Pablo C.
Yelp
As a Spaniard I had really high hopes for this restaurant. I understand, of course, that it might be hard for Spanish restaurants to get their hands on authentic ingredients, even here in NYC, so I have factored that into my rating. Also, if Yelp allowed half stars I wouldn't hesitate in giving it a 3.5. I suppose that it is also possible that if we had tried different things that the rating might be higher. On this occasion we tried the olives, the grilled sardines, the boquerones, the croquetas and the pan con tomate.
The olives were fine, although my wife thought they had too much vinegar. The real problem with the olives is that you pay $6.75 for maybe a dozen olives. I understand we're in Manhattan and that things get pricy here, but that price is a little steep, especially for a small, unassuming, quaint, family owned place like this. The grilled sardines were really good. They were cooked just like back in Spain. I only regret not ordering more of them (you get two per serving). The boquerones had some sort of weird, off-taste that I have never tasted before on boquerones. I've had boquerones all over Spain and we make them at home. They have always been marinated in olive oil with sliced garlic (sometimes onion also), and parsley. These were served with a sliced tomato for garnish together with lots of sliced onion. I'm not suggesting that there is only one way to prepare boquerones, but from Asturias to Alicante and Valencia to Cáceres, I have only ever tasted them the one way. If their method had tasted as good, even if it were different, I would be fine with it. But these just tasted off. I would not recommend them to anyone, particularly not anyone familiar with the way we've always experienced them everywhere else. The chicken croquetas were disappointing because they didn't seem, or taste, home-made at all. I have a very strong suspicion that they were pre-made frozen Goya brand or something similar to that. Either way, not authentic in the least. The pan con tomate, on the other hand, was also very good. Like I said, we only tried a small portion of what they offer. I would definitely come back to try other things and have more to base this on, I really want to love this place, but for now, these are my impressions.
The locale itself is great. The staff was very friendly and accommodating and the place itself has a very authentic feel to it. The bar was pretty quiet when we were there, but it seemed like a great place to watch Spain play in the World Cup or something. It's been around, family owned, since 1974 so I guess they must be doing something right.
The bottom line: This is a very authentic feeling, quaint, family owned restaurant. The limited food we sampled was ok but not very high on the authenticity scale. I'm not saying you shouldn't give this place a try, but you might want to manage your expectations if you have had authentic Spanish food.