Casa Nostra

La Casa Nostra is the crown jewel! Our meals were exceptionally good, with generous portions. The birthday boy and I raved over the freshness of every part of our meal, and his birthday gelato was the finest we’ve ever tasted. The atmosphere was warm and cozy. Noise? Nope! The staff was friendly, knowledgeable, quick, and accommodating. We’ve dined in many fine restaurants in Marlton, Cherry Hill, Bordentown, Lamberville, New Hope, Princeton, Haddonfield, Lake Placid…and can say with confidence that the La Casa Nostra fully fits its name: “Our Home.” It is clear to us that the owner William cares deeply about providing a superior dining experience. We highly recommend La Casa Nostra. Robert & Christine

What a fantastic experience! Casa Nostra is an absolute gem. The food was incredible, and the service was top-notch. We started with the fried calamari, which was perfectly crispy and flavorful. The linguine frutti di mare was another standout—packed with fresh seafood and cooked to perfection. A special shoutout to William, the owner, who went above and beyond to make us feel welcomed and ensure our evening was memorable. His personal touch made all the difference. I highly recommend Casa Nostra for an unforgettable dining experience. Whether you’re a local or visiting, this restaurant is a must-try!

Very good Italian restaurant and pizzaria. Great selection of appetizers, sandwiches, pizzas, pastas. There is something for everyone. The red and white pie is delicious. Great wings. The lasagna is delicious. Fast friendly service when eating there. Indoor and outdoor seating. Delivery is also usually fast.

A nice white tablecloth dining experience here. We arrived close to closing and they accommodated us and did not at all make us feel rushed. Everything we tried was yummy - the camera did not eat first on the pizza (sorry yall) but the short rib pizza with balsamic glaze was unique and deliciously executed. I did a mix and match on my pasta kind of combining the Cacchiatore (minus olives and minus the tangy tomato sauce) with the Parmigiana Cheese Cream Sauce from the gnocchi- and tbh they should add it to the menu and call it "The Mandee" bc it knocked my socks off! Give this place some love and try it out :)

Excellent food. Even better service. They were busy but the little wait was well worth it. The chef is putting out food that you would expect at a high end restaurant. Everything from the appetizer to the desert was amazing. We will defiantly be back as this it’s a hidden gem in the area.

Great atmosphere and a wide variety of delicious Italian food. Service was excellent, can't wait to go back. One of the rare places that makes cacio e pepe (yum.)

Great food, very friendly staff and owner. I have lived here Marlton for most my life. There are only a few places I would rate top tier for pizzas, steak sandwichs. I have a severe food allergies to milk products, I ordered a pizza without any cheese and extra sauce. They were extra careful with my order, even going as far cleaning the pizza cutter without me having to ask.

Our food was delicious as always. We have dined here many times in the past. However, we were very disappointed with our server tonight. He was very abrupt and seemed to want to hurry us along. There were plenty of empty tables and no customers were waiting and he was not busy. He never came to our table to ask if everything was okay and if we needed anything. At the end of my meal, I asked for a box for the remainder of my food (which he did bring). My husband and I were just sitting for a few minutes talking, letting our food digest. The waiter came by, pointed to my take-home container, motioned for me to put my leftovers in and basically for us to move on and get out. Again, as I said, there was no one waiting for the table and plenty of empty ones. The waiter we had could use some training in servicing the public and hopefully attain some better people skills. As always, we left a good tip.

Our favorite Italian restaurant in the Marlton area. Whether it's pizza to go, or dining in, it can't be beat. Delicious food and the friendliest staff. Some of the best pizza I've ever had; I'd say a 9.3 on the Portnoy Scale. The crust is amazing; airy yet crisp, almost like a focaccia meets a pizza dough. The pizza sauce is phenomenal, the freshest and tastiest I've ever had. As for dine-in fare, I'd have to recommend their calamari for appetizers; fresh and crisp, served with their tasty marinara and a sweet pepper relish (if you're afraid to order calamari at restaurants because you're afraid it's pre-packaged generic frozen kind, worry not, this is the REAL DEAL!) I'd also recommend their crab soup, it's absolutely delicious, you will not be disappointed. And last but not least, for an entree it has to be the aracino pasta dish; ravioli in a brandy cream sauce with crab meat. I get it every time, it's just lick your plate delicious.

