Annabelle R.
Yelp
I was pleasantly surprised by my experience at Cafe Zoetrope. We came in around noontime on a Sunday to order a pizza to go, and all of the staff were helpful and welcoming from the moment we walked in. The restaurant, both inside and outside, had a lot of character, the walls decorated with beautiful and unique artwork all over, even a couple statues inside to add to the charm. My favorite feature is their Short Story Dispenser by Short Edition, where visitors can obtain a free random piece of literature with the click of a button (I wrote a whole separate Yelp review on this). There's also both indoor and outdoor seating available, a small bar inside, and so many wines on display.
We ordered the Pizza Funghi e Salsiccia, and I thought it was really good, flavorful toppings (italian sausage, mushrooms, and mozzarella), on a creamy white sauce, and a perfectly cooked crust (though the crust is more on the plain side). Size-wise, it's 12 inches in diameter.
I also tried the caesar salad, and I'm pretty sure it's the best I've ever had, anywhere. I finished every last bite. Fresh romaine mix, topped off with a couple anchovies on top, with a generous side of perfectly creamy and savory caesar dressing and crunchy lightly seasoned croutons. Soooo good! Apparently, a popular underground restaurant, Caesar's Grill, originated in the historic Sentinal building long before Cafe Zoetrope existed, and "claims to be the birthplace of the Caesar salad".
There's a lot to love about Cafe Zoetrope. With the excellent service and great environment, there's no question that I'll be back.