Edwin Neckman
Google
Dinner at Calusso – A Memorable Experience
My friends and I had an early dinner at Calusso last night, and from the moment we arrived, we were impressed. The restaurant is beautiful both inside and out, with valet parking available, and offers both indoor and outdoor seating. Reservations are definitely a must.
They provide both a prix fixe and à la carte menu, which is a nice touch. I started with a drink and asked for Moscato, but unfortunately, they didn’t have it. Our waitress, who was fantastic, quickly offered me samples of other wines until I found one I liked. That level of attentiveness carried through the entire evening.
For appetizers, I ordered the Caesar salad. While the presentation looked great, the flavor was lacking, missing that classic Parmesan punch and crunchy croutons, replaced instead with breadcrumbs and parsley. To my surprise, Chef Jonathan Kaiser personally came to the table, asked for feedback, and took it very graciously. I switched to the burrata, which was fresh, creamy, and beautifully presented. Then, Chef Kaiser returned with a brand-new Caesar salad, this time prepared in the traditional way. It was absolutely delicious and showed me how much he truly cares about his craft, an unexpected level of attention that really stood out.
For entrées:
One friend ordered the filet mignon, perfectly cooked, flavorful, and nicely presented.
Another had the Cacio e Pepe with Tellicherry peppercorn, Pecorino Romano, and black truffle, rich and delicious.
I ordered the Heritage Chicken with roasted maitake, charred onion, and truffle jus. The presentation was stunning, it looked like a mini beef Wellington, but it was chicken stuffed and rolled to perfection. Easily one of the best chicken dishes I’ve ever had.
Throughout the evening, small details elevated the service, like the giant pepper mill presented tableside. For dessert, the chef sent out complimentary sweets, and I ordered the Chocolate Café Crunch (hazelnut crumble, espresso crémeux, nocciola ice cream). It was plated beautifully and tasted just as good as it looked.
When we left, Chef Jonathan Kaiser was at the door, once again apologizing for the salad mishap and shaking our hands. That personal touch is rare and memorable.
The only small critique I have: the bread selection could be improved. The focaccia was nice, but the smaller breads were dense and not very enjoyable.
Overall, the combination of attentive service, a chef who genuinely cares, and beautifully crafted dishes makes Calusso a must-visit. We will absolutely return, especially for that Royal Heritage Chicken.