The bread, meat and all ingredients so fresh and top quality. The way they put it together is magic! La Madrina so good.

M K.

Google
Great food great people just stopped around for mechanic work this gem was only one around

Madai V.

Google
I come here for the sandwiches and cappuccino. The cappuccino is delicious and comforting...makes you close your eyes and smile as you enjoy it. The sandwiches are delicious and there is a good variety too. You can also customize. The place is clean, has chill music, and the best staff. I like that there are tables to sit and enjoy your meal. I also like that they have freshly squeezed natural orange juice. It has authentic Italian ingredients and the Biscotti tastes like it was made by Nonna. Definitely recommend.

Emely P.

Google
Café Italia never disappoints! La Madrina is one of my favorite sandwiches - so flavorful and perfectly made. And their matcha? Absolutely perfect! Highly recommend!!!!

Emma C.

Google
The owner is outside. The food is soooooo amazing. I can’t even explain it. I travel from Staten Island just to have this delectable meal. Not only is the food amazing , but they serve with a smile. Can’t recommend enough

Janis D.

Google
The coffee is really good here!

steve 7

Google
Spotless place . The hero would of been great but they gave me really stale bread!!!!! What a shame. Was real hopeful for something good and to not have to drive to arthur ave
google avatar

Rhea A.

Yelp
Great fresh and authentic Italian flavor minus the trip to Arthur Ave. I was pleasantly surprised by the freshness and quality of the ingredients. Sandwiches are hand crafted and well prepared. The bread, cheese, and cold cut slices are as tasty as some of the more well known delis in Little Italy.

Steve H.

Yelp
Spotless place . Got the figo The hero would of been great but they gave me really stale bread!!!!! What a shame. Was real hopeful for something good and to not have to drive to arthur ave

Giustino D.

Yelp
Good food and good service. This is a hidden gem in this area. They also have coffee, fresh juices and smoothies.