Paul M.
Yelp
Cafe Italia has a small storefront, right in the heart of Little Italy, and looks like a good place for coffee drinks and pastries. And, it certainly is. But, it is so much more. Who would guess that they have the best gelato around? Their selection is small, around 5 varieties, but the quality is amazing. I have had several flavors, but the spumoni is my favorite. And, I'm not usually a big fan of spumoni. This one, however, is so packed with ingredients, including chocolate chips. Just fantastic!!
Also, to my surprise, they have great salads. My go-to salad is the Fragola. It has arugula, strawberries, goat cheese, avocado and toasted almonds tossed in a very flavorful lemon vinaigrette. I always add chicken, and that is a big part of why I love this salad. Unlike the dry, bland, grilled chicken breasts that most restaurants put on their salads, the chicken at Cafe Italia looks and tastes like it was carved right off the bone. Delicious!!
The service during my visit today was very friendly, as always. Their staff have smiles on their faces and are very patient and accommodating when people, like my wife and I, struggle to choose what flavor of gelato to order. My only complaint is that it can take some time to get your food, especially during the lunch rush. But, it is well worth the wait.