Cosa Nostra delivers again as usual The variety on this menu is unreal, from the appetizers (langoustine, calamari in saffron broth, burrata and prosciutto) to the entrees (steak and pasta dishes, I got the gnocchi with pork ragu) to the desert. This place is hands down best in the area. Portions are great size, prices are very fair and staff is friendly and hands on. Also a BYOB which is bonus If you haven't been here yet then you need to get moving

Great food, cool atmosphere, good value. Recommend getting a reservation Yummy Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm Mmmmmmmmm

The service was a bit slow as it looked like they only had 1 server so she didn't come over for about 15 minutes after we were seated which was fine since I couldn't find a menu online to check ahead of time. They had a pineapple burrata appetizer special which was something I haven't seen before so that immediately caught my attention. It was a decent size and ate like a salad for my husband and I to share. We got the bubble bread for an appetizer too since we've never had it before. For my entree, I decided on the Chicken Frangelica which gave a sweet and savory flavor. My husband had the butter fish which was tasty. Give them a try if you're in the area. The decor inside was nice and they have an outdoor seating area.

Holy crap - my bestie lives minutes from here. Since we are watching ourselves, we only ordered salads, but oh what salads they were!!! I had an incredible Caesar salad with added (succulent) shrimp and avocado. Homemade dressing and fresh croutons. My girl had an avocado salad that she adored as well! We were drooling over other Yelpers photos and are definitely going again but in the daytime when we can truly indulge (pasta dishes and bread!) CAN'T WAIT !!!

It was surprisingly easy to get a table on a Saturday night, but they seemed quite busy. The food on the menu looked great as did the decor of the restaurant. Unfortunately, that's where the good ended. We waited about 20 to 25 minutes after being seated by the host but no luck getting any service from the wait staff. Obviously, that is way too long of a wait, and it's only worse with two young children. The restaurant was filling up, so we got up and told the host we were giving up our table and we left. If we go back and are able to get service, I will certainly update the review.

We had dinner there 11 guys on our trimonthly get together Good and service excellent Homemade Cavatelli and shrimp dish was a great surprise to my plate. App where way above par (try old school meatballs yum yum) not one of our 11 gentleman had a negative cooment and that is a big win seeing the youngest guy is50! Will do it again The Gym

We dined here based on a recommendation on a good lBYOB in the area. Walking in, I immediately liked it. The places was packed. Server was super friendly and acknowledged us immediately. Food presentation not only looked good, it was delicious. Intend on returning again soon!

We like their food, but I ordered online and they automatically added a 20% tip to my order. I wanted to tip cash and had originally made the correction but needed to change something on the order. When I went back to make the change, the site automatically processed the 20% tip and I didn't know until completed the order and saw the updated cost. Tips should not be automatically added, and their lower rate was 17, but that wasn't the default.

Very good Italian restaurant and pizzaria. Great selection of appetizers, sandwiches, pizzas, pastas. There is something for everyone. The red and white pie is delicious. Great wings. The lasagna is delicious. Fast friendly service when eating there. Indoor and outdoor seating. Delivery is also usually fast.

Food was very good but the manager or owner, not sure which, was extremely rude and unprofessional

A great place for a great meal. The food is outstanding and the service is great. From the delicious brick oven pizza to the wonderful homemade Italian dinners, everything was sensational.

Good Italian food in a pleasant environment. Plenty of parking. Clean restrooms. Service was slow from start to finish. It took too long to take our order. The last meal for our party arrived a full ten minutes after the first. We had to ask the bus boy to clear the table and waited another 15 minutes for a check. As far as I could tell there was one waiter for the entire restaurant. They had a solo singer. While I understand the desire to attract people on slow weeknights, a restaurant is not a cocktail lounge. People go to eat, not to listen to music loud enough to impede their conversation. It was made worse when the singer strolled the room, like a bad mariachi band, and reached its nadir with Sweet Caroline. A restaurant is not the 7th inning stretch at Fenway. Lose the singer. Gains some waiters.

