Daniel B.
Yelp
Dinner here consisted of well prepared food and a warm atmosphere. In their quest for authenticity, they only serve Italian wine and spirits. You cannot order a vodka soda or a bourbon on the rocks. If you are not a fan of negronis or a bitter citrus version thereof, you risk dissapointment in the cocktail department here. I had the UPDP Negroni as recommended by Leslie Chesterman. It was bitter and very sweet, like most of the others I've had before. I'm sure they mixed it perfectly, it's just that this cocktail in general tastes like diabetes in a glass.
On to the food, we ordered a bunch of the small plates to share as well as the oysters. The oysters were a little on the small side, but tasted fresh and were served with two mignonettes (regular and spicy).
The burrata appetizer was also very nice. Served with a walnut pesto and some vegetables, it went really well with an order of their focaccia bread (for an extra charge). I was expecting a salty burst of basil, parmesan, and olive oil. Their take on pesto was a little muted. It's still a delicious dish. It's hard to be disappointed with fresh burrata cheese. Served as an appetizer, the dish is essentially a home run which is why nearly every Italian restaurant offers it. To this day however, I have never had a burrata or mozzarella appetizer as good as the one served at Da Emma (hockey puck sized lobes of salty and creamy cheese, gargantuan fresh beefsteak tomatoes, basil, oil) The ingredients are simple, but execution and quality go a long way.
Their Prosciutto di parma aged 18 months was very plain tasting. Served with some apple slices, I usually like a cured meat with a little more texture and concentrated flavour. The whole dish was very subtle. Nothing wrong with that if that's what people enjoy. No one went hungry, but my itch was not scratched here.
The winner of the night for me was the porchetta which was served with fresh mustard seeds and potatoes. It was crispy on the outside, tender on the inside and extremely moist. Just a comforting and wonderful dish.
I had a taste of my wife's gnocchi with crispy chicken skin and agreed with her that it was excellent albeit a tad bizarre as a concept. I also tasted our friend's veal carpaccio salad which again tasted very subtle and nice. Nothing revolutionary going on here. Desserts were tasty. We shared the chocolate cake and the olive oil cake. There is not much to say here; They are both simple and enjoyable slices of cake.
The waitress was exceptionally friendly and offered to open the window for us. For some reason, the ventilation was not working last week and the restaurant felt like it was about 25 or 26 degrees celsius. It's clear that a lot of money has been invested into this operation and that they want to swim amongst the big fish of the Montreal restaurant scene. I think that they can get there, but some tweaks are necessary to turn this establishment into a destination where people who just have to get their fix are clamouring for a table.