Paul M.
Yelp
I go to Cafe Italia for the salad and the gelato. So, I feel good about myself and guilty at the same time. I love the Fragola Salad, adding chicken. The salad has strawberries, avocado, almonds and goat cheese, among other items. The flavors go together very well, but the chicken is the highlight for me. It is so much better than the typical chopped chicken breast you get at most restaurants. The problem (and the reason for only 4 stars) is that they are too often out of chicken. It is very frustrating to order this salad only to find out there is no chicken. I have tried to substitute turkey, but that doesn't even come close.
On to the gelato. I can only say it's the best I have had in San Diego. It comes from Gelato Vero Caffe and is so rich and creamy. The Spumoni is absolutely amazing, and I am not a huge Spumoni fan normally. It is just so much better than any Spumoni I have ever had. I abandon the Spumoni, though, when they have the Reese's Peanut Butter Cup gelato. And, who can blame me? It's the kind of dessert you dream about for days before and after. Unfortunately, they don't often have that flavor available.
But, when the chicken is available and I enjoy one of their great gelatos, a lunch at Cafe Italia is truly fantastic!!