We order take out from here all the time as it's close to home- but we finally sat and had dinner with 7 friends Sunday night and I have to say all of us loved our dinners! It's a great little place in a strip mall! They do have outdoor seating also which we didn't do , nothing fancy but the inside is nice and I understand they have a singer on Wednesday nights-so will check that out! The pizza there is also terrific- we ordered from There again last night and have highly recommend the Red and White pizza! We had a great waiter named Juan Sunday night who had two big tables but we never lacked for anything- no bar BYOB- do check it out!

This classic neighborhood restaurant is a true gem. Absolutely delicious food prepared perfectly. They accomodate all requests and have great flavoring, and beautiful presentation of dinners. I really love that it is 10 minutes from home. Every bit or better than Collingswood faves and much closer to home.Will be celebrating my husbands 70th there next week! Great selection of Italian faves, including Southern & Northern specialties. Veal is cooked perfectly, thin and tender. Chicken is tender and very tasty. Pasta is cooked al dente.Reservations recommended for evenings but not mandated. We especially love the musical presentations with our fav opera singer!

4 of us had dinner here on a recent Saturday evening. Though they had a full house, we never felt rushed and the service was impeccable. Appetizers, main courses, and desserts were amazing. This was a great find.

First time trying this restaurant based on a friend's recommendation. We were not disappointed. Four of us went and all ordered different entrées. All of us thought it was delicious. Our waiter's knowledge of the menu was very impressive and the service was impeccable. We'll definitely be back.

Excellent food and very friendly service. It has become a "regular " for us. I would encourage anyone who lives in the Medford and Evesham area to try this restaurant.

Review is not on the food--it is on the takeout service. Counter person was most unfriendly, and quite frankly, rude! I felt like I was bothering him to place the order. In the meantime, someone walked in to pick up his order and obviously they knew each other. The problem...they chatted for approximately 8 minutes, and early on in their conversation, my order was placed on the counter. I was handed my order ONCE THEIR CONVERSATION ENDED. My first and last time ordering from Casa Nostra!

Not advertised and not cool that 4% is added to your total for paying by credit card. Prolly a sun big enough to mKe me choose one of the endless other options to get fee-free pizza. Pizza here is decent but would be better if they use a better quality cheese. Not a very friendly guy behind the counter. Kinda mean actually. Ambiance is what you'd expect.

Amazing Food and Service! So happy to have found this place. Everything from the thin crust pizza to the jumbo shrimp Parmesan & Caesar salad. We have been frequenting this restaurant and we find that everything that we try is just as good as the previous time.

We had a delicious dinner there! The service was wonderful and the ambiance was very nice. We will definitely go back.

I went there for dinner with friends. I wasn't very hungry, so I decided to just order an appetizer which was $15 on the menu. The place is lovely, most of my companions said their dinners were very good. They had a singer who was wonderful & engaged the entire restaurant in joining him with the singing. We were a large party & the service was very good. I couldn't wait to tell my friends what a great place this was & recommend they go there. The problem was, when the server gave me my check, it was for $20. I thought he made a mistake so I brought it to his attention. I was told it wasn't a mistake, if you only order an appetizer, they charge $20 no matter how much the appetizer is on the menu. Can you explain to me the logic in this?? I was livid & told the waiter I'll never go there again. Of course, one person not returning isn't a big deal, but I've told every one I've spoken to about this & they all said they'll never go there. I want everyone to know how unfair they are at this restaurant!

Pizza tasted okay but $19 for a 11.5 inch pizza is rediculous. It was supposed to be a large pizza but ive neve seen a large pizza this small before. 6 small slices was all we had. My son ate 1/3 of the pizza before I could stop him on the ride home. I will never go there again. There are so many other places in the area that are so much better and cheaper. At least those places you can make a meal for 3 people from a medium or large pizza.

Tried two different specials. The chicken Jerusalem and veal special. The veal was outstanding the mozzarella on top amazing. The chicken with the tortellini amazing. We will be back!

