Carissa's the Bakery - Sag Harbor

Delicious pastries, delightful cookies and the coffee was equally delicious. Friendly and highly efficient customer service. Highly recommended!

The coffee was good, but the salmon sandwich was dry, as if it had been made yesterday. I didn't get the croissant, though. Why is there chocolate inside if it's a pistachio one?

Wowwww this place is great! Even though it was crowded and hectic, the staff were very attentive and personable. She helped me pick out some bakery items and checked me out quickly. I got 3 tarts for $25. Also got the cucumber gazpacho soup and sandwich. They were pretty good. I ate one of the tarts in the car and a lady outside gasps, points at it and says OH MY GODD THAT LOOKS SO GOOD I WANT IT Which i thought was really funny. Will definitely be coming back to check out your other dessert items! When i came, they only had almond croissant but i’m hoping next time they’ll have other croissant flavors

This place doesn't stand up to Bagel Buoy. The raw NY atmosphere that use to envelop you whenever entering the building. Now replaced with drab, minimalist mediocrity and from what I can tell, pre-made/frozen "food" 0 stars aren't an option but it should be.

No wonder this place is pretty famous…esp being an Ina Garten fave! Place is gorgeous / feels like a cafe in Paris. Breads, pastries coffee and the service - all terrific! We had the apple turnover / croissant & chocolate croissant and lattes.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Carissa’s in Sag Harbor is a sensory delight—where thoughtful design meets exceptional flavor. Every visit feels like a breath of fresh air, with beautifully baked goods, seasonal offerings, and a serene atmosphere that captures the essence of Hamptons living. As a local real estate professional, I often recommend Carissa’s to clients looking to get a true taste of the area. Whether picking up pastries for an open house or enjoying a quiet moment between appointments, it’s a go-to spot that never disappoints. Elegant, intentional, and delicious—Carissa’s is a gem in the heart of Sag Harbor. — Cassandra Leggio, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson Curating Legacy, Refining Worlds

Just delightful! Excellent pastries, nice staff, phenomenal attention to detail, decent selection A little pricey but it's Sag Harbor so what do you expect.

i’ve never been dismissed by not one, but two people behind the counter of a food and beverage establishment. the older couple behind the counter this morning both, independently of one another asked me to move the line along with the woman rudely saying “i’m gonna move you down the road!” before i even ordered. needless to say i left before actually trying anything, so i can’t speak to the quality of their pastry, but most likely we’d never go back again. they desperately need to work on their customer service skills.