Cape Cod Creamery

Cape Cod Creamery is the place to go for home made ice cream while on the cape. The building is very nice, there is parking in the back, and chairs and tables on the covered porch, on the side, and in front. The ice cream is absolutely delicious! My husband and I had Sandbar Swirl, vanilla ice cream with fudge and peanut butter cups. The ice cream was creamy and refreshing. We enjoyed sitting on the covered porch out of the sun because I didn't want to lose a drop of the creamy treat. Another evening our family purchased a few pints to go including more Sandbar Swirl, mint chocolate chip, and Almond Joy. All three flavors were a hit!

Cape Cod Creamery is a must-stop if you’re in the area! The ice cream is incredibly creamy and flavorful, with fun Cape-inspired names like “Monomoy Mud Pie” and “Pleasant-Bay Peanut Butter.” The variety is impressive, and you can see all the flavors beautifully displayed inside the case. We loved how many unique combinations they offered, and everything tasted homemade and fresh. When we arrived, there was no line, which was perfect for our group. But by the time we sat down with our ice cream, a line had already started forming—clearly a local favorite! I ordered a large dish with 3 scoops, and it was more than enough to satisfy my sweet tooth. My son went with a waffle cone filled with Oreo ice cream. The only bummer was the cone had a large hole in the bottom, and the ice cream started dripping pretty fast. We could have asked for a bowl, but he decided to tackle it as a challenge—and finished it like a champ, eating from both ends! 😄

Delicious ice cream and friendly service. The waffle cone holds all the ice cream of a regular as it melts. Thumbs up!

Atmosphere great. Flavors great. Staff horrible. No cheer, smiles, or happiness whatsoever! Seemed like a combo of bored, ambivalent, and maybe even angry? There wasn't a huge crowd, so it didn't seem like fatigue. The customers in front of us came in cheerfully celebrating their birthday, and the staff sneered at her when she mentioned it - literally looked at her like, "good for you who gives a crap." Part of the fun of getting ice cream is a smiling staff happy to dole out scoops of tasty treats. This was "Frappes with a Frown". That being said, I'd go back to a different location - the ice cream was great!

Good quality, homemade ice cream. There is a good variety of flavors. This ice cream is aerated heavily which makes a lightly flavored and easy to scoop ice cream, you can justify eating more because the milk-fat is much less than the richer ice cream that you may get elsewhere. I am not implying that this ice cream is better or worse than the competition, it is for days when you want their type of ice cream, just like sometimes you may choose soft-serve or gelato for different experiences.

Lots of outdoor seating on the lawn and porch at this location of Cape Cod Creamery. The house made ice cream cones (regular size) looked delicious but disappointed; the bottom of the cones were burnt and all three bottoms were tossed. The small cone was good from top to bottom. One order was also messed up (the requested Craigville Caramel Crunch became something with butterscotch). The pecans in the Truro Turtle were a bit stale. But overall, we liked it.

After a long day flying in from Grand Rapids. The 8 of us decided we wanted ice cream. The creamery was easy walking distance from our vrbo. Headed over around 9pm and was surprised to find it packed. Large selection of flavors and options. Reasonably priced for a tourist area. Ice cream was delicious. Plenty of outdoor seating. Only strange thing that I've never seen before, was the ice cream melted so fast after being served. It was still very tasty you just had to eat it quickly or throw it back in the freezer, which we all did when we got back to the house.

The ice cream was good and there was plenty of options and seating. I wished there were a few non dairy options, but it was good all the same.