Claudia B.
Yelp
After quietly mourning the loss for the past two years of Carlitos Cafe's sister restaurant in Montecito, CAVA, we fiiiiinally made our way to Carlitos Cafe to see if we could resurrect the same great food since they are owned by the same person/company. Let me just say that CAVA was our absolute favorite Mexican restaurant ANYWHERE, and we would travel from Los Angeles up to Montecito frequently to eat there. When we learned of their closing about two years ago, we never got over the loss. I'm not kidding. It was bad, and we still don't understand why it closed. Anyway, I found out the owner of CAVA maintained his OTHER restaurant, Carlitos Cafe, so we decided to give them a try. It just took us two years to do it.
So the bottom line is that it was really good. Perfect like CAVA? No... but it was pretty darn good. My husband and I decided we'd definitely return because there was a lot that we really liked. The chips, salsa and guac were right on par with CAVA. The salsa had great flavor and was ultra thick... just how we like it. The guac was fresh and flavorful and again, just how I like it. (Hubby doesn't like guac.) Great start. BUT.... the entrees, which were the mariscos enchiladas for both of us, were not on par. They were good, but they were definitely missing something in the spices. I'm not exactly sure what it was, but it was not what I remembered. They were packed full of shrimp and scallops just like I remember, but something was not quite right with the flavors. My husband said the same thing, soooooo I don't know. It wasn't bad; it just wasn't amazing, knock our socks off great.
As an aside, they have a lovely patio area for dining outdoors. The restaurant itself is on the smallish side, but still attractive, and at least when we went on a Saturday for lunch, we had an easy time choosing if we wanted to dine indoors or out.
The next time we return, and we will... we won't be ordering the mariscos enchiladas as our entree. We'll definitely try something else, but at least we found a suitable alternative to our Mexican food cravings in Santa Barbara. And yes, I still wish CAVA didn't close.