Carmelo Greco

Great ambience and super tasty unique food. Staff is friendly and prices are right for a Michelin star restaurant. Suited for a special occasion. Happy to return.

The food was good (portions and presentation were good but the taste was just ok, nothing special), service was ok, but the atmosphere was terrible. One pays not only for the food when going to a Michelin Star restaurant (+€500). Very disappointed that the atmosphere looked more like a cheap pub than a restaurant. Quite noisy with diners who shouted and laughed so loudly that they prevented us at our table from talking. We told the service staff but they only offered us a table that was also very close to this noisy group. It's a shame that I couldn't enjoy my dinner and birthday celebration. In addition, the risotto was salty and the broccoli was quite oily. I won't go back to this restaurant and I don't think it really deserves a star. They are not quite there yet.

The restaurant was beautiful but the most amazing part about it was its staff, the people who are working there have indeed been working really hard & they put their heart & soul to the work that they do

The food here was excelent and filling. Given the price the dishes were well balanced and the right portion and the wine was very good. Overall this is one of the best culinary experiences. Totally recommend.

We had a great dinner in the restaurant terrace overlooking the “woods” in this very attentive and quiet restaurant 12 minutes by car from the Frankfurt Airport. The reception and service was outstanding. The wine list short but well cured. As for the food, the starters where very good and the main course and the dessert where excellent! The weakest part of the menu was unfortunately the pasta, although well presented it lacked some flavor. Overall a magnificent experience, and will definitely be back!

Compared to other Michelin restaurants that I tried, Carmelo was less experimental and more traditional (Italian), but this doesn’t make it worse. Everything was good, but the fillet was extraordinary

Eating at Carmelo's is an amazing experience. It is like visiting a museum and you can eat the art. Everything is well composed, looks amazing and tastes delicious. The Staff is also very attentive and friendly. In contrast to other critics say, I don't think it is overpriced. But very worth it!

Carmelo Greco, Frankfurt/M. » My (last) visit: June 2023 » Total score: 4.2/5 » In a nutshell: I would say that the gourmet restaurant met my high expectations quite well. ===== My ratings for this gourmet restaurant in detail: ●● Service: • Hospitality, friendliness, obligingness, etc.: 4.7/5 • Mood/atmosphere, etc.: 4.7/5 ●● Food: • Flavors (range, depth, composition, harmony/balance, etc.): 4.5/5 • Level (thoroughness, craftsmanship, exclusivity, variety of impressions, consistency/diversity of styles, etc.): 4.5/5 • Choices: 4.8/5 ●● Beverages, mainly the wines: • Taste (depth/range, length, complexity, balance, accessibility, elegance, intensity/subtlety, etc.): 4.5/5 • Level (variety/novelty of impressions, consistency/diversity of styles, exclusivity, etc.): 4.4/5 • Did the beverages (mainly wines) match the dishes?: 4.4/5 • Choices: 3.4/5 ●● Presentation of the food: • Textures and (differences in) temperatures: 3.4/5 • Colors and decorations: 3.5/5 • Timing and sequencing as well as sizes of portions: 3.8/5 • Special effects (positionings, DIY-effects, sculptural or thematic elements, surprises, color and motion effects, fake effects, olfactory effects, fog or smoke effects, etc.): 4.5/5 • Procedures at and around the table (attunements and explanations, elements added/changed, service and staffing intensity, involvement of kitchen team, orchestrated dish presentations, preparations and dishes (partially) built up at the table, etc.): 3.9/5 ●● Presentation of beverages, mainly the wines: • Explanations and attunements: 4.7/5 • Quantities poured as well as timing in relation to the dishes: 4.6/5 ●● Premises and location: • Accessibility, surroundings and - as applicable - the view: 3.2/5 • How did I like the room or - as applicable - outdoor area’s style, decor and atmosphere?: 3.9/5 • Well-being (space, privacy, temperature, ventilation, odors, lighting, noise, sanitary facilities, etc.): 4.0/5 ●● Price: • Price-performance ratio for food: 4.2/5 • Price-performance ratio for wines and other beverages: 2.5/5 • Transparency (online price information when booking the table, price information for food/wine in the menu, correspondence of the expected to the actual price): 2.7/5