I always got a good dinner, Sub, cheesesteak and I think it has that best tasting pizza in Burlington county the crust and the sauce and the cheese all come together in a memorable pizza. I think the secret is in the sauce. Another thing that gives us a high rating is the people making the food have an Italian accent and you can't get it any better than that... Arrivederci

Hidden Jem. In a small offbeat shopping strip with not many stores . Great food and service. Best chicken parm I've had in a while. Definitely will be back

I have ordered from there and it was good , today I ordered 2 pizzas edges burnt and no signs of cheese lots of watery sauce . Did they change owners?

Always delicious! Service is friendly. I've tried several dishes and can't wait to sample more.

The place is adorable and the food is ok! The but when it comes to cleanliness in the kitchen that is a huge problem! There is black mold on dust on the ceilings with fans blowing at high speed! No one in the kitchen Preparing the food wears gloves! Meat and fish are not kept at proper temperatures. It is absolutely insane to have walked through this kitchen To have seen the "owner" sweating and smoking a cigarette while preparing food ! I was there interviewing for a position and I walked out! There was no possible way I could be part of this horrible mess.

Went on a friends recommendation, and we were delighted. It's such a pretty and warm place to sit back and enjoy a meal. The food was incredible. Everything was done to perfection, and they had many choices. We left, taking home enough food for another meal - really generous portions! The service was superb, and they truly knew how to make us comfortable and special. Can't wait to go back, which will be very soon!

Ordered a Cheesesteak Hoagie to go - came with no cheese (although I requested provolone), no lettuce or tomatoes. However, since I paid with a credit card, I received a receipt. It clearly states Cheesesteak and was charged extra for lettuce and tomatoes. My question is how can you read an order and completely omit the cheese, lettuce and tomatoes that you are being charged for? The cost was $14.00! Plus I left a tip. What gives? Needless to say, I will not be back because they can't even read a very simple order!

Hands down the BEST pizza I have ever had. I order from here frequently for this godsent pizza. I'ts just different from other places ya' know? The dough under the sauce has a nice soft crunch to it and the crust at the end is the same way minus the sauce. If you live around the area and have tried UpperCrust Pizza, then I would give this place a go. I find that it's similar but more perfected. A large plain pie will cost you about $14 and change, plus a tip if you go that route. I would say its adequate size but don't expect that large to feed any more than say 3 people who each eat roughly 2 slices. Worth a try, i've been trying to convert all my friends to this place with success.

My oh my what a pie! The crust, cheese, and sauce are perfect. This is hands down, the best pizza in Marlton and might be the best pizza in south jersey. I'm so lucky this place is around the corner from me and will easily be my go to pizza place from now on.

Food is way overpriced and not that great. 40 dollars for a small pizza and garden salad. Really?

Party of 8 for lunch, while there was another party of 20. While the main meals came out at different times, we understood that would happen, and everyone's food was perfect, and tasty. We had plenty of appetizers, breads, and salad, and no glass was ever empty. The service staff was excellent in taking care of us, and very personable. Definitely recommend.

Just bought a property in the area and heard about Casa Nostra so wanted to give it a try. stopped in on a Tuesday night with a party of 5 adults. We enjoyed appetizers of fried calamari, jumbo shrimp/cherry tomatoes/peppers in a delectable garlic and wine sauce. Also finished the apps with the sausage/spinach and cannelloni beans. Apps were enjoyed by all. Not one negative comment. Then all of the party had the house salad. Again very nice house dressing. We then all had different entrees. I enjoyed the plentiful chicken Marsala over capellini and the wife had a chicken in lemon sauce again over pasta. Others in the party had different dishes such as chicken fra diavolo chicken Fantasia and the final one a gnocchi that was to die for in a Parmesan cream sauce. I put this experience right up there with some of my favorite Italian joints all over. Service was great. Food served hot. Will be back soon.

This place is a gem. The best Italian food by far in the area. We had the chicken parm as well as the eggplant parm, both were excellent. Fresh ingredients and authentic sauce! The fried mozzeralla appetizer was delicious. The waiter was friendly and efficient. The prices are reasonable and it's a BYOB. This is our "go to" Italian from now on.

The food is absolutely delicious. It was piping hot from beginning to end. The servers were friendly. William the chef came out and spoke with us. I have already made plans with our group to return the next time we're in town. I'm going to dream about this food.

