Rick Beyer
Google
We have eaten at a half dozen restaurants in the North End now, and Cantina Italiana is my favorite so far for the overall experience.
For starters, the food was good and did not seem like an American interpretation of Italian cuisine. I had the Gnocchi alla Norcina, which is by far the best gnocchi I have had outside of Italy. My gin martini was also delicious, and was delivered like all martinis should be: quickly.
For me, though, there were two other details that elevated Cantina Italiana above most of the other restaurants we've tried. First, the service was friendly and fast. We tend to eat unfashionable early these days, and that often helps us get a table, but here it was bustling and we got a table quickly anyway. Our server checked on us frequently.
Second, there was live music - in the form of an older gentleman walking around serenading diners on his accordion. It was lovely. He played just long enough to be romantic, but didn't overstay his welcome.
For my money, this is the place. The food is good, the service is great, and the atmosphere was perfetto.