I have driven pass this place many times and really did not know the name until I parked almost in front of the joint. The restaurant is modern, clean, and cool with a friendly staff. Dine inside or out your choice, also BYOB place. Jaun our waiter help us out with the menu, also explained all the specials in detail and did not rush our orders. Appetizer which we ordered was calamari tubes only came with a warm marinara sauce and some type of a sweet red pepper sauce with was outstanding. Meal came with house salad very colorful with a taste house dressing. Entrees were cheese ravioli with shrimp in a creamy sauce. Also ordered the special of Swordfish with eggplant, provolone cheese, roasted tomato, something that I never had caper berries in a light sauce, swordfish was a good size eggplant, tomato, and cheese on both ends and big enough to split. I could only eat about 25 percent of this dish. I was also checking out the wood cooked or wood fired oven pizza that is only served in the restaurant area on Friday and Saturday evenings. I think you have to be sitting in the dining area for the wood fired pizza, pretty good choices to choose from, heading back very soon.

The Carne pizza was amazing. The sauce was deep and rustic vs sweet/fruity. The meatballs were extremely soft and flavorful, must be pork! The onions were caramelized and a sweet crunch to balance the profiles. Amazingly surprising treat after the pizza craving hit. We'll definitely be ordering again. Thanks CN Team!

Wonderful service was great. Food was wonderful. I would recommend this restaurant for a special holiday or birthday occasion.

Very disappointed. My husband and I have been there several times and we've gotten take out as well. A friend and myself decided to have a pizza after a long week of work, she was here from California. It was busy, which is always a good thing, and I can see they were short handed, but we were hungry, and knew it would be worth a few extra minutes. We were seated and forgotten. After several attempts to get someone's attention for 20 minutes, we left. I understand the worker shortage, but several parties that were seated after us, had their orders promptly taken. The one kid that was there was running around picking up empty glasses and bringing bread to 3 other tables that were seated well after us, we didn't even get bread, all we got was water, and the older person in the shirt and tie, I assume was the manager, was talking to the people waiting at the door who were waiting to be seated, laughing and chatting with all the other customers, everything but take our order. Like I said, I understand being short staffed, but that was an awful experience and we won't be back, at least not until you have enough people to serve everyone. Maybe because it was just 2 of us, and not a large group where a larger tip is involved. You both looked right at us several times while walking by, then kept going. We went down the road to Montesini's, and had a great pizza and salads. And, I did send a message to them-they didn't even bother to respond.

We had lunch Saturday and we were very happy. I heard it was good but I always wait for them to slip up and start sucking but that didn't happen. The place wasn't busy but they still had good service. We had really good bread for the table, chicken Milanese ( the chicken was slightly greasy from just being cooked) and the salad part of it was really good. The meatballs for an appetizer were delicious and we also had chicken parm which was also really good.

I had a couple of very bad experiences here a couple of years ago with one of the owners. I don't know why he acted the way he did, the past is the past. Sometimes people have things they are going through and it has nothing to do with you so you should not take it personal. The food is great. The older gentleman owner is sweet. The server is wonderful. Their meatballs are the best in the area. This place is down the street from my home.

Sorry. We Iive in the area and decided to try Casa Nostra after recommendations from our friends. My husband ordered the pasta Fagioli soup and fried calamari (2 apps), enough for dinner. I ordered spaghetti and meatballs. The server told us there is a $15 sharing charge and because I ordered an entree for $20 there would be an additional $15 added to our bill. The sharing charge is listed on the menu. I could understand it if we only ordered one dish. We left the restaurant. This is bad business practice. Sorry, we won't be back. You lost what could have been good customers.

Lived around the corner from this place for 10 years first time I tried their food very good will definitely be going back. Give it a try if you haven't.

I have had their eggpalnt rollatini and different sandwiches. Food is excellent and their service was superb. The staff even brought us warm milk upon request for coffee. Would highly recommend this restaurant.

We had my son's Confirmation dinner after mass and the food was amazing. From the appetizers to the desserts and everything in between was delicious. Service was fantastic!! William and Giovanni know how to take care of their customers. The prices were so reasonable for the amount of food we received and the quality. Highly recommend eating in or doing take out. Panini sandwiches are also delicious!!! Great food, great night, and amazing memory which is what we needed during this difficult time.